跳至主要内容
临床试验/NCT07823231
NCT07823231招募中不适用

Impact Evaluation of Accelerating Climate-Resilient Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Services for Schools and Healthcare Facilities in Karamoja

Elijah Kipchumba1 个研究点 分布在 1 个国家目标入组 16,380 人开始时间: 2026年10月19日最近更新:
适应症
干预措施

试验速览

阶段
不适用
状态
招募中
发起方
入组人数
16,380
试验地点
1
主要终点
School absence rate among enrolled pupils

研究概览

简要总结

Karamoja, in north-eastern Uganda, is among the most water-insecure regions in sub-Saharan Africa. Only 24 per cent of households can access the WHO-recommended 20 litres of water per person per day. Only 11.7 per cent have access to improved sanitation. A rapid vulnerability assessment covered all 182 operational primary schools in the sub-region between October and November 2025. It identified 53 schools as severely water insecure and a further 37 as moderately water insecure. Together, these schools serve an estimated 196,000 learners. The assessment also found that 89 schools lacked enough latrines to meet the national pupil-to-latrine ratio. Seventy-eight schools had no functional menstrual health management facilities.

This study is a three-arm, phase-in cluster-randomised controlled trial. It evaluates the causal effects of a climate-resilient school WASH package on children's health and school attendance. It also examines adolescent girls' menstrual health self-efficacy. The study covers 60 primary schools that were found to be water-insecure across Karamoja's nine districts. The schools were stratified into three geographic zones. The researchers then used covariate-constrained randomisation to assign schools to three study arms. Phase 1 includes 30 schools receiving the intervention early. Phase 2 includes 20 schools receiving it later. The remaining 10 schools form the pure control group.

The intervention combines climate-resilient WASH infrastructure with capacity-building and social and behaviour change activities. The infrastructure includes motorised boreholes, sex-disaggregated latrines and handwashing stations built to national standards. A subset of the boreholes will have data loggers for remote monitoring. The package also provides dedicated menstrual health facilities. These include enclosed changing areas and hygienic waste-disposal systems. Community water access points will be installed next to each school. Capacity-building activities will involve School Management Committees, Parent-Teacher Associations, teachers, District Water Officers and School Health Clubs.

Data will be collected through three repeated cross-sectional rounds. The baseline will take place in the fourth quarter of 2026. The midline will take place in the first quarter of 2028, and the endline in the first quarter of 2030. Seven instruments will be used. These include pupil and matched caregiver surveys, school WASH facility and classroom roll-call observations, and head teacher and teacher surveys. The study will also digitise school enrolment, attendance and examination records. Community leaders will be interviewed separately. In each round, the sample will include 20 post-menarche girls and 20 general pupils per school. The study will interview one caregiver for each sampled pupil. The study will also interview six teachers, the head teacher and four community leaders in each school catchment.

The study has three co-primary outcomes. The first is the pupil absence rate, measured using digitised attendance registers. The second is the seven-day prevalence of diarrhoea among pupils. The third is menstrual health self-efficacy among post-menarche girls. We will measure this using the 26-item Self-Efficacy in Addressing Menstrual Needs Scale (SAMNS-26). The primary analysis will estimate the intent-to-treat effect of assignment to Phase 1. At midline, Phase 1 schools will be compared with Phase 2 and pure control schools. We will conduct two comparisons at endline. First, we will compare all treated schools with the pure control group. Second, Phase 1 schools will be compared with Phase 2 schools to test whether effects differ by exposure duration.

详细描述

BACKGROUND AND RATIONALE

Access to safe water and sanitation in schools is essential for children's health, dignity and learning. However, evidence on the effects of school WASH interventions remains mixed. A systematic review of 38 studies found reductions in school absence ranging from 21 to 61 per cent. Several trials reported larger effects for girls. However, some cluster-randomised trials found no effects. These include a trial in 60 Ethiopian schools that found no improvement in attendance.

The largest effects are generally found in settings with severe water scarcity. A Kenyan trial found a 58 per cent reduction in the odds of absence among girls in schools receiving water treatment. However, it found no overall effect across all schools. The intervention also reduced diarrhoea prevalence by 66 per cent in water-scarce schools. It had no effect in schools that already had access to water. A recent meta-analysis of 50 trials found a similar pattern. WASH interventions reduced diarrhoea risk by 33 per cent during the dry season, compared with 18 per cent during the rainy season.

Evidence on menstrual health interventions is also mixed. In Uganda, girls are nearly six times more likely to miss school during menstruation than on other days. Multi-component menstrual health programmes consistently improve knowledge, attitudes and self-efficacy. However, the most rigorous Ugandan trial to date found no effects on school attendance or educational performance after one year. This was despite improvements across almost every measured dimension of menstrual health.

This trial takes place in a setting with severe baseline deprivation. Existing evidence suggests that WASH interventions may have larger effects under such conditions. The trial therefore examines whether the intervention produces detectable health and education effects in Karamoja.

