OSA-18 in Children With Mild Obstructive Sleep Apnea: Can it be a Helpful Decision Making Tool?
- Conditions
- Apnea, Obstructive SleepObstructive Sleep Apnea
- Interventions
- Other: Decisional Conflict (DCS)Other: OSA-18 Survey
- Registration Number
- NCT05911646
- Lead Sponsor
- Connecticut Children's Medical Center
- Brief Summary
The concept is a novel research idea that incorporates the potential impact of patient quality of life (QOL) on decision-making for treatment of mild obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). Our hypothesis is that in children with mild OSA there is significant conflict with parental decision-making; in the absence of significant sleep apnea, there is limited research regarding comparative efficacy of various treatment options. The impact of a QOL questionnaire can be a significant deciding factor and may help guide management decisions in such situations.
- Detailed Description
This concept is a novel research idea that incorporates the potential impact of patient quality of life (QOL) on decision making for treatment of mild sleep apnea in children between the ages of 3yrs to \<16 years. Previous studies have shown that parents of children with mild OSA experience similar decisional conflict (DC) to those with a more severe disease. The investigators believe it is important to provide caregivers with tools that can aid in decision making and potentially reduce DC when choosing between more than one treatment option, considering research on some of these options is also recent and somewhat limited.
Children with mild OSA may be offered watchful waiting, surgery or medical therapy for initial management. Although surgery results in resolution/improvement in symptoms in the majority of children with mild OSA, recent data also shows encouraging success rates after medical management. A well-designed RCT has also shown that untreated children with non-severe OSA show normalization of PSG with watchful waiting, although they continued to have higher OSA18 scores as compared to those who underwent surgery. This implies that there is a continuing impact on quality of life and warrants inclusion of this information early on in the decision-making process.
When presented with these data, some parents face a conflict deciding between management options and/or may be reluctant to pursue the recommended management option. This is known as "decisional conflict" and is frequently accompanied by emotional distress, which can lead to delays in decision making.
The hypothesis is that in children with mild OSA there is significant conflict in parental decision making, and, in the absence of significant sleep apnea, impact on QOL can be a statistically significant deciding factor and may help guide management decisions in such situations. Investigators propose to use OSA 18, a validated questionnaire that determines the effects of obstructive sleep apnea on pediatric quality of life, and subsequently measure caregivers' decision-making processes through a decisional conflict scale survey. Investigators believe that using this questionnaire may impact decision making for such patients and help reduce the DC.
This will be a randomized controlled trial (RCT).
Identification and Recruitment: Convenience sampling will be used for this study. The clinic lists will be scanned weekly by a member of the study team to identify patients with mild OSA. Consecutive patients/ families, meeting inclusion criteria will be invited to participate. Participants will be approached by a member of the study team on the day of visit or within 1 week of the visit by a telephone call to enlist participation.
Consent/Assent: Verbal consent will be obtained through the phone call and confirmed on the day of clinic visit and documented in the consent documentation form which will be locked away in a secure cabinet and also documented on the network drive. A secure REDCap database will also be used to document verbal consent in the instance that recruitment was done telephonically. Verbal consent will be obtained at the time of recruitment by a study team member. The team member will introduce the study and explain the purpose, the procedures, and how participants are randomly assigned to a group.
Retention: Participation last through the completion of all surveys. The surveys take approximately 5 minutes to complete.
Protocol:
At the start of the visit, families who consented to participate will be given a demographics questionnaire asking about age, race/ethnicity, and health literacy. BMI and sleep study data will also be recorded by a study team member. Following this survey, participants will follow the protocol for the group they are randomly assigned to, either case or control.
Case Group:
If in case group, parents will be asked to complete the OSA18 questionnaire. The total score along with category: mild, moderate or severe will be presented to the families along with scores for various domains. Families will then be provided with a printed form, "decision aid," at the time of consultation with various management options, detailing evidence based risks and benefits for each option. In the case group, this will include the OSA 18 total scores at the bottom this will also help standardized the discussion by the provider.
The decisional conflict scale (DCS) will be filled out at conclusion of visit after the provider has left the room. The DCS is a 16-item survey in which participants are asked to respond to statements related to their decision on a five-point ordinal Likert scale: 0) strongly agree, 1) agree, 2) neither agree nor disagree, 3) disagree, and 4) strongly disagree. Scores are summed, divided by16, and multiplied by 25. Scores range from 0, signifying that the respondent has complete certainty about the best choice, to 100, which signifies that the respondent feels extremely uncertain about the best choice. The validation study indicates that a score ≥ 25 signifies a decisional conflict.
Control Group: Families in the control group will be provided with a printed form, "decision aid," at the time of consultation with various management options, detailing evidence based risks and benefits for each option.
