Determining the Effectiveness of Working Out Dads to Reduce Mental Health Difficulties in Fathers of Young Children
- Conditions
- Mental Health Issue
- Interventions
- Behavioral: Working Out DadsBehavioral: Usual care
- Registration Number
- NCT04813042
- Lead Sponsor
- Murdoch Childrens Research Institute
- Brief Summary
This is an individually randomised trial, where Working Out Dads (WOD) will be delivered as a group intervention. Participants will be randomised to one of two groups: either WOD or usual care.The trial aims to test the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of WOD, a 6-week week group-based peer support intervention, in reducing fathers' mental health difficulties in early parenthood.
- Detailed Description
This is an individually randomised trial, where Working Out Dads (WOD) will be delivered as a group intervention.
The primary aim of this study is to test the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of WOD in reducing fathers' mental health difficulties in early parenthood. A second aim is to identify barriers and facilitators for sustained use and scalability of the WOD program and its adaptation across Victoria and Australia in the future.
Participants will be 280 fathers of young children (0-4 years) who are experiencing mental health difficulties or at risk of poor mental health and suicide. Approximately 140 fathers will be randomised to WOD, and 140 fathers randomised to usual care.
Fathers will be recruited from four Victorian Local Government Areas (LGAs): Wyndham, Whittlesea, Geelong, and Ballarat. Within these sites, fathers will be recruited through maternal and child health, medical and family support services.
Data will be collected via self-report surveys at baseline, 10 weeks, and 24 weeks. The assessment at 24 weeks will also include a telephone interview with a researcher (blinded) to assess mental health. In August 2022, an optional 72-week follow-up was added to the study design.
Participants will be randomised in a 1:1 ratio to the two treatment arms. A statistician not directly involved in the analysis of the trial results will prepare the randomisation schedule using permuted block randomisation, stratified by LGA, using a random number generator on a computer. The schedule will be held by the independent statistician and embedded within the web-based data management system.
Treatment arms:
Intervention condition - WOD: Fathers will attend a WOD group within approximately two weeks of randomisation and within four weeks of baseline assessment. WOD is a 6-week group-based peer support intervention. WOD's weekly sessions consists of 1-hour group discussion focused on common challenges and risk factors for poor mental health in early fatherhood, followed by a 30-minute group exercise session. Fathers in the WOD intervention condition will also have access to online resources and a father-managed WhatsApp group.
Usual care condition: Fathers will receive the clinical care typically provided by an early parenting or community health service to parents experiencing mental health difficulties. Within two weeks of baseline assessment, Tweddle's Clinical Manager will conduct a brief telephone consultation to: (a) enquire about mental health symptoms and conduct a risk assessment for suicidal ideation; (b) provide referral options to telephone support services (e.g., PANDA, MensLine); and (c) encourage visiting a general practitioner to discuss accessing a mental health care plan.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- ACTIVE_NOT_RECRUITING
- Sex
- Male
- Target Recruitment
- 293
- Be aged 18 years or older
- Be biological or step-father, or male caregiver of a child aged 0-4 years
- Be in regular weekly contact with the child, even if non-resident parent
- Be sufficiently fluent in English to complete surveys and participate in the intervention
- Have mental health difficulties above the symptomatic cut-point (score of 20+) on the K10.
AND/OR
• Have at least two risk factors for poor mental health/suicide including: (a) history of mental health difficulties; (b) relationship difficulties; (c) high work-related stress; (d) unemployment; or (e) have a child with sleep difficulties, a disability, chronic illness or other special health care need.
