Determining the Effectiveness of Aquatic Exercise in Comparison to Land-based Exercise for Canadian Military Veterans Experiencing Chronic Lower Extremity Musculoskeletal Pain: A Feasibility Study for a Randomized Clinical Trial

As of March 31, 2020, Veterans Affairs Canada estimated the total Veteran population in Canada to be 629,300. It has been reported that 41 percent of Veterans experience constant pain or discomfort, which is close to double the 22 percent reported by the Canadian population. Pain is a complex phenomenon that involves biological, psychological, and social determinants and impacts. Evidence suggests Veterans have unique pain management needs and evaluation of interventions is urgently needed to address the complex needs of Canadian Military Veterans living with chronic pain.

Aquatic therapy is a possible treatment option that may improve outcomes in military Veterans with chronic pain. Aquatic therapy has previously been shown to decrease pain, improve function or disability, increase quality of life, and improve health-related fitness measures . Most of the research showing effectiveness of aquatic therapy for musculoskeletal pain conditions has involved comparing aquatic therapy to a control group; however, a control group does not accurately reflect current best practice for people with lower extremity musculoskeletal pain. Clinical practice guidelines suggest physical activity and exercise interventions as first-line treatment for people with lower extremity musculoskeletal pain, but do not provide direction on what type of exercise is most effective for people with lower extremity pain. Building on existing research by comparing aquatic therapy to a land-based exercise comparison will provide a more robust evaluation of the effectiveness to inform clinical practice guidelines. Additionally, given their unique health needs, there is a need for evidence specific to the military Veteran population.

To date, there have been eight randomized clinical trials comparing aquatic exercise to land-based exercise on function or disability for people with lower extremity musculoskeletal pain. While meta-analyses reveal no difference between these two groups in pain, function, and quality of life, this body of research is limited by small sample sizes and risks of bias, making it difficult to draw conclusions and apply the evidence of effectiveness in practice. There are opportunities to improve rigor by reducing the risk of bias (e.g., most studies did not describe allocation concealment) and conducting a fully powered trial. Additionally, important differences between groups in satisfaction of participants and a gap in terms of understanding the experiences are emerging. Further research on the experiences and perspectives of participants is needed. Most importantly, there have been no studies on the effectiveness or experiences of aquatic therapy among Canadian Military Veterans living with pain. Given the unique needs of this population, evidence specific to this group is needed in order to inform service delivery.

Prior to conducting a fully powered trial, there is a need for a pilot study to determine the feasibility of carrying out the interventions and trial procedures. Primarily, the ability to recruit Canadian Military Veterans who live with chronic pain into the study and to determine if participants have the opportunity to book and attend two sessions per week for eight weeks.

Objectives: