SSM vs HEP in Late-Life Depression
- Conditions
- Late-life DepressionTreatment-resistant Depression
- Interventions
- Behavioral: Health Enhancement Program (HEP)Behavioral: Sahaj Samadhi Meditation (SSM)
- Registration Number
- NCT03564041
- Lead Sponsor
- Lawson Health Research Institute
- Brief Summary
The investigators will conduct a randomized controlled trial (RCT), comparing SSM (n=96) versus HEP (n=96) in 192 LLD participants stratified by site and presence of treatment resistant late life depression (TR-LLD). Participants will be blinded to the treatment hypothesis while investigators, raters and treating clinicians will be additionally blinded to the intervention. Both SSM and HEP will be taught over 4 consecutive days in similar sized groups (4-10 participants) followed by weekly reinforcement sessions for subsequent 11 weeks. Trained raters will collect data on depression symptoms (HAM-D 17 scale) and cognition at baseline, 12-week and 26-week follow-up as the primary and secondary outcome measures respectively.
- Detailed Description
RECRUITMENT AND CONSENT:
Participants will either be recruited from primary-, secondary-, and tertiary-care centres or from self-referral (general public). Montreal patients will be recruited from the Douglas Institute and associated Integrated University Health and Social Services Centres (CIUSSS)-Ouest de l'ile Local Community Services Centres (CLSCs) (CLSC Verdun and CLSC Lasalle), Jewish General Hospital (JGH) Psychiatry clinics (Institute for Community and Family Psychiatry) and associated CIUSSS-Centre-Ouest family medicine clinics/CLSCs: CLSC Benny Farm, CLSC Rene Cassin, CLSC Côte Des Neiges, CLSC Metro, CLSC Parc Extension, Herzl Family Medicine JGH, St-Mary's Dept. of Psychiatry, and McGill University Health Centre (MUHC) Dept. of Psychiatry. London participants will be recruited from London Health Science Centre (LHSC) sites (Victoria Hospital and University Hospital) and Parkwood Institute - Mental Health Care Building. Participants will be screened for eligibility and given a letter of information (LOI) for their review. After 24 hours, a research assistant will contact the participant and, if they are interested in participating and eligible to participate in the research study, they will be recruited into the study after valid consent is received.
STUDY INTERVENTION:
This study is a 12-week, randomized controlled trial seeking to recruit 192 participants with late-life depression total across two sites - (1) McGill University, Montreal, Quebec (QC), and (2) University of Western Ontario in London, Ontario (ON). Participants will be randomly assigned to one of two conditions: Sahaj Samadhi Meditation (SSM) or the Health Enhancement Program (HEP). The SSM intervention will be offered by trained and certified teachers from the Art of Living Foundation at Montreal and London between August 2018 and August 2021. The HEP intervention will be offered by a trained Nurse Practitioner, Social Worker, Psychologist, Occupational Therapist or other qualified professional at Montreal and London between August 2018 and August 2022. Raters, clinicians, and care providers will be blind to participant study condition.
SSM (the experimental group) and HEP (the active control group) require participants to attend training for 4 days, attend weekly follow-up sessions, and to practice the trained techniques at home for 20-minutes per day (details of each intervention can be found below). Participants will additionally be asked to fill out "homework logs" to record days they practiced the trained technique. A total of 3 assessment sessions are planned for participants to attend: to occur at baseline (0-week) as well as at 12-week and 26-week follow-ups.
MENTAL HEALTH ASSESSMENTS:
Participants will be screened using the Screening for Cognitive Impairment in Older Adults (Mini-Cog), Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9), the Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) pre-screening questionnaire, the Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview, the Test of Premorbid Functioning, and the Antidepressant Treatment History Form (ATHF). Participants will be tested for the primary outcome, depression, using the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAM-D17). The secondary outcome, executive functioning, will be measured by the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS) Digit Span, Delis-Kaplan (D-KEFS) Verbal Fluency Test, Rey-Osterrieth Complex Figure-Copy Trial, and the California Verbal Learning Test-II-Short Form. Measures of primary and secondary outcomes will be administered at all 3 assessment sessions. All measures are described below.
BLOOD DRAW:
Blood draws will be performed at baseline (0-weeks) and 12-week follow-up by a qualified nurse at the CLSC in Montreal and Parkwood Mental Health in London. The blood collected will be stored at the Douglas Mental Health University Institute in Montreal, QC, and at Robart's Research Institute in London, ON.
GAIT:
Gait data will be collected in London, Ontario, only. The data to be collected is weight, height, waist circumference, and hip circumference. Gait data will be measured alongside the Falls Efficacy Scale (FES-I) (described below).