- Has a severe mental health disorder - self reported psychosis, substance use dependency, prescribed anti-psychotic medication that may require more intensive mental health interventions and treatment
- Has an overt indicator of family violence - self-reported intervention order or court case for family violence
- Has child protection service involvement
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Working Out Dads Working Out Dads Fathers allocated to the Working Out Dads (WOD) arm will receive the intervention program. WOD is a 6-week manualised program. The weekly 90 minute sessions combine a one hour facilitated discussion by a male facilitator trained in delivery of WOD and a 30-minute gym workout provided by a personal trainer. The group size ranges from 6-10 fathers, with 14 groups running over the study period. The weekly sessions are provided in the evenings, in local gyms or a community setting (e.g., maternal child health centre, local council rooms, local hall, local park, Tweddle Child \& Family Health Service). Usual Care Usual care Fathers allocated to the Usual Care arm will receive the clinical care typically provided to parents experiencing mental health difficulties by an Early Parenting Centre or community health service. Within 2 weeks of baseline assessment, Usual Care participants will receive a brief psychological consultation from Tweddle's Clinical Manager.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Kessler Psychological Distress Scale, mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 24 The 10-item Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K10) assesses depressive and anxiety symptoms in the last 4 weeks. Scores range from 10-50 with higher scores indicating greater levels of psychological distress. Rationale: The K10 is widely used in clinical trials for common mental health disorders, and is consistent with a transdiagnostic approach proposing a common set of psychological distress symptoms underlie mood and anxiety disorders.
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method The Suicidal Ideation Attributes Scale mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 The Suicidal Ideation Attributes Scale is a 5-item screener for the presence and severity of suicidal thoughts in the last month based on frequency, controllability, closeness to attempt, level of distress, and impact on daily functioning. Scores range from 0-50 with higher scores indicating a greater severity of suicidal ideation. Any ideation is indicative of risk for suicidal behaviour; scores \>21 indicate high risk. Online administration has been validated (N=1352 Australian adults), and it has excellent reliability (Cronbach α=0.91) and validity.
The Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21 mean difference scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 The Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21 (DASS-21) assesses symptoms of depression, anxiety, and stress in the past week (21 items). Scores on each scale range from 0-42 with higher scores indicating a greater severity of symptoms. Clinical ranges are available. Excellent reliability and validity has been demonstrated in Australian population-based samples. The DASS-21 is routinely used by early parenting services.
Perceived Need for Care Questionnaire (modified version), mean difference in proportion with unmet need between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 A modified version of the Perceived Need for Care Questionnaire will be used to ask fathers if they needed mental health care but could not access (same time period). Fathers will be as either as either 0= having no unmet need, or 1= having unmet needs.
Health Service Use cost, mean difference in cost of healthcare use between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 24 Service use will be assessed by self-reported cost of healthcare services accessed (prior to baseline and during the study period) and by examination of Medicare data. Higher cost will indicate a greater expense of health care use.
Uptake of father specific supports and/or activities- mean difference in number of activities taken up between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms. post intervention at week 72 Study specific questions have been developed to ask fathers about what activities (e.g., joined a fathers' group, stayed in contact with other fathers) they have engaged in since participating in WOD or usual care.
The Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview mean difference in proportion of depressive, suicidal, and anxiety mental health disorders between Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 24 The Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI) will be used to determine clinically significant depressive, suicidal or anxiety mental health disorders. Administered via telephone by trained staff, this 15-minute structured diagnostic interview assesses 17 common DSM-5 and ICD-10 psychiatric disorders. It is well validated for use in clinical trials and epidemiological studies. In this prevention trial, we predict a higher proportion of fathers in the usual care arm (vs. the intervention arm) will have ongoing or emerging clinically significant depressive, suicidal or anxiety mental health disorders by 6 months
The Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21mean difference scale scores between Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 10 The Depression Anxiety Stress Scale-21 (DASS-21) assesses symptoms of depression, anxiety, and stress in the past week (21 items). Scores on each scale range from 0-42 with higher scores indicating a greater severity of symptoms.Clinical ranges are available. Excellent reliability and validity has been demonstrated in Australian population-based samples. The DASS-21 is routinely used by early parenting services.
The Kessler Psychological Distress Scale mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 The 10-item Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K10). assesses depressive and anxiety symptoms in the last 4 weeks. Scores range from 10-50 with higher scores indicating greater levels of psychological distress. Rationale: The K10 is widely used in clinical trials for common mental health disorders, and is consistent with a transdiagnostic approach proposing a common set of psychological distress symptoms underlie mood and anxiety disorders.
