Comparison of the Efficiency of Anesthetic Depth Control Using Closed Loop Anesthesia Delivery System vs. Manual Control Using Target Controlled Infusion in Patients With Moderate to Severe Left Ventricular Systolic Dysfunction
试验速览
- 阶段
- 不适用
- 状态
- 已完成
- 发起方
- 入组人数
- 40
- 主要终点
- Wobble
研究概览
简要总结
Advancement in techniques for anaesthetic drug delivery and real time monitoring has facilitated safe induction and maintenance of anaesthesia in severely compromised patients. Cardiac diseases are the commonest causes of morbidity and left ventricular failure is the commonest clinical presentation at the end stage. LV systolic dysfunction is defined as reduction in LVEF ≤55%. Patients with LVEF 55%-46% have mild, 45%-36% moderate and ≤35% severe LV systolic dysfunction. Patients with heart failure have a diminished cardiac reserve capacity that may be further compromised by anaesthesia. In addition to depression of sympathetic activity, most anaesthetics interfere with cardiovascular performance, either by a direct myocardial depression or by modifying cardiovascular control mechanisms. Propofol with fentanyl is advocated as the best anaesthetic combination for induction of anaesthesia in patients undergoing CABG. Propofol is a drug with narrow therapeutic index and may cause severe hypotension and hemodynamic instability during induction of anaesthesia, especially if it is given in too large doses.
Automated drug delivery systems are popular for delivery of propofol. They can be of two types, depending on whether they are based on pharmacokinetic or pharmacodynamic principles. Closed Loop Anaesthesia Delivery system has been used world-wide and in our institute in patients of various age groups and in patients undergoing cardiac surgery. But still the studies are lacking in patients with moderate to severe left ventricular systolic dysfunction. Moreover none of the studies have compared the efficacy of anaesthetic drug delivery using these two devices in this group of patients.
Thus there is paucity of literature regarding PK and PD of propofol in patients with cardiac failure. The investigators hypothesized that as the Closed Loop Anaesthesia Delivery System is based on pharmacodyanamic principles, it should perform better than the Target Control Infusion system, which works on pharmacokinetic principles. The investigators planned to conduct this study to determine the anaesthetic depth control using Closed Loop Anaesthesia Delivery system vs. manual control using Target Controlled Infusion in patients with moderate to severe left ventricular systolic dysfunction.
详细描述
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Patient will be pre-medicated with oral tablet alprazolam 0.25 mg the night before and on the morning of surgery. In the anesthetic room, 16 G i.v. cannula will be inserted and following monitors will be attached: continuous pulse-oximetry (SpO2), electrocardiogram (ECG), periodic non-invasive blood pressure (S/Anesthesia monitor, Datex Ohmeda Inc., Madison, WI) , and continuous BIS (BIS XP, Aspect Medical Systems, Newton, MA in the S/5 Anesthesia monitor). Pre-induction arterial line and central line will be inserted in all patients and continuous arterial blood pressure and central venous pressure measurements will be recorded. Pulmonary artery catheter will also be inserted in all patients for monitoring of cardiac output. All invasive lines will be inserted under local anesthesia. NIBP measurements will be stopped after transducing arterial line, because it may interfere with the assessment of MOAA/S score.
All the patients will receive i.v. fentanyl at a dose of 3µg.kg-1 over a period 3 minutes, followed by propofol administration either by CLADS or TCI.
Group 1:
Propofol will be administered with the Diprifusor (Marsh Pharmacokinetic model, Master TCI pump, Fresenius Kabi; Bad Homburg; Germany) starting at a predetermined target plasma propofol concentration (Cp) of 1.8µg.ml-1 based on a previous study. Further target concentrations were set according to the Dixon up and down method. A failure will be followed by an increase in the target plasma concentration in the next patient by 0.2µg.ml-1 and a success will be followed by a decrease in the target plasma concentration in the next patient by 0.2µg.ml-1. TCI pump will be controlled manually and all the data including BIS and vitals will be recorded through CLADS into a laptop. MOAA/S will be assessed every 15 second for assessing time to loss of consciousness; BIS and HR will be recorded every 5 seconds and MAP and PAP every 10 seconds. Thus, the anesthetic depth control will be assessed based on time to achieve loss of consciousness and by comparing the dose of propofol required for induction and maintenance. BIS overshoots and hemodynamic stability will be noted. In case the patient achieves loss of consciousness within 5 minutes, a 2 minutes observation period will be allowed for achieving target BIS. If the patient does not achieve target BIS after this period, the case will be considered a failure. On the other hand, if the patient achieves target BIS within this period it will be considered a success. In cases where neither LOC nor target BIS will be achieved within 5 minutes will also be considered a failure Vecuronium will be administered at a dose of 0.1 mg.kg-1 after the LOC and the patient will be intubated after 4 minutes. Patients will be ventilated through face mask to maintain normocapnia administering air-oxygen mixture with FiO2 of 0.6 during the period of induction till intubation. Fentanyl infusion 1µg.kg.h-1 will provide analgesia with additional boluses of 1µg.kg-1 before skin incision, sternotomy and at the commencement of CPB. Additional bolus of analgesic supplements (fentanyl 1µg.kg-1) will be given when the mean arterial pressure (MAP) or heart rate exceeds 25% of the baseline <50. If hypertension or tachycardia persists with a BIS≤50, either nitroglycerine infusion or esmolol will be used. In conditions of hypotension, inotropic support and/or vasopressor will be initiated after ensuring normovolaemia. Atropine sulphate will be used to treat bradycardia (heart rate <45b.p.m.) after excluding other treatable causes. The MAP on CPB will be maintained between 50 and 80 mmHg using phenylephrine / nitroglycerine as required. Systemic hypothermia up to 28ºC will be practiced during CPB and patients will be actively re-warmed to 36ºC before separation from CPB.
