跳至主要内容
临床试验/NCT05381987
NCT05381987已完成不适用

The Effectiveness of Radial Shockwave Therapy on Myofascial Pain Syndrome: a Mixed Method Study That Combines a Randomised Control Trial and Semi-Structured Interview.

King Faisal Specialist Hospital & Research Center2 个研究点 分布在 1 个国家目标入组 70 人开始时间: 2022年4月21日最近更新:
适应症

试验速览

阶段
不适用
状态
已完成
入组人数
70
试验地点
2
主要终点
Numeric pain rating scale (NPRS)

研究概览

简要总结

Introduction: Myofascial pain syndrome (MPS) is a common, costly and often persistent musculoskeletal problem. Radial shockwave (RSW) is one of the most common treatment for MFS. However, a recent systematic review found very low-level evidence to support its short-term benefit, due to poor methodological qualities. The authors therefore recommended further large scale, good quality placebo-controlled trials (RCT) in this area. Further still, previous studies have not considered the experiences of patient regarding this intervention.

Study Objectives: To determine the effectiveness of RSW compared to placebo for the treatment of patients with MPS in neck and upper back, and to establish the experiences of patients receiving the treatment.

Research Questions: Is RSW therapy more effective at improving MPS compared to a placebo? What are the experiences of patients with MPS receiving this treatment?

Methods: A pragmatic double blind RCT to investigate the effectiveness of RSW on patients with MPS and a semi-structured-interview to investigate the patients' experience of receiving the treatment.

Sample: 120 potential participants with MPS for the RCT and 20 participants for the semi-structured qualitative interview.

Interventions: The Intervention group will receive a total of 6 sessions of RSW following manufacturer's parameters: 1.5 bar, pulses 2000, frequency 15 Hz (Time 3 minutes). The Control group will receive an identical treatment except that the they will receive a no energy shock of 0.3 bar, frequency 15 and no pulses.

Outcome measures: Improvements in the patient's numeric pain scale (NPS), neck disability index (NDI), pressure pain threshold (PPT) and SF-12 questionnaires at 4, 8 and 12 weeks' follow-up between the two groups.

Significance of the Study's Outcome: The expectation is that this study will add to the body of knowledge required to help patients, healthcare practitioners, policy makers and researchers make effective treatment choices on RSW in the management MFS.

详细描述

INTRODUCTION Myofascial pain syndrome (MPS) is a common, costly and often persistent musculoskeletal problem that affects 85% of the general population at some point in their lifetime (Fleckenstein et al, 2010; Simon, 1996). Reported overall rates vary between male and female population and with different patient populations. MPS has been reported as the leading cause of chronic and persistent musculoskeletal regional pain such as neck pain, shoulder pain, chronic back pain and facial pain (Li et al, 2017). In the United States, the estimated economic cost for the management of chronic pain is $560-$635 billion per annum for medical care and disability programs, with the potential to increase year on year (Gaskin & Richard, 2012). Therefore, it is important that chronic musculoskeletal pain such as MPS in the neck and upper back is treated efficiently and effectively to improve patient's clinical outcomes and experience.

The clinical manifestation of MPS varies widely because it is not a distinct pathology. It is characterised by localized pain, muscle tenderness, palpable intramuscular taut band, local twitch response, referred pain, muscle spasm and sleep disturbance (Fernández-de-las-Peñas et al, 2012; Sciotti et al, 2001; Alvarez & Rockwell, 2001; Travell & Simmons, 1999). Myofascial trigger points can produce symptoms of pain upon palpation and pressure. A nail bed palpation by pressing manually with a thumb or using a digital algometer probe can trigger a local twitch response (LTR), which can reproduce symptoms of pain. This study will use a digital algometer to measure pressure pain threshold, which have been used by previous authors (Luan et al, 2019).

Most patients with MPS are treated by physiotherapists, physicians, chiropractors and osteopaths using trigger point injection, dry needling, acupuncture, ultrasound, stretches, deep frictional massages and taping (Galasso et al, 2020; Tough et al, 2009; Müller-Ehrenberg, 2005; Fernández-de-las-Peñas, et al, 2012). However, the most effective treatment for MPS is not known.

Radial shockwave is one of the most common and non-invasive treatments method with very few negative side effects, for musculoskeletal tissues such as MPS that normally are very difficult to treat (Watson, 2014). They are low to medium-energy pulses and their penetration depths are normally 0-6 cm ("0-2.3") (Watson, 2014). The therapeutic doses of radial shockwave ranges from low (up to 0.08mJ/mm2) to high (up to 0.63mJ/mm2) energy levels, and the number of treatment session repetitions is between 3 - 7 sessions (Watson, 2014). The number of shocks per session is usually between 1000 to 2500.

