Skip to main content
Clinical Trials/NCT07204119
NCT07204119RecruitingNot Applicable

Official Title: Comparison of Graston Technique With Tissue Flossing Technique in Patient With Post-Operative Knee Stiffness

Riphah International University1 site in 1 country48 target enrollmentStarted: February 12, 2025Last updated:
Conditions
Interventions

Trial Snapshot

Phase
Not Applicable
Status
Recruiting
Enrollment
48
Locations
1
Primary Endpoint
Range of Motion:

Study Overview

Brief Summary

The purpose of this study was to compare the effects of Graston Technique and Tissue Flossing Technique in patients with post-operative knee stiffness on pain, range of motion, and functional outcomes. A randomized controlled trial was conducted at Benazir Bhutto Hospital, Rawalpindi. The total sample size was 48, divided into three groups. The study duration was six months. Purposive sampling was applied for recruitment, and group randomization was performed by lottery method. Only patients with post-operative knee stiffness meeting the inclusion criteria were enrolled. Outcome measures included goniometer, Functional Independence Measure (FIM), and Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index (WOMAC) questionnaires. Data was collected at baseline and after interventions, and analysis was performed using SPSS version 23.

Detailed Description

Stiffness has been defined as a decrease in postoperative range of motion (ROM), including flexion contracture, accompanied by persistent pain and/or functional compromise (1). Post-traumatic stiffness may result from dense intra-articular adhesions and fibrotic transformation of periarticular structures (2). The knee joint, crucial for lower-limb biomechanics, is the most frequently injured joint in the lower extremities (3). Post-traumatic knee stiffness and loss of ROM are common complications following knee injuries. The normal ROM of the knee joint is generally accepted to be 0° (full extension) to 135° (full flexion). A stiff knee is defined as one with a total ROM of less than 50°, while an ankylosed knee is characterized by a ROM of less than 30° (4). Knee joint stiffness may result from several factors, including periarticular surgeries, traumatic injuries, inflammatory or infectious joint diseases, fractures, prolonged immobilization, and scar formation due to burns or trauma. Post-surgical procedures such as open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) may also contribute to stiffness through scar tissue formation and reduced joint mobility (5). The choice of fixation method for femoral or tibial fractures depends on the fracture type and anatomical location. For femoral shaft fractures, intramedullary (IM) nailing is considered the gold standard. Stabilization of femoral or tibial fractures can also be achieved through ORIF using screws, plates, or rods. In cases with compromised skin integrity at the fracture site, external fixation provides a temporary solution, using external frames to align the bones (6) Diagnosis of post-operative knee stiffness is based on reduced knee flexion and extension after surgery, commonly following ORIF of femur, tibia, or fibula fractures. Literature defines stiffness as total knee ROM <50° and ankylosis when <30°. Clinical judgment with goniometric assessment and functional evaluation using WOMAC and FIM questionnaires provides valid measures. Previous studies suggest intra-articular adhesions, fibrotic changes, and prolonged immobilization as primary contributors to post-operative knee stiffness.

Various therapeutic interventions have been developed to address this issue, myofascial compression technique, i.e., Graston Technique and tissue flossing emerging as promising approaches. The Graston Technique (GT) is a therapeutic approach known as instrument-assisted soft tissue mobilization (IASTM). GT uses specialized tools to massage and scrape the skin, reducing pain and targeting tissue restrictions that cause dysfunction. The Graston Technique supports soft tissue healing by enhancing blood flow (vasodilation) to the affected area, which can accelerate recovery and reduce stiffness (7).

The Graston Technique, instrument-assisted soft tissue mobilization (IASTM), has shown efficacy in improving range of motion and reducing pain in various musculoskeletal conditions. Studies have demonstrated its effectiveness in treating chronic low back pain, with significant improvements in pain reduction and increased range of motion compared to general exercise alone (8).

The technique has also been found to be beneficial in addressing postoperative elbow stiffness, showing greater improvements in pain reduction and patient-specific function compared to other soft tissue mobilization techniques (9)

. For instance, a study on patients with anterior knee pain found that IASTM techniques, including the Graston Technique, were as effective as stretching exercises in reducing pain, improving flexibility, and enhancing lower extremity function in patients with iliotibial band tightness (10).

Study Design

Study Type
Interventional
Allocation
Randomized
Intervention Model
Parallel
Primary Purpose
Treatment
Masking
Single (Participant)

Eligibility Criteria

Ages
20 Years to 40 Years (Adult)
Sex
All
Accepts Healthy Volunteers
No

Inclusion Criteria

  • •Age group between 20 to 40 years.
  • •Both male and female.
  • •Patients with 6 weeks post-operative following open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) of femur, tibia, or fibula shaft fracture
  • •Decreased in knee Flexion & Extension (A minimum of 20° or above).

Exclusion Criteria

  • •Those patients who have allergies to latex
  • •Malignant or metabolic cause of knee fracture
  • •Venous Thrombotic disease/ Varicose veins.
  • •Cardiopulmonary illness and hypertension.
  • •Skin diseases/ metabolic disorders.
  • •Patient with arthroplasty and arthroscopy.
  • •Patellar fracture/ ACL/ PCL/ MCL/ LCL rupture/ injuries.
  • •Any pathological condition having effects on knees.

Arms & Interventions

Tissue Flossing Technique

Experimental

Hot pack: 10 minutes, PNF (hold-relax with agonist contraction), CPM: 10 minutes, Self-stretching: End range position for 30 seconds, repeat twice.

1 to 2 minutes for Tissue Flossing Technique Description: Active and passive movement with knee wrapped in a high-quality floss band (208×5×0.15 cm), Wrapped from upper gastrocnemius to lower quadriceps and hamstring muscles using a 50% overlapping pattern with a 25% elongation stretch, Series of active and passive exercises (knee flexion and extension) with 3 repetitions.

Intervention: Tissue Flossing Technique (Other)

Graston Technique

Experimental

Hot pack: 10 minutes, PNF (hold-relax with agonist contraction), CPM: 10 minutes, Self-stretching: End range position for 30 seconds, repeat twice.

2 minutes for Graston Technique Technique Description: Participant lies supine with hip and knee straight, Water-based gel used to reduce friction.

Superior and inferior longitudinal strokes delivered with GT-4 instrument at a 45° angle to soft tissues Sequence includes strokes from above patella to anterior inferior iliac spine (AIIS) and back, maintaining a 2-second cadence

Intervention: Graston Technique (Other)

Control group

Active Comparator

Hot pack: 10 minutes

  • PNF (hold-relax with agonist contraction): Gentle stretch of knee muscle for 10 seconds Isometric contraction for 6 seconds. Flex knee with therapist assistance. Hold position for 10 seconds, repeat 3 times
  • CPM: 10 minutes
  • Self-stretching: End range position for 30 seconds, repeat twice

Intervention: Control group (Other)

Outcomes

Primary Outcomes

Range of Motion:

Time Frame: 2 weeks

Range of motion (ROM) is the extent of movement possible at a joint or body part. It's the arc of motion a joint can travel, typically measured in degrees using a goniometer. Healthy ROM allows for comfortable movement, while limitations can lead to pain and reduced function.

Secondary Outcomes

  • Numerated Pain Rating Scale:(2 weeks)
  • Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index(2 weeks)
  • Functional Independence Measure:(2 weeks)

Investigators

Sponsor Class
Other
Responsible Party
Sponsor

Study Sites (1)

Loading locations...

Similar Trials