The decisional conflict scale (DCS) will be filled out at conclusion of visit after the provider has left the room. The DCS is a 16-item survey in which participants are asked to respond to statements related to their decision on a five-point ordinal Likert scale: 0) strongly agree, 1) agree, 2) neither agree nor disagree, 3) disagree, and 4) strongly disagree. Scores are summed, divided by16, and multiplied by 25. Scores range from 0, signifying that the respondent has complete certainty about the best choice, to 100, which signifies that the respondent feels extremely uncertain about the best choice. The validation study indicates that a score ≥ 25 signifies a decisional conflict.
Responses from all participants will be stored securely in a de-identifiable manner.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- RECRUITING
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 130
- Parent/caregiver of child with an initial diagnosis mild obstructive sleep apnea defined as polysomnography AHI score between 1 and 5
- Parent/caregiver of child between 3 and 12 years of age
- Parent/caregiver of child who has been diagnosed with tonsillar hypertrophy grade 2 or higher
- Parent/caregiver of child diagnosed with a syndromic or known neurologic condition and/or multiple (more than two) medical cardiac or respiratory medical conditions
- Parent/caregiver of child who has previously underwent tonsillectomy
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Control Group Decisional Conflict (DCS) During the consultation, families will be given a printed form, "decisional aid," which is given to families to explain treatment options as well as their risks and benefits. The consultation will proceed as normal according to standard of care with the aid being used to guide conversation. After the consultation is complete and the provider leaves the room, families will be given a decisional conflict scale survey to complete. All surveys will remain anonymous and only a unique study identification number will be placed on the surveys to correctly match each survey. Forms will be placed in a locked box by parents prior to departure from the exam room. OSA-18 Case Group Decisional Conflict (DCS) Case group participants will be given the OSA-18 survey at the start of their consultation. OSA-18 is an 18-item questionnaire that collects information about 5 subscales that are considered to be elements in quality of life: sleep disturbance, physical symptoms, emotional symptoms, daytime function, and caregiver concerns. The score is calculated that ranges from 18 (no impact on quality of life) to 126 (major negative impact). Upon completion of OSA-18, scores are tabulated and relayed to families through a decisional aid. The score and the aid, which explains treatment options, risks and benefits will be used to guide discussion throughout the consultation. After the consultation is complete and the provider leaves the room, families will be given a decisional conflict scale survey. All surveys will remain anonymous by using a unique study identifier. Forms will be placed in a locked box by parents prior to departure from the exam room. OSA-18 Case Group OSA-18 Survey Case group participants will be given the OSA-18 survey at the start of their consultation. OSA-18 is an 18-item questionnaire that collects information about 5 subscales that are considered to be elements in quality of life: sleep disturbance, physical symptoms, emotional symptoms, daytime function, and caregiver concerns. The score is calculated that ranges from 18 (no impact on quality of life) to 126 (major negative impact). Upon completion of OSA-18, scores are tabulated and relayed to families through a decisional aid. The score and the aid, which explains treatment options, risks and benefits will be used to guide discussion throughout the consultation. After the consultation is complete and the provider leaves the room, families will be given a decisional conflict scale survey. All surveys will remain anonymous by using a unique study identifier. Forms will be placed in a locked box by parents prior to departure from the exam room.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS) Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes The Decisional Conflict Scale (DCS) is a survey administered to both the experimental and active comparator evaluating the degree of conflict a caregiver feels when determining a treatment option. The minimum score is 0 (indicating no decisional conflict) and the maximum score is 100 (indicating significant decisional conflict).
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Race/Ethnicity of child and parent/legal guardian Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes * American Indian or Alaska Native
* Asian
* Black or African American
* Hispanic or Latino
* Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander
* White
* Prefer not to answerGender of child and parent/legal guardian Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes * Male
* Female
* Intersex
* None of these describe my child
* Prefer not to answerBMI Z-score Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes number value of BMI z-score
BMI percentile Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes BMI reported as kg/m\^2 will be reported as a percent based on the growth chart.
Polysomnography (PSG) (Sleep Study Data), AHI Through study completion, and average of 3 months Apnea Hypopnea Index (AHI) will be recorded from the PSG. Value is reported as a real number.
Polysomnography (PSG) (Sleep Study Data), OAHI Through study completion, and average of 3 months Obstructive apnea hypopnea index (OAHI) will be recorded from the PSG. Values is reported as a real number.
Polysomnography (PSG) (Sleep Study Data), high CO2 occurrences Through study completion, and average of 3 months The number of times the patient has a CO2 level of \>50mmHG during the course of the sleep study will be recorded.
Polysomnography (PSG) (Sleep Study Data), minimum oxygen saturation Through study completion, and average of 3 months The lowest oxygen saturation of the patient during the sleep study, sometimes called nadir O2, will be recorded.
Age of child and parent/legal guardian Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes years
Parent/legal guardian identified health care literacy and comfort completing medical forms. Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes * Extremely
* Quite a bit
* Somewhat
* A little bit
* Not at allSelected Treatment Option Through clinical visit, an average of 30 minutes Parent/Caregiver will choose between surgery, medication, watchful waiting, or undecided at their regularly scheduled clinical visit.
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
Connecticut Children's Medical Center
🇺🇸Hartford, Connecticut, United States