Child-Parent Relationhip Scale mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms. post intervention at week 72 The Child-Parent Relationship Scale- short form (CPRS)\[39\] is a 15-item measure which assess parents' perceptions of their relationship with their child.
The Medical Outcomes Study-Social Support Survey mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 The Medical Outcomes Study-Social Support Survey (MSSS). The 14 items assess tangible, emotional, affective and positive support. Scores range from 14-70 with higher scores indicating greater levels of perceived social support. Excellent reliability (Cronbach's α=0.88) and validity have been established.
The Revised Attitudes Towards Seeking Professional Psychological Help Scale mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 24 The 10-item Revised Attitudes Towards Seeking Professional Psychological Help Scale.Scores range from 0-30 with higher scores indicating a more positive attitude towards help-seeking. Excellent reliability has been established in Australian samples (Cronbach's α=0.77).
The Karitane Parenting Confidence Scale mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 24 The Karitane Parenting Confidence Scale (KPCS) is a 15-item measure that assesses parents' perceived parenting self-efficacy or sense of competence in their parenting abilities. Scores range from 0-45 with higher scores indicating a greater level of parenting self-efficacy. The scale has documented excellent internal consistency, test-retest reliability, convergent and discriminant validity with mothers of young children.
The Child-Parent Relationship Scale- short form mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 24 The Child-Parent Relationship Scale- short form (CPRS) is a 15-item measure which assess parents' perceptions of their relationship with their child. The measure is comprised of two subscales: closeness and conflict. Scores on the Conflict subscale range between 8-40 with higher scores indicating greater levels of perceived parent-child conflict. Scores on the closeness subscale range between 7-35 with higher scores indicating greater parent-child closeness.
Health Service Use, mean difference in number of healthcare use between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 Service use will be assessed by self-reported number of healthcare services accessed (prior to baseline and during the study period) and by examination of Medicare data. Higher numbers will indicate a higher frequency of health care use.
Health behaviours mean differences in summed scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 Questions related to alcohol use and physical activity from the AUDIT-C and Active Australia Study, respectively, have been included. Seven study designed items have been developed to ask fathers about the extent to which they are engaging in positive health behaviours (e.g., had enough rest and sleep, exercised regularly, had time to self, spent time with family, friends, and partner).
The Assessment of Quality of Life 8 dimension, mean difference in preference weighted health related quality of life utility scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms post intervention at week 72 The Assessment of Quality of Life 8 dimension (AQoL-8D), is a validated tool assessing quality of life impacts in the economic evaluation. Australian population normative data are available and will be used to determine preference weighted health related quality of life utility scores ranging from 0-1 with higher scores indicating higher quality of life. The AQoL-8D is particularly suited to measuring mental health aspects of quality of life.
Me as a Parent Scale mean difference in total scale scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms. post intervention at week 72 The Me as a Parent Scale (MaaPS) is a 16-item scale assessing parent beliefs about self-efficacy, personal agency, self-management and self-sufficiency.
Parenting Warmth, hostility and engagement in home learning activities- mean difference in total summed scores between the Working Out Dads and Usual Care arms. post intervention at week 72 Parenting hostility will be assessed using four adapted items from the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study of Children. Fathers will rate how often they engage in hostile behaviours during interactions with their child. Parenting warmth will be assessed using a modified six-item subscale from the Child Rearing Questionnaire. Fathers will indicate how often they feel close to and express affection toward their child. Parental Involvement Scale is a five-item scale taken from the Growing Up in Australia: Longitudinal Study of Australian Children assessing the frequency in which parents have done the following activities with their child: read from a book, told a story (not from a book), played with toys/games indoors (e.g., board/card games), involved them in everyday activities at home (e.g., cooking/caring for pets), and played a game outdoors or exercise together (e.g., walking, swimming).
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
Murdoch Children's Research Institute
🇦🇺Parkville, Victoria, Australia