Comparison of Spencer Technique and Gongs Mobilization on Pain, Range of Motion, Disability and Scapular Symmetry in Patients With Phase ii Adhesive Capsulitis
Trial Snapshot
- Phase
- Not Applicable
- Enrollment
- 44
- Locations
- 4
- Primary Endpoint
- NUMERIC PAIN RATING SCALE
Study Overview
Brief Summary
Adhesive capsulitis can be defined as insidious and progressive loss of both active and passive shoulder mobility in the glenohumeral joint presumably due to capsular contracture. It is associated with inflammation and stiffness of the capsule surrounding the glenohumeral joint, greatly restricting motion and causing chronic pain. The objective of this study is to compare the effects of spencer technique and gongs mobilization on pain, range of motion, disability, and scapular symmetry in patients with phase II adhesive capsulitis.
This study will be a Randomized Clinical trial involving 48 patients both males and females aged 40 to 60 years clinically diagnosed cases of phase II adhesive capsulitis. Patients will be randomly assigned into two groups using consecutive sampling technique. Group A will be treated with conventional treatment and spencer technique whereas Group B will be treated with conventional treatment and gongs mobilization. Numeric Pain Rating Scale will be used to measure pain of patients. Shoulder Pain and Disability Index score will be used to ask some questions related to patient's symptoms and disability. Lateral scapular slide test will be used to measure scapular symmetry and universal goniometer will be used to measure range of motion of shoulder joint. Each session will be repeated for 40 minutes thrice a week. All participants of the study will fill the Numeric Pain Rating Scale and Shoulder Pain and Disability Index score on day 1 as pretreatment values and at the end of 4th week as post treatment values respectively. The collected data will be analyzed on SPSS - 25.
Key words: Adhesive, scapula, mobilizations, glenohumeral joint, pain
Detailed Description
Adhesive capsulitis is characterized by a painful, gradual loss of both active and passive glenohumeral motion resulting from progressive fibrosis and ultimate contracture of the glenohumeral joint capsule. The term "frozen shoulder" was first introduced by Codman in 1934. He described frozen shoulder as a painful shoulder condition of insidious onset that was associated with stiffness and difficulty in sleeping on the affected side. In the general population, the incidence of adhesive capsulitis is 2-5%, more in females, those aged 40-65 years and those suffering from diabetes mellitus. In Pakistan, its precise prevalence is unknown, but, in general, it ranges 2-5%.
An increased incidence of frozen shoulder has been noticed in patients with hyperthyroidism and hypertriglyceridemia. Frozen shoulder progressive through three clinical phases painful phase- severe pain usually worst at night and when lying on the affected side (2-9 months) are stiffening or frozen phase- difficulty with simple activities of daily living. Stiffness progresses and leads to disused atrophy (4-12 months) Thawing phase - gradual increase in range of motion and improvement in pain, although it may reappear as stiffness ceases (5-12 months). In pathological condition like adhesive capsulitis where there is presence of capsular pattern of glenohumeral joint, in such a condition it is not possible to achieve full abduction through elevation because of marked limitation of external rotation.
Adhesive capsulitis is primarily categorized into two types: primary and secondary. Primary or idiopathic adhesive capsulitis is characterized by a gradual onset of pain and stiffness at the gleno-humeral joint without a specific cause. Secondary adhesive capsulitis is known to be caused by several predisposing factors. Women are affected more than men with a ratio of 58:423. The spencer technique is developed by spencer D. O. in 1916. This approach is a well-known osteopathic manipulative technique that focuses on mobilization of the glenohumeral and scapulothoracic joints. It helps the restricted joints to improve their functions, as well as positively affects other emotional, social, and cognitive areas. Spencer technique is an articulatory technique with 6 different procedures used to treat shoulder restriction caused by adhesive capsulitis. In this technique passive, smooth, rhythmic motion is designed to stretch contracted muscles, ligaments and capsules.
