Effect of Total Compression Time and Rate (Slope) on Incidence of Symptomatic ETD and MEB: A Phase II Prospective Study.
- Conditions
- Middle Ear BarotraumaEar BarotraumaEustachian Tube DysfunctionMiddle Ear; InjuryMiddle Ear DiseasePressure Injury
- Interventions
- Procedure: Hyperbaric Compression Profile
- Registration Number
- NCT04776967
- Lead Sponsor
- Northwell Health
- Brief Summary
Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD) and middle ear barotrauma (MEB) are common reported complications during hyperbaric oxygen treatment. The Phase I study data was the first to demonstrate a statistically significant decrease in the occurrence of symptomatic ETD and middle ear barotrauma (MEB). The Phase I Trial suggested the total time interval and rate (slope) of compression (ROC) may be a determining factor in ETD and MEB. This Phase II study investigates an optimal total time interval and rate of compression to reduce ETD and MEB when considering each multiplace treatment (with multiple patients) as the unit of observation collectively as a group, rather than for each individual patient.
Data will be collected prospectively on group patient-treatment exposures. The investigators randomly assigned patient-treatment group exposures to four different time interval and rate (slope) of compression. These total time intervals of compression and rates (slopes) of compression are identical to those used in the Phase I trial. All patients experiencing symptoms of ETD and MEB requiring compression stops will be evaluated post treatment to confirm the presence of ETD and MEB using the O'Neill Grading System (OGS). Data will be analyzed using the IBM-SPSS statistical software program.
The number of compression holds observed in each of the 4 compression schedules, similar to ther Phase I trial will be recorded. Patients who are symptomatic and require compression stops (as in the Phase I trial) using a United States Navy Treatment Table 9 (USN-TTN9) during elective hyperbaric oxygen treatments in a Class A multiplace hyperbaric chamber will be analyzed. Analysis using descriptive and inferential statistics will be applied to the patients requiring first stops in the 4 compression profiles. This Phase II study increases the sample size of treatments and they will be combined with the total number of treatments used in the original phase I study. This will increase power to facilitate detailed descriptive analysis and to determine if the findings are robust in the phase I study.
- Detailed Description
Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD) and middle ear barotrauma (MEB) are common reported complications during hyperbaric oxygen treatment. The investigators Phase I study data was the first to demonstrate a statistically significant decrease in the occurrence of symptomatic ETD and middle ear barotrauma (MEB). The Phase I Trial suggested the total time interval and rate (slope) of compression (ROC) may be a determining factor in ETD and MEB. This Phase II study investigates an optimal rate of compression to reduce ETD and MEB when considering each multiplace treatment (with multiple patients) as the unit of observation as a group, rather than for each individual patient.
Data will be collected prospectively on group patient-treatment exposures. The investigators will randomly assign patient-treatment group exposures to four different time interval and rate (slope) of compression. All patients, within every patient-treatment group exposure, received all 4 compression profiles (CP) on a rotating basis, in effect having patients serve as their own controls in a crossover design and to reduce the risk of treatment order on the effects observed. These compression rates and slopes were identical to those used in the Phase I trial. All patients experiencing symptoms of MEB requiring compression stops will be evaluated post-treatment for the presence of ETD and MEB using the O'Neill Grading System (OGS) for ETD/MEB.
For approximately 10 years, the investigators hyperbaric center used a routine daily multiplace chamber treatment protocol to a depth of 45 feet of seawater (fsw) (modified U.S. Navy Treatment Table 9). The chamber was compressed over a 10-minute time interval representing a 4.5 fsw/minute uniform rate of compression. This 4.5-fsw/minute linear rate (slope) of compression rate was maintained throughout the total 10-minute time interval of treatment and will be used as a baseline compression rate to compare all other compression schedules \[total compression time interval/compression rates (slopes)\]. The investigators will prospectively collect data on patient-treatment group exposures after formalizing four different compression schedules each including a unique combination of compression rate (slope) and time intervals of compression. This was similar to the Phase I study.
Data will be collected prospectively on all patients recruited and receiving treatment from February 11, 2019, and February 10, 2020, and combined with the data obtained in our Phase I trial collected from September 8, 2014 to September 8, 2016. This Phase II study defines the unit of observations as a multiplace patient-treatment group exposure rather than individual patient treatment exposures. This approach was considered appropriate as a treatment stop or hold in a multiplace chamber affects all other patient occupants in the same treatment group exposure.
To mitigate the risk of confounding, only the first stop will be used as the stop or hold indicator for that particular patient-treatment group exposure. Data will be collected on the patient(s) experiencing the stop or hold. All patients will undergo pre-treatment video otoscopy with baseline tympanic membrane (TM) photos and video of TM motion documenting the patients ability to equalize. This is used to assess potential Eustachian tube patency and proper equalization performance to help exclude individual patient technique as a confounding variable. Photos will be repeated at the end of treatment on any patient(s) complaining of symptoms referable to ETD/MEB that require a stop during compression.
