Health-circuit Evaluation as a Digital Support for the Management of Patients at Risk of Hospitalization
Trial Snapshot
- Phase
- Not Applicable
- Status
- Completed
- Sponsor
- Hospital Clinic of Barcelona
- Enrollment
- 400
- Locations
- 1
- Primary Endpoint
- Unplanned visits
Study Overview
Brief Summary
Background - There is a high potential for hospitalization prevention through: (i) a greater continuity of care, achieved by facilitating collaborative work among professionals at different levels of care, and (ii) improving the self-efficacy of patients. For both objectives, the support of appropriate information and communication technologies is essential. The study raises the hypothesis that an industry 4.0 system, Health-Circuit, based on communication technologies and intelligent collaboration, will facilitate a greater continuity of care and an improvement in patients' self-efficacy.
Objective - Analysis of Health-Circuit's potential for improving the continuity of care and self-efficacy of chronic patients at risk of hospitalization.
Material and methods - Controlled, single-blinded, randomized trial by primary care teams, with a 2:1 intervention-control ratio. The first phase of the study (September-November 2019) will be carried out in 75 patients from the primary care area of Barcelona Esquerra under the influence of Hospital Clínic of Barcelona (CAPSBE, 110k inhabitants). In the intervention group, the patients, and the corresponding healthcare professionals, will communicate and collaborate though Health-Circuit, while the control group will receive conventional treatment. In a second phase (beginning December 2019), the study will be extended to the entire healthcare area of Barcelona Esquerra (AISBE, 520k inhabitants).
Expected results - From a clinical perspective, a reduction in the number of urgent face-to-face visits is expected at: (i) Hospital; (ii) Primary Care, or, (iii) Primary Care Emergency Centers, due to better continuity of care and greater self-efficacy of patients. However, the results sought in Phase I of the study will be, fundamentally: (i) the evaluation of the usability and acceptability of Health-Circuit for patients and professionals, and (ii) the analysis of the potential of the digital tool for the management of complex clinical processes with the help of intelligent bots. In phase II of the study, the central objectives will be (i) increase in the capacity to resolve events, and (ii) improvement of patients' self-efficacy.
Detailed Description
The present investigation develops in the framework of the EU project CONNECARE "Personalized Connected Care for Complex Chronic Patients (H2020 - BHC25 - 689802), whose registration number in the medical research ethics committee of Hospital Clínic of Barcelona is HCB / 2018/0803. CONNECARE assumes that (i) the improvement of the continuity of care, associated with facilitating collaborative work among professionals of different levels of care, and, (ii) the increase in patients' self-efficacy, results in an optimization of the management of chronic patients with the consequent decrease in unplanned consultations, whether at primary care or at the hospital. This necessarily leads to an increase in the resolving capacity of primary care teams and an increase in the prevention of hospitalizations.
Although the role of digital technologies, as an element of support for integrated care services, is well-demonstrated, at present, we still do not have adequate digital tools that provide adequate support for collaborative work between professionals and, in turn, encourage the empowerment for self-management of patients. We understand as such, technologies: (i) compliant with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), (ii) interoperable with existing health information systems, and, that (iii) facilitate the adaptive and collaborative management of chronic patients.
The present study evaluates the potential of an industry 4.0 system, Health-Circuit, based on communication technologies and intelligent collaboration, for the improvement of the management of chronic patients, with the consequent increase of the resolving capacity of the community health teams. Health-Circuit allows patients and professionals to interact, bilaterally or in groups, from various information systems and devices, regardless of their physical location. The base technology platform, Circuit, is robust (TRL 9), located in the cloud (private, mixed or public) and complies with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Circuit allows multimedia corporate communication (chat, call, video-call, file exchange, etc.) between healthcare levels, increasing coordination among professionals with the consequent improvement of health outcomes. Its potential can be increased in the future with the use of intelligent Chatbots to guide patients and professionals through complex care processes, providing decision support for personalised service selection by means of enhanced health risk assessment and patient stratification.
Study Design
- Study Type
- Interventional
- Allocation
- Randomized
- Intervention Model
- Parallel
- Primary Purpose
- Health Services Research
- Masking
- Single (Outcomes Assessor)
Eligibility Criteria
- Ages
- 18 Years to — (Adult, Older Adult)
- Sex
- All
- Accepts Healthy Volunteers
- No
Inclusion Criteria
- •Participation in the SELFIE study.
- •Accepting to participate in the study and sign the consent.
- •In the intervention group, having a "smart phone" or "Tablet" that can support the use of the computer tool (versions of the operating systems Android or iOS compatible with the patient's application) and having an internet connection.
Exclusion Criteria
- •Physical or psychological health problems that prevent the use of the tool and that the patient does not have the help of a caregiver.
Arms & Interventions
Health-Circuit mobile application
The intervention contemplates. (i) management of unexpected events; and, (ii) empowering the patient to improve self-efficacy.
Users of the intervention arm will have the Health-Circuit mobile application, which will offer them the possibility of contacting the case managers to notify a health event at any time and that this can be resolved by their health professionals through Health -Circuit. The improvement of the patient's self-efficacy for the management of their health problems through the use of Health-Circuit is considered through the virtual visits of follow-up with the manager, the possibility of interacting with the manager and the consultation of the shared documents reminders of the action plan agreed with the patient.
Intervention: Health-Circuit mobile application (Behavioral)
Conventional treatment
Patients assigned to this group will follow conventional treatment. Once the three months have passed, we will contact you again to ask the pertinent questions.
Outcomes
Primary Outcomes
Unplanned visits
Time Frame: 3 months
Number of unplanned primary care and hospital visits
Secondary Outcomes
- Duration of the symptom(3 months)
- Number of errors due to the participant's temporary functions(3 months)
- Number of patients who have accessed the conditions of use(3 months)
- Software failures(3 months)
- Equipment failures(3 months)
- Change in the Fantastic Lifestyle questionnaire(3 months)
- Errors in execution(3 months)
- Number of participants in the study with respect to the total of potential participants(3 months)
- Professional mHealth tool usability by the System Usability Scale(3 months)
- Errors due to failures in the organization(3 months)
- Number of entries to the application (app) per patient(3 months)
- Service utilization measures(3 months)
- Change in The Health Empowerment Scale(3 months)
- Number of video calls(3 months)
- Change in Continuity of care within the healthcare system as measured by the Nijmegen Continuity of Care Questionnaire(3 months)
- Professional satisfaction with the mHealth tool assessed by the Net Promoter Score alongside three custom made general satisfaction.(3 months)
- Patient mHealth tool usability assessed by the System Usability Scale(3 months)
- Professional mHealth experience(3 months)
- Number of clinical diagnoses in app users(3 months)
- Degree of severity of the symptom(3 months)
- Number of professionals that the manager has contacted through the app(3 months)
- Number of solutions that has been a classroom visit(3 months)
- Number of contacts with clinical professionals responsible for managing the case(3 months)
- Patient satisfaction with the mHealth tool assessed by the Net Promoter Score alongside three custom made general satisfaction.(3 months)
- Patient mHealth experience(3 months)
- Number of interactions between professionals through the app(3 months)
- Number of referrals to the emergency department regarding the total number of solutions(3 months)
- Number of solutions provided only by the manager(3 months)
- Number of solutions provided by the primary care professional(3 months)
- Number of solutions that has been a virtual visit(3 months)
Investigators
Carmen Herranz
Nurse
Hospital Clinic of Barcelona