研究设计

研究类型
Interventional
分配方式
Randomized
干预模型
Parallel
主要目的
Prevention
盲法
None

入排标准

性别
All
接受健康志愿者

入选标准

  • CLUSTER LEVEL (school)
  • Government primary school, operational at the time of the October-November 2025 rapid vulnerability assessment, located in one of the nine districts of the Karamoja sub-region (Abim, Amudat, Kaabong, Karenga, Kotido, Moroto, Nabilatuk, Nakapiripirit, Napak)
  • Classified in the severe or acutely affected moderate water insecurity tier on the adapted HWISE assessment, and among the 60 highest composite priority scores across all 182 assessed schools
  • Hydrological viability confirmed: sub-surface geology and groundwater survey establish the feasibility of a viable water source at or adjacent to the school site
  • Head teacher and school administration grant permission for facility observation and school records capture
  • INDIVIDUAL LEVEL
  • Enrolled in grades P2 to P7 at a trial school and appearing on the current enrolment register at the time of sampling
  • Selected by systematic random sampling from the enrolment register with proportional representation across grades
  • Parent or legal guardian has provided written informed consent, and the pupil has provided assent
  • For the menstrual health sub-sample: post-menarche, approximately aged 11 to 17
  • Caregivers:
  • Parent or legal guardian of a sampled pupil, matched one-to-one
  • Provides own informed consent
  • Teachers and head teachers:
  • Currently employed and appearing on the staff register of a trial school
  • Teachers selected by simple random sampling from the staff register, six per school
  • Provide their own informed consent
  • Community leaders:
  • Local council chairperson, religious leader, women's group representative or community elder resident in the catchment area of a trial school
  • Provides own informed consent

排除标准

  • Schools not confirmed hydrologically viable for a school-site water source
  • Schools outside the top 60 composite priority scores
  • Pupils not appearing on the current enrolment register at the time of sampling
  • Any individual for whom consent (and, for pupils, both guardian consent and pupil assent) is not obtained
  • Any individual who declines or withdraws at any point, without requirement to give a reason and without consequence

研究组 & 干预措施

Phase 1: Early implementation

Experimental

Thirty schools were randomised to receive the full climate-resilient WASH, menstrual health and social and behaviour change package from mid-2026, ahead of baseline data collection in Q4 2026. By midline (Q1 2028), these schools will have had approximately 18 months of intervention exposure.

干预措施: Climate-resilient school WASH infrastructure package (Other)

Phase 1: Early implementation

Experimental

Thirty schools were randomised to receive the full climate-resilient WASH, menstrual health and social and behaviour change package from mid-2026, ahead of baseline data collection in Q4 2026. By midline (Q1 2028), these schools will have had approximately 18 months of intervention exposure.

干预措施: WASH and menstrual health capacity building and social and behaviour change package (Behavioral)

Phase 2: Delayed implementation

Experimental

Twenty schools were randomised to receive the identical intervention package after midline data collection concludes in Q1 2028. These schools serve as untreated comparison clusters at baseline and midline, and as a differential-exposure comparison against Phase 1 at endline, by which point they will have had at least 18 months of exposure.

干预措施: Climate-resilient school WASH infrastructure package (Other)

Phase 2: Delayed implementation

Experimental

Twenty schools were randomised to receive the identical intervention package after midline data collection concludes in Q1 2028. These schools serve as untreated comparison clusters at baseline and midline, and as a differential-exposure comparison against Phase 1 at endline, by which point they will have had at least 18 months of exposure.

干预措施: WASH and menstrual health capacity building and social and behaviour change package (Behavioral)

Pure control

No Intervention

Ten schools were randomised to receive no element of the intervention package during the evaluation period. These schools continue to receive whatever routine district WASH and education services are ordinarily available. Ten clusters is the maximum untreated group compatible with the programme's commitment to reach 50 water-scarce schools.

结局指标

主要结局

School absence rate among enrolled pupils

时间窗: Baseline (month 0), midline (month 15), endline (month 40)

Proportion of scheduled school days on which a pupil is recorded absent in the school's termly attendance registers for the full academic year preceding each survey round. Registers are digitised at each round by photographic capture with pupil name columns covered (whole-school, de-identified) and by transcription for the approximately 40 consented sampled pupils per school. Computed at pupil level and aggregated to school level, disaggregated by sex. Source: Module 6, School Records. Analysed as an intent-to-treat contrast of Phase 1 assignment against Phase 2 and pure control at midline, with school-clustered standard errors.

Seven-day period prevalence of diarrhoea among pupils

时间窗: Baseline (month 0), midline (month 15), endline (month 40)

Proportion of sampled pupils reporting three or more loose or watery stools on any one day during the seven days preceding the interview, following the WHO IMCI case definition and the recall structure used in Freeman et al. 2012/2014 and Bick et al. 2024. Self-reported by the pupil in a private interview. Source: Module 1, Pupil Survey, item B2. A two-day recall measure (item B1) is retained as a lower-bias secondary measure of the same construct.

Self-efficacy in addressing menstrual needs (SAMNS-26) among post-menarche girls

时间窗: Baseline (month 0), midline (month 15), endline (month 40)

Score on the Self-Efficacy in Addressing Menstrual Needs Scale (SAMNS-26; Hunter et al. 2022), administered to the sub-sample of 20 post-menarche girls aged approximately 11-17 per school by trained female enumerators. Twenty-six items, each prefixed "How sure are you that..." and scored on a 0-3 scale (0 = not at all sure, 3 = very sure). Subscale and total scores are computed as the item mean rescaled to 0-100. Three subscales are reported: menstrual hygiene preparation and maintenance, menstrual pain management, and engagement in stigmatised tasks. Higher scores indicate greater self-efficacy. Source: Module 1, Section O.

次要结局

未报告次要终点

研究者

发起方
Elijah Kipchumba
申办方类型
Other
责任方
Sponsor Investigator
主要研究者

Elijah Kipchumba

Impact Evaluation Consultant

UNICEF

研究点 (1)

Loading locations...

相似试验