A Study Comparing Bi-parametric MRI to Multi-parametric MRI in the Diagnosis of Clinically Significant Prostate Cancer

Brief Summary

Detailed Description

The PRECISION study (NCT02380027) has established that multiparametric MRI +/- targeted biopsy of suspicious areas identified on MRI is superior to standard 12 core TRUS biopsy in the detection of clinically significant prostate cancer (Gleason \> 3+ 4) (38% vs 26%), in reducing the detection of clinically insignificant prostate cancer (Gleason 3 + 3) (9% vs 22%) and in maximising the proportion of cores positive for prostate cancer (44% vs 19%). Multiparametric MRI (mpMRI) typically uses T2-weighted (T2W), diffusion-weighted (DWI) and dynamic contrast enhanced (DCE) sequences. As a mpMRI is a precious resource, due to capacity and resource limitations, one of the major challenges across institutions is delivering a health service with pre-biopsy MRI before a biopsy in all men with suspected prostate cancer. However, biparametric MRI (bpMRI), that is, a combination of T2W and DWI, which does not use the DCE sequences, has demonstrated similar detection rates of prostate cancer as mpMRI in some studies and there is a debate about the necessity of the DCE sequence. The potential advantages of avoiding the DCE sequence include avoiding the cost associated with it, shorter scan time, avoiding the need for medical practitioner attendance, and avoiding putative basal ganglia accumulation and the possibility of adverse neurological effect. Thus, a bpMRI approach may be more feasible and have health-economic benefits over a mpMRI approach and may thus increase the accessibility of this resource to men who need it. PRIME is a multi-centre study. Men referred with clinical suspicion of prostate cancer based on raised prostate specific antigen (PSA) or abnormal digital rectal examination (DRE) who have had no prior biopsy undergo mpMRI. The DCE sequence is blinded from the radiologist who reports the bpMRI first. After reporting the bpMRI, the DCE sequence is made available to the radiologist who reports the mpMRI. The MRIs and lesions are scored on 1-5 scales of suspicion for the likelihood that clinically significant cancer is present: 1. - Very low (clinically significant cancer is highly unlikely to be present) 2. - Low (clinically significant cancer is unlikely to be present) 3. - Intermediate (the presence of clinically significant cancer is equivocal) 4. - High (clinically significant cancer is likely to be present) 5. - Very high (clinically significant cancer is highly likely to be present) Men with non-suspicious MRI on bpMRI and mpMRI and low clinical risk of prostate cancer will be counselled by their clinical teams as per routine clinical care. In routine clinical practice these men typically do not undergo prostate biopsy. Suspicious areas scoring 3, 4 or 5 on either bpMRI or mpMRI will undergo targeted and systematic biopsy using the information from the mpMRI to influence biopsy conduct. Suspicious areas will be labelled by their MRI score, with their location according to sector diagrams. The proportion of patients with clinically significant prostate cancer will be ascertained and compared between bpMRI and mpMRI. Treatment eligibility decisions without the DCE information will be made and once the clinicians are unblinded to the DCE sequence the impact that this information makes on the treatment decision will be evaluated.

Primary Outcomes

Secondary Outcomes

• Agreement between bpMRI and mpMRI for radiological staging decision(When MRI results available, at an expected average of 30 days post-MRI)
• Cost-effectiveness of BpMRI compared to mpMRI (cost per diagnosis of prostate cancer)(At an expected average of 30 days post-intervention)
• Agreement between bpMRI and mpMRI for score of suspicion(When MRI results available, at an expected average of 30 days post-MRI)
• Test performance characteristics for bpMRI & mpMRI when using the Likert scoring system in comparison to the PIRADS scoring system(When biopsy results available, at an expected average of 30 days post-MRI)
• Proportion of men with clinically insignificant cancer (Gleason grade 3+3 / Gleason grade group 1)(When biopsy results available, at an expected average of 30 days post-biopsy)
• Agreement between bpMRI and mpMRI for treatment eligibility(When treatment options discussed in multidisciplinary meeting, at an expected average of 30 days post intervention)
• Proportion of men with cancer missed by bpMRI and mpMRI-targeted biopsies and detected by systematic biopsy(When biopsy results available, at an expected average of 30 days post-biopsy)