MRI:
The investigators aim to recruit a total of 50 participants (25 from each group) from the SSM/HEP study into a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) study that will involve MRI scans at baseline and at the 12-week follow-up. Participants eligible for this sub-study will have had to complete the MRI pre-screening questionnaire. Those who are part of this sub-study will be invited to attend two MRI scanning sessions, which are expected to take about 1.5 h, to occur at baseline and the 12-week follow-up. Each MRI appointment will be completed in addition to the tasks described above.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS
Descriptive statistics will be run with continuous variables summarized using mean and standard deviations and categorical variables summarized using counts and proportions. HDRS-17 scores at baseline and 12-week follow-up of patients assigned to SSM and HEP will be compared using linear mixed models. This approach will account for the clustering of observations, since both SSM and HEP will be delivered in a group setting. Next, we will evaluate whether a greater proportion of patients assigned to SSM, compared to HEP, achieve depression remission (defined as a HDRS-17 score ≤7 at the 12-week follow-up) using generalized linear mixed models.
We will take Z-scores of executive functioning tests at baseline and at 12-week follow-up for each test and take the mean of these to calculate an overall Z-score for Planning and Organizing Cognition Measures. Z-scores at baseline and at 12-week follow-up of patients assigned to SSM and HEP will be compared using linear mixed models.
PROTOCOL DEVIATIONS
On March 22, 2019 a protocol deviation occurred when a preliminary analysis (n=14) was completed for the purpose of an undergraduate student research volunteer's course requirements. This volunteer did not have access to patient identifiers. The results were presented at an undergraduate research day as a poster with no abstract in the public domain.
This preliminary analysis has the potential to reduce the available degrees of freedom for the final study analyses. It could also be that blinded personnel (raters and PI) who are now aware of the preliminary results may inadvertently suffer from selection /outcome bias.
The investigators agree that the risk of this preliminary analysis jeopardizing the final analysis is theoretically significant and hence data from these participants will not be included in the final analyses.
On September 5, 2019 two protocol deviations occurred when all the participants in a cohort (n=4) were allocated to attend the SSM intervention. This decision was made at that time a) to maintain recruitment targets and b) to ensure the therapeutic effect of a group intervention a size of 4-6 was felt necessary.
It was felt that that if minimum group size participants are not met, participants will not benefit from the support of their peers as offered by SSM and/or HEP.
As a result of this decision two protocol violations occurred: 1. one participant did not attend the intervention to which they were randomized but rather to the other intervention 2. the study rater was unblinded to the allocations of all 4 participants in this group.
The investigators agree that these protocol deviations will lead to data from these 4 participants to be compromised and hence it will not be analyzed in the final analyses.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- TERMINATED
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 95
Not provided
Not provided
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Health Enhancement Program (HEP) Health Enhancement Program (HEP) Arm type: Active control group HEP controls for several non-specific factors found in a meditation group such as Sahaj Samadhi, including: group support and morale, behavioral activation, reduction of stigma, facilitator attention, treatment duration, and time spent on at-home practice. HEP has been tailored to be structurally equivalent to a SSM intervention, with similar-sized groups, meeting for 4 days for 2 hours, and then a one-hour follow up session weekly for the subsequent 11 weeks, and completing the same amount of home practice (20 minutes twice daily, every day), and will be asked to complete weekly practice logs. Sahaj Samadhi Meditation (SSM) Sahaj Samadhi Meditation (SSM) SSM will be taught to participants over 4 consecutive days, for 2 hours each day. Participants will initially learn about the nature of meditation and will be taken through a guided meditation. Afterwards, participants will undergo training which includes understanding the nature of the mind and the thoughts arising from it, guided meditation by the instructor, and a discussion of what is correct and incorrect meditation. Follow-ups will be conducted once every week for the following 11 weeks, each including guided meditation. Participants will be encouraged to practice the meditation at home for 20 minutes per session and will be given weekly practice logs to complete.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Change in depressive symptoms: Hamilton Depression Scale (HAM-D17) Change from week 0 to week 12 and change from week 0 to week 26. The HAM-D17 is a measure of depressive symptoms. Higher scores on this scale indicate greater depression severity; whereas lower scores indicate minimal/no presence of depression. Change in participant scores on this scale throughout the study will be assessed.
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Delis-Kaplan Executive Function System (D-KEFS): Verbal Fluency Test 0 weeks (baseline); 12 weeks; and 26 weeks The Verbal Fluency Test of the D-KEFS asks participants to provide responses according to rules set out by 3 sub-tests (letter fluency, category fluency, and category switching). Correct and incorrect responses are scored. The higher number of correct responses and the lower number of incorrect responses is indicative of stronger verbal fluency. A higher number of incorrect responses and/or lower number of correct responses in one of the sub-tests may indicate neurological dysfunction in a corresponding brain region. No global score is generated.
California Verbal Learning Test-II (CVLT-II), Short Form 0 weeks (baseline); 12 weeks; and 26 weeks The CVLT-II is a tool used to assess verbal learning and memory. Scores are determined by recording correct and incorrect responses on each task. Raw scores are used to assess overall performance on the CVLT-II, with higher correct responses and lower incorrect responses indicating good executive functioning.
Rey-Osterrieth Complex Figure-Copy Trial 0 weeks (baseline); 12 weeks; and 26 weeks This neuropsychological test asks participants to draw an image they have been shown after no delay (copying it), a short delay, and a longer delay. The accuracy of each drawn image to the original at each time point is indicative of neurological systems' functioning level.
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
London Health Sciences Centre
🇨🇦London, Ontario, Canada