Some of the most strongly established therapeutic and biological effects of radial shockwave include mechanical stimulation, increased local blood flow that leads to tissue repair and regeneration by causing micro-functional and micro-structural changes, increase in cellular activity - release of substance P, prostaglandin E2 and tumour growth factor (TGF β), transient analgesic effect on afferent nerves and break down of calcific deposits (Watson, 2014; Wang, 2012). No evidence of serious tissue destruction at therapy level doses has been reported.

研究设计

研究类型
Interventional
分配方式
Randomized
干预模型
Parallel
主要目的
Treatment
盲法
Double (Participant, Outcomes Assessor)

盲法说明

Randomisation allocation sequence will be based on computer-generated random sequence using permuted block size of 4 and concealed random allocation using sealed opaque envelopes.

入排标准

年龄范围
19 Years 至 80 Years(Adult, Older Adult)
性别
All
接受健康志愿者

入选标准

  • Patients aged 19 and above
  • Neck and or upper back pain localised the lateral or posterior neck and or upper back
  • Palpable tenderness in the lateral or posterior neck and or upper back
  • Trigger points in lateral or posterior neck and or upper back
  • Able to give informed consent

排除标准

  • Patients below 19 years of age
  • History of:
  • Malignancy
  • Lung tissue
  • Haemophiliacs or patients on anticoagulant therapy
  • Visible tissue damage (skin petechiae & microvasculature disruption)
  • Metal implants - implanted cardiac stents & heart valves
  • Infection
  • Rheumatic, respiratory, cardiovascular diseases
  • Psychopathy
  • Disorders of the vestibular and visual systems
  • neck or shoulder surgery within a year,
  • Recent history steroid injections to myofascial trigger point
  • Pregnancy
  • Diagnosed as:
  • Fibromyalgia, cervical radiculopathy or myelopathy
  • Inability and unwillingness to continue study
  • Failure to consent

结局指标

主要结局

Numeric pain rating scale (NPRS)

时间窗: 12 weeks

NPRS is a single 11-point numeric scale (with 0 as "no pain" and 10 as the "worse imaginable pain") to measure pain intensity in adults (Hawker 2011). It allows patients to measure their level of pain accordingly using a whole number (0-10 integers) that corresponds to their pain intensity (Rodriguez, 2001). The scale is considered reliable (accurate and consistent), responsive (ability to detect clinically significant changes) and valid (actually measures what it sets out to) (Hawker, 2011). Accordingly, a pain reduction of 2 points, or 30%, on the NPRS scores is defined as Minimal Clinically Important Difference (MCID) \[Childs et al, 2005; Farrar et al, 2001\]. The NPS is relatively easy to comprehend, and to apply, especially by patients with musculoskeletal disorders (Hawker, 2011).

Pressure pain threshold (PPT)

时间窗: 12 weeks

It will be measured using a digital algometer and pain score measurement will be performed with digital palpation. The algometer circular flat tip with 1.0 cm2 surface will be slowly pushed vertically to the skin over the trigger points until the participants interprets the compression on skin as pain sensation. The exerted pressure will be enlarged at a rate of 1 kg/cm2. Participants will be requested to inform the treating physiotherapist by saying "yes" when the pain is perceived. The measurements will be taken three times with 40 seconds intervals, and the mean average value will be taken (Fischer, 1998). A mean difference of 0.94 kg/cm2 in PPT was defined as MCID (Asiri et al, 2020).

Neck Disability Index (NDI)

时间窗: 12 weeks

It is the most commonly used self-rated disability score for assessing patients with neck pain Vernon \& Mior (1991). It consists of ten domains: pain intensity, personal care, lifting, reading, headaches, concentration, work, driving, sleeping and recreation. Each question contains six answer choices, scored from 0 (no disability) to 5 (complete disability). All sections are then totalled. Scoring is reported on a 0-50 scale, 0 being the best possible score and 50 being the worst. The score can also be reported as a percentage (0-100%). The Minimum Detectable Change (90% confidence) is 5 points or 10% points Vernon \& Mior (1991), and the MCID is in the range of 3.5-5.0 points (Pool et al, 2007).

SF12 - Quality of life (QoL)

时间窗: 12 weeks

Quality of life status will be evaluated using the short form (SF12), which is a shorter version of SF-36 questionnaire. The health survey (SF-12) questionnaire, consists of 12 items regarding the quality of life with respect to the physical and emotional aspects. Likert scales and yes/no options were used to assess function and wellbeing on this 12-item questionnaire. To score the SF-12, scales are standardized with a scoring algorithm to obtain a score ranging from 0 to 100. Higher scores indicate better health status. It is one of the most widely used patient report outcome with well documented high validity, reliability, and responsiveness rate among many groups varying by age, sex, socio-economic status, geographical region, and clinical conditions (Ware et al, 2000).

次要结局

未报告次要终点

研究者

申办方类型
Other
责任方
Sponsor

研究点 (2)

Loading locations...

相似试验