Ultrasound - Guided Paramedian Techniques in Spinal Anesthesia
- Conditions
- Anaesthesia
- Interventions
- Procedure: Conventional landmark guided midline spinal anaestheticProcedure: pre-procedure ultrasound guided paramedian spinal
- Registration Number
- NCT02171975
- Lead Sponsor
- Cork University Hospital
- Brief Summary
Multiple passes and attempts while administering spinal anesthesia are associated with a greater incidence of post dural-puncture headache, paraesthesia and spinal hematoma. The investigators hypothesised that the routine use of pre-procedural ultrasound-guided paramedian spinals reduces the number of passes required to achieve enter the subarachnoid space when compared to the conventional landmark-guided midline approach.
- Detailed Description
Spinal anesthesia is widely performed using a surface landmark based 'blind' technique. Multiple passes and attempts while administering spinal anesthesia are associated with a greater incidence of post dural-puncture headache, paraesthesia and spinal hematoma.
Real time and pre-procedural neuraxial ultrasound techniques have been used to improve the success rate of spinal anesthesia. The use of real time ultrasound-guided spinal anesthesia has to date been limited to case series and case reports. Its use may be limited by the requirement for wide bore needles and the technical difficulties associated with simultaneous ultrasound scanning and needle advancement. The use of pre-procedural ultrasound has been shown to increase the first pass success rate for spinal anesthesia only in patients with difficult surface anatomic landmarks.No technique has been shown to improve the success rate of dural puncture when applied routinely to all patients.
Studies on pre-procedural ultrasound-guided spinal techniques are limited to a midline approach using a transverse median view (TM). The parasagittal oblique (PSO) view consistently offers better ultrasound view of the neuraxis compared to TM views. However no studies have been conducted to assess whether these superior PSO views translate into easier paramedian needle insertion.
We hypothesised that the routine use of pre-procedural ultrasound-guided paramedian spinal technique results in less number of passes required to enter the subarachnoid space when compared to the conventional landmark based midline approach.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- COMPLETED
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 100
- all consented patients scheduled to undergo elective total knee or total hip arthroplasty under spinal anesthesia were included in the study.
- Patients with contraindications to spinal anesthesia (allergy to local anesthetic, coagulopathy, local infection and indeterminate neurological disease) were excluded from the study.
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Group C Conventional landmark guided midline spinal anaesthetic Patients in this group underwent Conventional landmark guided midline spinal anaesthetic. Group P pre-procedure ultrasound guided paramedian spinal This group had their spinal anaesthetic done based on pre-procedure ultrasound guided paramedian spinal
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Number of passes Up to 45 minutes from the start of insertion of spinal needled for administration of spinal anaesthetic The number of passes, defined as the number of forward advancements of the spinal needle in a given interspinous space (i.e. withdrawal and redirection of spinal needle without exiting the skin)
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Time for identifying landmarks Up to 10 minutes fraom start of plapating for landmarks - Completed once anethetist declares that markings are complete Time for identifying landmarks in group C was defined as time from which the anesthesiologist started palpating to identify the landmarks to completion of the process as declared by the anesthesiologist. In group P it was defined as time from which the ultrasound probe was placed on the skin to the anesthesiologist declaring that the markings are completed
Time taken for performing spinal anesthetic Up to 45 minutes from the start of insertion of spinal needled for administration of spinal anaesthetic defined as time taken from insertion of introducer needle to completion of injection
Incidence of radicular pain Up to 24 hours after administration of spinal anaesthetic Shooting pain going down along one of the dermatomal levels in the leg
Number of spinal needle insertion attempts Up to 45 minutes from the start of insertion of spinal needled for administration of spinal anaesthetic number of spinal needle insertion attempts (defined as the number of times the spinal needle was withdrawn from the skin and reinserted) were noted
Blood in spinal needle Up to 45 minutes from the start of insertion of spinal needled for administration of spinal anaesthetic Presence of blood in spinal needle
Presence of paresthesia Up to 24 hours after administration of spinal anaesthetic Paresthesia along dermatomal distribution during performing spinal anaesthetic
Grading of palpated landmarks Up to 10 minutes fraom start of plapating for landmarks - Completed once anethetist declares that markings are complete Anesthesiologist palpated the landmarks after positioning and graded the ease of palpation on a 4 point scale (easy, moderate, difficult or impossible)
Peri-procedural VAS scores of pain at injection site up to 30 minutes following spinal anaesthetic injection and prior to sedation After positioning and prior to administration of sedation, patients were asked for their peri-procedural pain scores measured using an 11 point verbal rating scale (0=no pain, 10=most pain imaginable)
peri-procedural discomfort scores up to 30 minutes following spinal anaesthetic injection and prior to sedation peri-procedural discomfort scores measured using an 11 point verbal rating measured (0= no discomfort, 10=most discomfort imaginable).
Level of block 15 minutes after spinal anaesthetic injection Dermatomal level at which loss of cold sensation (ethyl chloride spray) occurs
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
South Infirmary Victoria University Hospital
🇮🇪Cork, Ireland