CT Colonography as the Initial Diagnostic Imaging Tool for Patients With Suspected Colorectal Cancer
- Conditions
- Colorectal Cancer
- Interventions
- Procedure: Optical colonoscopyProcedure: CTC
- Registration Number
- NCT02820389
- Lead Sponsor
- Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust
- Brief Summary
This study aims to evaluate whether the use of Computed Tomography Colonography (CTC) for patients with low to intermediate risk of suspected colorectal cancer decreases overall NHS costs and waiting times whilst increasing patient satisfaction compared to clinical practice with utilisation of Optical Colonoscopy.
- Detailed Description
Given the recent change in the NICE guidance for the cancer pathway referral for patients with suspected colorectal cancer (See NG12), there will be an increase in demand for optical colonoscopy. Optical colonoscopy is technically difficult, resource intensive and associated with complications; therefore the increased use of CT Colonography (CTC) should be considered as an alternative. The diagnostic efficacy of CTC, in comparison to optical colonoscopy, is well established and has been shown to be accurate for identifying malignancies and medium to large polyps (≥6mm) with a greater level of patient acceptability.
The use of CTC as the first diagnostic imaging tool would identify those patients who would benefit from further investigation (colonoscopy or flexible sigmoidoscopy) to occur on the same day, as well as ruling out those who do not require further testing. This would then ensure that colonoscopy capacity can be prioritised appropriately to support the increase in demand due to the NICE guidance changes.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- UNKNOWN
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 246
- Every adult patient over 40 years old, presenting with constipation or alternating change in bowel habits, with a differential diagnosis of suspected colorectal cancer.
- Patients presenting with anaemia;
- Patients presenting with diarrhoea only for more than 6 weeks;
- Patients presenting with rectal bleeding;
- Patients who have undergone a previous whole-colon examination in the past 6 months;
- Patients who have been referred for a whole-colon examination to follow up already diagnosed colorectal cancer;
- Patients lacking capacity to give consent or participate in the study;
- Patients already taking part in any clinical trial of an investigational medicinal product (CTIMP);
- Prisoners
- Patients who are not fluent in English.
Study & Design
- Study Type
- OBSERVATIONAL
- Study Design
- Not specified
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Optical colonoscopy Optical colonoscopy Patients with suspected colorectal cancer will undergo optical colonoscopy as the initial imaging modality. CT Colonography CTC Patients with suspected colorectal cancer will undergo Computed Tomography Colonography (CTC) as the initial imaging modality. Subsequent imaging might be required based on the findings from the CTC scan.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method 3-month cost analysis per patient undergoing either Optical Colonoscopy or CTC as the initial imaging modality (measured in £ per patient) 3 months following the initial imaging modality (either CTC or Optical Colonoscopy) The primary outcome of this study is to investigate whether the investigation of patients with suspected colorectal cancer using CTC as the first diagnostic imaging tool is cost-saving at 3 months compared to optical colonoscopy.
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method 6-month cost-effectiveness analysis per patient undergoing either CTC or Optical 6 months following the initial imaging modality (either CTC or Optical Colonoscopy) This secondary objective is aimed at evaluating whether the use of CTC as the initial imaging modality for patients with suspected colorectal cancer is cost-effective at 6 months compared to the use of Optical Colonoscopy.
Likelihood ratio of CTC as the initial diagnostic imaging tool against the optical colonoscopy in patients with initial positive CTC findings for medium to large polyps and colorectal cancer (estimated using the p-value) 3 months The likelihood ratio of CTC against colonoscopy in patients with initial positive CTC findings will be assessed using Colonoscopy as the gold standard.
Patient satisfaction associated with both clinical pathways (i.e. using CTC or Optical Colonoscopy as the initial imaging scan) 3 months To evaluate and compare the levels of patient satisfaction associated with the two pathways: i) with CTC as the initial imaging scan; and ii) with Optical Colonoscopy as the initial imaging scan. Two patient satisfaction questionnaires (on the day and 3 months following the CTC/Optical Colonoscopy test) will be used to quantify patient satisfaction.
Patient's self perceived quality of life - measured using EQ-5D-5L questionnaire 3 months This objective aims to evaluate the patient's self-perceived quality of life associated with both pathways using a standard questionnaire (EQ-5D-5L).
6-month cost analysis per patient undergoing either Optical Colonoscopy or CTC as the initial imaging modality (measured in £ per patient) 6 months following the initial imaging modality (either CTC or Optical Colonoscopy) This secondary outcome aims to investigate whether the investigation of patients with suspected colorectal cancer using CTC as the first diagnostic imaging tool is cost-saving at 6 months compared to optical colonoscopy.
Do not Attend (DNA) or On the Day Cancellation rate associated with the pathway using Colonoscopy or CTC as the initial imaging test (measured as a percentage) Day 0 (on the day of the CTC or Optical Colonoscopy scan) This objective aims to estimate the Do not Attend (DNA) or On the Day Cancellation (ODC) rate associated with the pathway using Colonoscopy or CTC as the initial imaging test. Given that the bowel preparation associated with CTC is easily tolerated, it is anticipated that the increase in CTC utilisation will lead to a decrease in DNA and ODC rates.
3-month cost-effectiveness analysis per patient undergoing either CTC or Optical Colonoscopy as the initial imaging modality (measured in £ per QALY) 3 months following the initial imaging modality (either CTC or Optical Colonoscopy) This secondary objective is aimed at evaluating whether the use of CTC as the initial imaging modality for patients with suspected colorectal cancer is cost-effective at 3 months compared to the use of Optical Colonoscopy.
Time taken (measured in days) to reach a definitive diagnosis and first major treatment decision based on the the initial CTC scan in comparison to Optical Colonoscopy as the initial imaging modality. 3 months This objective will measure the time elapsed from the referral to either Colonoscopy or CTC and the time: 1) the test is actually performed; 2) a definitive diagnosis is reached (Optical Colonoscopy will be considered the gold standard for patients presenting positive findings in the initial CTC); and 3) the treatment decision is reached.
Frequency of incidental findings using CTC as the initial diagnostic imaging tool (measured as a %, number of patients with incidental findings in CTC / number of CTC scans) Day 0 (following the initial CTC scan) CTC has the potential to investigate other intra-abdominal organs that are not seen with optical colonoscopy. Hence, CTC scans might lead to extracolonic findings. This outcome aims to evaluate the percentage of CTC scans that lead to clinically significant findings.
Cost per correctly diagnosed medium to large polyps (≥6mm) and colorectal cancer using CTC as the initial investigation (measured in £ per patient) 3 months The second outcome is to evaluate the cost per correctly diagnosed medium to large polyps (≥6mm) and colorectal cancer using CTC as the initial investigation.
For patients with positive findings on CTC (either medium to large polyps and/or CRC), optical colonoscopy will be used as the comparator to assess whether the initial diagnosis with CTC was correct.
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
Guy's and St Thomas' NHS Foundation Trust
🇬🇧London, United Kingdom