Efficacy and Mechanisms of Technology-based Behavioral Interventions
- Conditions
- College Student Drinking
- Interventions
- Behavioral: college drinker's check upBehavioral: Ecological Momentary InterventionBehavioral: Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention
- Registration Number
- NCT03510728
- Lead Sponsor
- James M. Henson
- Brief Summary
Large scale surveys indicate that approximately 68% of college students drink alcohol every month and 40% of college students engage in heavy episodic drinking. Despite prevention/intervention efforts, problematic alcohol consumption among college students continues to result in an estimated 1,800 deaths and 600,000 injuries annually, and epidemiological studies demonstrate no appreciable decrease in risk among college students. The purpose of the proposed research is to improve extant college-drinking interventions by advancing the dissemination methodology and the intervention content (Specific Aim 1). As a methodological improvement, rapid advances in mobile computing makes ecological momentary interventions (EMIs) increasingly feasible. EMIs refer to interventions that can be delivered multiple times and "in the moment". EMIs can optimize the timing and location of the intervention while also increasing the dose of the intervention. To improve the intervention content, the researchers will examine protective behavioral strategies (PBS) to reduce alcohol problems, not just alcohol use. PBS are behaviors that one can engage in immediately prior to, during, and immediately following alcohol use that limit alcohol use and/or alcohol-related harm. Research suggests that PBS use can protect individuals from alcohol problems above and beyond its effect on reducing alcohol use. The primary purpose of this research is to provide a more powerful test of a PBS intervention's effects on alcohol-related consequences by using a technology-based intervention methodology (i.e., EMI). Participants will be randomized into to a fully crossed, 3 (Standard BMI, BMI with a PBS component, control) X 2 (PBS-based EMI, Ecological Assessment Only) design. These 6 conditions will answer several critically important research questions (Specific Aim 2): a) does the addition of a PBS component improve the efficacy of a standard BMI, b) does a PBS-based EMI improve efficacy over the standard, single session BMI, c) does the combination of motivation-based intervention (BMI) with a skills-based intervention (EMI) yield even greater decreases in consequences (i.e., moderation). A final purpose of this research is to examine PBS norms, PBS perceived effectiveness, and motivation to change PBS use as novel mediators of the improved interventions. Results can be used to disseminate more effective college drinking interventions that are cheaper and more efficacious.
- Detailed Description
Hazardous alcohol use among college students is a significant public health concern that has resulted in the development of numerous interventions. Although motivational interviewing components are effective at reducing problematic alcohol consumption among college students via reductions in descriptive norms (i.e., the perceived drinking by peers), the effects of single-session brief motivational interventions (BMIs) on alcohol use and consequences are relatively short-lived (i.e., 3 months). Guided by a harm-reduction perspective, researchers have become increasingly interested in how protective behavioral strategies (PBS) can impact alcohol consequences beyond the effects of reduced alcohol consumption. PBS have been found to be a robust predictor of alcohol-related problems controlling for consumption, and multiple intervention studies have found that PBS mediates intervention effects. Few studies, however, have examined the efficacy of PBS-related intervention components.
Specific Aim 1a: The researchers will augment and improve extant college alcohol interventions by developing and rigorously evaluating an added PBS component to an existing BMI with demonstrated efficacy to further reduce alcohol-related consequences beyond what is explained by reduced consumption.
An additional goal of this research is to deliver PBS in a way that capitalizes on newer technologies that allow for the repeated in vivo delivery of alcohol interventions. Given the widespread use of handheld devices among the college population, ecological momentary intervention (EMI) shows great promise in producing lasting behavior for a modest cost.
Specific Aim 1b: The researchers will develop a technology-based, college-drinking ecological momentary intervention (EMI; a newer, less explored methodology) that is disseminated using mobile, hand-held devices, which can be used in vivo with every drinking episode.
Characterizing Intervention Efficacy. The researchers intend to demonstrate that adding a PBS-focused component can increase efficacy beyond standard single-session BMIs while keeping costs minimal. Although the researchers predict that the PBS-based EMI will effect greater and more lasting decreases in alcohol consequences beyond standard intervention, it is important to verify that cheaper, single-session alternatives are not as effective (i.e., PBS-based BMI). Therefore, the researchers intend to implement a 2 (EMI, Ecological Momentary Assessment only \[EMA\]) by 3 (no single-session intervention control, standard BMI, BMI plus PBS component) factorial design. The researchers will characterize the efficacy of the BMI+PBS and EMI over traditional, single-session BMIs in several ways:
Specific Aim 2a: The researchers will examine whether the EMI methodology effects greater and more lasting behavior change as compared to the EMA assessment conditions.
To accomplish Specific Aim 2a, the researchers will examine the main effect of assessment (EMI vs. EMA) to demonstrate that the EMI conditions yield better longitudinal outcomes regardless of the single-session intervention.
Specific Aim 2b: The researchers will examine whether the PBS intervention component leads to reduced alcohol related consequences as compared to a standard BMI, even with a single-session intervention.
To accomplish Specific Aim 2b, the researchers will examine the main effect of the single-session intervention to demonstrate that a single-session BMI that has been enhanced by the PBS component will yield superior longitudinal effects relative to a BMI without the PBS component regardless of assessment style (EMA or EMI); the researchers further expect both BMI groups to be superior to the no-intervention control.
Specific Aim 2c: The researchers expect the EMI to moderate the single-session intervention, such that the PBS-BMI coupled with EMI will yield superior longitudinal outcomes on drinking consequences.
The researchers expect the PBS intervention component to be most efficacious when delivered in vivo during high-risk, alcohol use situations (i.e., EMI), where student motivation and perceived norms about drinking are most challenged. By using a 2X3 design, the researchers will be able to verify the synergistic interaction and characterize the effect size of the relative superiority of the PBS single-session component coupled with the PBS-based EMI.
Mechanisms of Behavior Change. Unlike the BMI, which relies upon motivation and descriptive norm changes, the researchers expect the PBS intervention component to have different mechanisms of behavior change. Specifically, the PBS component is an intervention that emphasizes skill use rather than motivation. Further, when coupled with EMI, which is a direct behavioral intervention, the PBS component will effect change by targeting specific behaviors as opposed to drinking motivation.
Specific Aim 3: To characterize the differential mechanisms of behavior change across the single-session and EMI interventions.
The researchers expect key differences in the mediating variables across interventions conditions. The researchers will examine PBS norms, PBS perceived effectiveness, and motivation to change PBS to ascertain how the researchers can best effect increases in PBS use in college populations.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- UNKNOWN
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 600
- Current college students at the sponsor institution at the time of enrollment
- Between the ages of 18 and 25
- Consumed at least standard drink of alcohol in the past 4 weeks
- Under age of 18 or older than 25
- Not a college student
- Did not drink alcohol in the past 4 weeks
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- FACTORIAL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Standard single-session intervention-EMA college drinker's check up Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will be followed up. Participants in this condition will interact with their phone only for assessment purposes. Standard single-session intervention-EMI college drinker's check up Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will be followed up. Participants in this condition will be interacting with their phones during drinking occasions to promote protective behavioral strategy use (Ecological Momentary Intervention). Augment single-session intervention-EMA Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will also take a computerized intervention developed to increase the use of protective behavioral strategies during drinking (Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention). Participants in this condition will interact with their phone only for assessment purposes. Augment single-session intervention-EMI college drinker's check up Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will also take a computerized intervention developed to increase the use of protective behavioral strategies during drinking (Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention). Participants in this condition will be interacting with their phones during drinking occasions to promote protective behavioral strategy use (Ecological Momentary Intervention). Augment single-session intervention-EMI Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will also take a computerized intervention developed to increase the use of protective behavioral strategies during drinking (Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention). Participants in this condition will be interacting with their phones during drinking occasions to promote protective behavioral strategy use (Ecological Momentary Intervention). Augment single-session intervention-EMA college drinker's check up Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will also take a computerized intervention developed to increase the use of protective behavioral strategies during drinking (Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention). Participants in this condition will interact with their phone only for assessment purposes. No single-session intervention-EMI Ecological Momentary Intervention Participants in this group will not take a single-session intervention at baseline, but will be interacting with their phones during drinking occasions to promote protective behavioral strategy use (Ecological Momentary Intervention). Standard single-session intervention-EMI Ecological Momentary Intervention Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will be followed up. Participants in this condition will be interacting with their phones during drinking occasions to promote protective behavioral strategy use (Ecological Momentary Intervention). Augment single-session intervention-EMI Ecological Momentary Intervention Participants will take a computerized BMI with known efficacy, the college drinker's check up, and will also take a computerized intervention developed to increase the use of protective behavioral strategies during drinking (Protective Behavioral Strategies Intervention). Participants in this condition will be interacting with their phones during drinking occasions to promote protective behavioral strategy use (Ecological Momentary Intervention).
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Alcohol Consumption 6-months Modified version of the Daily Drinking Questionnaire (typical weekly consumption)
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Alcohol Consequences 6-months Young Adult Alcohol Consequences Questionnaire
Trial Locations
- Locations (5)
California State University Dominguez Hills
🇺🇸Carson, California, United States
Colorado State University
🇺🇸Fort Collins, Colorado, United States
William and Mary
🇺🇸Williamsburg, Virginia, United States
Old Dominion University
🇺🇸Norfolk, Virginia, United States
University of New Mexico
🇺🇸Albuquerque, New Mexico, United States