Multiple stops for the same patient on the same treatment will not be considered. Only the first compression stop or hold during each treatment exposure will be recorded or assigned as a patient-treatment stop representing that particular patient-treatment group exposure. Compression stops will be made when any patient experiences difficulty equalizing (requests a stop or complains of ear discomfort of any type).
Repeat video otoscopy will be conducted on all patients complaining of symptoms referable to ETD or MEB to objectively document the grade of barotrauma at the end of the treatment. The OGS system will be used to record the severity of the ETD or MEB. The depth of the stop, the treatment number for that particular patient, and the actions taken to alleviate the symptoms during equalization will be recorded.
The depth of the compression stop will be recorded in feet of seawater (fsw) as will be the ascent (fsw) required for the patient to clear the middle ear pressure and relieve the symptoms. The patients symptoms must be resolved, rendering the patient asymptomatic and able to continue the treatment compression profile. All team members (physicians, nurses, and technicians) present and working on the day of the exposure, are responsible for viewing the patients pre and post tympanic membrane photos and determining the grade of barotrauma using the OGS criteria.
All stops were categorized under the respective compression protocol used for that particular patient-treatment group exposure. Data will then compared using both descriptive and inferential statistical analysis including the risk difference, odds ratio (OR), two-tailed Chi Square analysis using α=0.05, and outcomes will be studied separately in a logistic regression analysis.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- COMPLETED
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 300
Any patient meeting the indications for hyperbaric oxygen treatment.
Any patient with absolute contraindications to hyperbaric oxygen treatment, chronic bilateral perforation of the tympanic membrane or prior bilateral myringotomy tube placement.
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- CROSSOVER
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Compression Profile 3 Hyperbaric Compression Profile Compression Profile/Schedule 3 = 10 minute non-linear, Total Time Interval of Compression to treatment depth = 10 minutes Rate (slope) of compression = Non-Linear rate of compression = 3 fsw/min to a depth of 17 fsw, then 5 fsw/min up to a depth of 38.5 fsw, then 6.5 fsw/min to arrival at the treatment depth of 45 fsw Compression Profile 4 Hyperbaric Compression Profile Compression Profile/Schedule 4 = 10 minute linear, Total Time Interval of Compression to treatment depth = 10 minutes, Rate (slope) of compression = Linear rate of compression = 4.5 fsw/min to arrival at treatment depth 45 fsw Compression Profile 2 Hyperbaric Compression Profile Compression Profile/Schedule 2 = 15 minute linear, Total Time Interval of Compression to treatment depth = 15 minutes Rate (slope) of compression = Linear rate of compression = 4.5 fsw/min to arrival at the treatment depth 45 fsw Compression Profile 1 Hyperbaric Compression Profile Compression Profile/Schedule 1 = 15 minute non-linear, Total Time Interval of Compression to treatment depth = 15 minutes Rate (slope) of compression = Non-Linear rate of compression = 2 fsw/min to a depth of 13 fsw, then 3 fsw/min up to a depth of 35 fsw, then 5 fsw/min to arrival at the treatment depth of 45 fsw
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Assessing the severity of Eustachian tube dysfunction and middle ear barotrauma after using various compression rates and slopes of compression during hyperbaric oxygen treatment via direct video otoscopy Patients are assessed during each hyperbaric chamber compression until reaching treatment pressure/depth daily throughout the entire treatment course that varies based on diagnosis over 4-12 weeks Photo otoscopy and the severity of eustachian tub dysfunction and/or middle ear barotrauma will be defined using the O'Neill Grading System when a patient experiences a stop or hold during the compression phase of hyperbaric oxygen treatment.
O'Neill Grading System:
0 = Symptoms of Eustachian tube dysfunction with no objective signs of barotrauma on otoscopy
1. = Objective evidence of increased erythema, air trapping or serous/serosanguinous effusion
2. = Any frank bleeding in the middle ear space, tympanic membrane or external ear canal or perforationCompression stops or holds during the compression phase of hyperbaric oxygen treatments Patients are assessed during each hyperbaric chamber compression until reaching treatment pressure/depth daily throughout the entire treatment course that varies based on diagnosis over 4-12 weeks Hyperbaric oxygen treatment (HBOT) protocols include a compression phase. Pressure is increased until final treatment pressure is achieved. Pressure changes vary between 14.7 psi to 35 psi. Patients experience symptoms of pain or pressure in the middle ear space because they cannot clear middle ear pressure. Pressure symptoms may be time and/or slope related. Using varying rates of pressure may decrease discomfort related to clearing middle ear pressure; Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD) and middle ear barotrauma (MEB), the most common adverse effects of HBOT. The authors believe a slower rate or slope of compression may decrease the occurrence of stops and decrease the incidence of ETD and MEB during HBOT. Decreasing rate of compression may further mitigate risk and decrease the incidence of symptomatic ETD and MEB.
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
Phelps Hospital Northwell Health
🇺🇸Sleepy Hollow, New York, United States