Physiotherapy methods such as active and active assisted exercises, pendular exercises, wand exercises, wall and ladder exercises, capsular stretching exercises and shoulder joint mobilization are often standard exercises in treating frozen shoulder. Electrotherapy modalities such as application of ultrasound, short-wave diathermy and LASER are used to relieve pain and promote hyperthermic effect to tissues.
Joint Mobilization is a manual therapy that applies passive traction and gliding motion to the articular surface to maintain free mobility of joints or to restore the normal condition of joints . Gong's mobilization technique helps to heal physical pain as well as distract the mind from stress. It is a corrective antero-posterior glide applied for shoulder distraction and their restricted movements to decrease pain and to improve range of motion. According to Wontae gong, gong's mobilization is more effective for anterior to posterior glide to improve shoulder abduction, external and internal rotation. Joint mobilization technique is effective to reduce pain and improves range of motion.
Study Design
- Study Type
- Interventional
- Allocation
- Randomized
- Intervention Model
- Parallel
- Primary Purpose
- Treatment
- Masking
- Single (Outcomes Assessor)
Eligibility Criteria
- Ages
- 40 Years to 60 Years (Adult)
- Sex
- All
- Accepts Healthy Volunteers
- No
Inclusion Criteria
- •Patients of age group between 40-60 years.
- •Both Males and Females.
- •Clinically diagnosed patients of phase II adhesive capsulitis will be included.
- •Adhesive Capsulitis subjects with limited Range of motion of shoulder abduction and external rotation.
- •Subjects with bilateral/unilateral adhesive capsulitis.
Exclusion Criteria
- •Recent history of surgery on particular shoulder.
- •Patients with rotator cuff tears.
- •Rheumatoid and gouty arthritis.
- •Tumors of the shoulder region.
- •Subjects with acute inflammation.
- •Recent shoulder dislocation
Outcomes
Primary Outcomes
NUMERIC PAIN RATING SCALE
Time Frame: 4 weeks
Numeric pain rating scale is a measurement of pain intensity in adults. The NPRS is a segmented numeric version of visual analogue scale (VAS) in which respondent select a whole number (0 to 10) that best reflects the intensity of pain. Scores range from 0 to 10
UNIVERSAL GONIOMETER
Time Frame: 4 weeks
Active and passive abduction (in the frontal plane) and external rotation (with the arm at 0 degrees of abduction) ROM measured with a conventional goniometer as per the guidelines given by the American Academy of Orthopedic Surgeons. Goniometric measurements are highly reliable provided measurements are conducted by same therapist (test-retest reliability: 0.94-0.98)
LATERAL SCAPULAR SLIDE TEST
Time Frame: 4 weeks
Three positions are measured with the LSST designed by Kibler, is used to assess the scapular asymmetry under varying loads. To maintain a consistent posture during the various test positions, participants are instructed to fix their eyes on an object in the examination area. First test position, the participant is instructed to keep the arms relaxed at his/her sides, the most inferior aspect of the inferior angle of the scapula and the closest spinous process in the same horizontal plane is identified through palpation and marked. The distance between the 2 reference points is measured bilaterally with the help of a tape measure. This procedure is repeated for test position 2 (participant actively placed both hands on the ipsilateral hips, and consequently the humerus is positioned in medial rotation at -45° of abduction in the coronal plane) and test position 3 (the participant is instructed to maintain thumbs down position
SHOULDER PAIN AND DISABILITY INDEX (SPADI)
Time Frame: 4 weeks
SPADI 5 is a self-administered, shoulder-specific, fixed object index composed of 13 items divided into two subscales: pain (five items) and impairment (eight items). Responses to each item were recorded on a 10 point Likert scale, where 0= no pain or no difficulty and 10 =worst imaginable pain or so difficult it required help for the pain and disability items, respectively. The SPADI score is calculated by summing and then averaging the items of the two subscales to give a score out of 100 (higher scores reflects more pain/disability). The SPADI has acceptable test-retest reliability (intraclass correlation coefficients of 0.91 and 0.65 (95% CI, 0.42 to 0.8) in surgical and primary care populations respectively) and acceptable responsiveness
Secondary Outcomes
No secondary outcomes reported