研究设计
- 研究类型
- Interventional
- 分配方式
- Randomized
- 干预模型
- Parallel
- 主要目的
- Health Services Research
- 盲法
- Single (Outcomes Assessor)
入排标准
- 年龄范围
- 18 Years 至 65 Years(Adult, Older Adult)
- 性别
- All
- 接受健康志愿者
- 否
入选标准
- •Left ventricular ejection fraction ≤45%
- •NYHA III/IV
- •ASA III/IV
- •Undergoing CABG or valve replacement surgeries
排除标准
- •Patients with body mass index (BMI)>30 kg.m2and <15 kg.m
- •Patients with LVEF≥45%
- •Patients already on inotropes
- •Anticipated difficult airway
- •Central nervous system disease
- •Psychiatric disorder
- •Liver disease
结局指标
主要结局
Wobble
时间窗: approx 8 hrs
Wobble measures the intra-individual variability in performance error.The median of the difference between individual performance errors throughout anesthesia and the median performance error for each participant is the wobble of that participant. The mean value per participant is indicated in the outcome measure.
Percentage of Time Bispectral Index Remains Within 10 of Target BIS of 50
时间窗: approx 8 hours
The duration of time depth of anesthesia was maintained in the recommended range (as measured by BIS) during the period propofol was administered to the study population. This value expressed as percentage. BIS is an objective measure of depth of anesthesia derived from statistical (bispectral) analysis of electroencephalographic waves. BIS ranges from 0 to 100. It decreases monotonically from 100 in the awake state to lower values with sedation and anesthesia.
Median Performance Error (MDPE)
时间窗: approx 8 hrs
The difference between the observed and target of measure of depth of anesthesia (BIS) expressed as percentage of target BIS is calculated as performance error every 30 seconds. This value may be either '+' or '_' indicating whether the observed measure is above the target (overshoot-+) or below the target (undershoot-_). The median value of all performance errors during propofol anesthesia is median performance error and is a measure of bias of the system. This outcome is expressed as the mean of Median Performance Errors per participant
Global Score
时间窗: approx 8 hrs
Gives an idea of the overall performance of the closed-loop system, was calculated as the sum of MDAPE and wobble divided by the fraction of time BIS was within ±10 of the target.
Median Absolute Performance Error (MDAPE)
时间窗: approx 8 hrs
The median of the absolute values of performance errors (without considering the direction of error) is median absolute performance error. This outcome measures the magnitude of error or inaccuracy of the system studied. A lower value indicates a more precise system.This outcome is expressed as the mean of Median Absolute Performance Errors per participant.
次要结局
- propofol consumption(approx 8 hrs)
- fentanyl used(approx 8 hrs)
- adrenaline use(approx 8 hrs)
- nitroglycerine use(approx 8 hrs)
- Estimation of EC50 and EC95 for target plasma concentration in TCI group(during induction (approx 10 min))
- induction dose of propofol(during induction ( approx 20 min))
- Percentage of Time Heart Rate Remained Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline(approx 8 hrs)
- Percentage of Time Mean Arterial Pressure Remained Within 25% of Pre-op Baseline(approx 8 hrs)
- phenylephrine use(approx 8 hrs)
- percentage fall of mean arterial pressure at during induction(during induction ( approx 20 min))
- Estimation of EC50 from Dixon up and down method in the TCI group(during induction ( approx 10 min))
- induction time(approx 8 hrs)
研究者
Varun Mahajan
MBBS
Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh
