Novel Objective Comparison of Short-term Surgical Outcomes From Total Mesorectal Excision Between Total Neoadjuvant Therapy - Rapido Protocol, Standard Long Course Radiotherapy and Upfront Surgery

A review of prospectively collected data was performed for all patients who were diagnosed with rectal cancer and who underwent ultra-low anterior resection (ULAR) from January 2016 to May 2022 in a single institution in Singapore. Exclusion criteria of this study included patients who underwent emergency surgery and patients with unresectable metastatic disease at presentation. All patients were discussed at multi-disciplinary tumour board for recommendation and decision of the respective treatment protocols. Patients were analysed in 3 main categories: neoadjuvant therapy per RAPIDO protocol, LCRT and upfront surgery. Patients under RAPIDO group underwent 25Gy/5 sessions of short course radiotherapy followed by 6 cycles of neoadjuvant XELOX similar to that of the RAPIDO trial protocol while patients in LCRT group underwent conventional 50Gy/25-28 sessions of long course radiotherapy with concurrent oral capecitabine. All cases were performed by 7 consultant-grade colorectal surgeons in the department.

Patient demographics and peri-operative details were collected. Histopathological stage of disease was in accordance with the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) staging manual after surgical resection with review of the resected specimen by consultant-grade pathologists who were blinded to the type of pre-operative treatment the patients received.

Primary outcome for the study was the operative time required for primary resection of rectal tumour. If combined surgery was performed for oligometastatic disease, we removed the operating time for non-rectal component as this was separately defined in the operation notes.

Secondary outcomes included the intraoperative blood loss, duration to stoma function, failure to remove urinary catheter, presence of post-operative ileus, duration of hospitalisation after surgery. Presence of stoma function was defined as enteric content of significant amount (>200ml or presence of formed faecal material). Failure of removal of urinary catheter is defined as acute urinary retention requiring re-insertion of catheter post-operatively. Post-operative ileus is defined as ileus which persist beyond 7 days from operation.

Follow-up outcomes and data for patients were collected until 31 May 2022. Local-regional recurrence was defined as the first clinical, radiologic and/or pathologic evident tumour of the same histological type at the region of the anastomosis and pelvis. Distant recurrent was defined similarly at sites outside primary malignancy such as liver, lung, bone, brain, para-aortic region. Presence of recurrence in patients was recorded, disease-free interval was calculated in months from date of surgery to date of recurrence.