A Randomised Trial of Radical Chemo/Radiotherapy vs Radiotherapy Alone in the Definitive Management of Localised Muscle Invasive TCC of the Urinary Bladder
Overview
- Phase
- Phase 3
- Intervention
- Cisplatin
- Conditions
- Transitional Cell Carcinoma of Urinary Bladder
- Sponsor
- Trans Tasman Radiation Oncology Group
- Enrollment
- 67
- Locations
- 22
- Primary Endpoint
- Invasive local failure at 3 years
- Status
- Completed
- Last Updated
- 8 years ago
Overview
Brief Summary
The purpose of this study is to define the optimal management of localised transitional cell carcinoma (TCC) of the urinary bladder. The main objective is to evaluate whether chemoradiation is superior to radiotherapy alone.
Detailed Description
Whilst concurrent chemo-radiation is increasingly being looked upon as the treatment of choice for patients referred for bladder preservation, the study by the NCI of Canada (Coppin CM, Gospodarowicz MK et al.Improved Local Control of Invasive Bladder Cancer by Concurrent Cisplatin and Pre-operative or Definitive Radiation.J. of Clinical Oncol. 14(11): 2901-2907, 1996) is the only randomised trial to show some superiority of concurrent Cisplatin and radiation treatment over radiation alone in increasing pelvic tumour control. There was no impact on overall survival. However, this study had relatively small subject numbers and included two distinct treatment options. In one group the patients were treated with a bladder sparing approach and in the other by pre-operative therapy and cystectomy with the type of definitive treatment being decided upon by both the treating Specialist and patient. At 5 years the pelvic failure rates in the radiation alone and chemo-radiation arms were 59% and 40% respectively. With half of the patients in each group having had planned cystectomy as part of their treatment regimen, the above rates of local relapse (especially in the chemo-radiation arm) are disappointing. Given the concerns with the above study, and the continuing paucity of randomised phase III studies comparing chemo-radiation with radiation alone, there lies an opportunity for Australasian centres to take up the challenge. For this study, the proposed schedule for the chemo-radiation arm is to be the same as that being investigated in our previous phase II study (six weekly doses of Cisplatin plus radiation to a dose of 64Gy in 32 fractions over 6.5 weeks). This will be compared with radical radiation alone (64Gy in 32 fractions over 6.5 weeks).
Investigators
Eligibility Criteria
Inclusion Criteria
- •Histologically proven TCC of the urinary bladder. Mixed tumours comprising predominantly TCC and elements of squamous or adenomatous metaplasia or carcinoma are also eligible.
- •Clinically and radiologically localised T2, T3 or T4a non-bulky disease (\<= 7cm in maximum dimension), N0, M
- •If radiological evaluation of a lymph node is interpreted as "positive" this must be evaluated further by either lymph node sampling or percutaneous needle biopsy. Patients with histologically confirmed lymph node metastases will not be eligible.
- •Maximal TUR.
- •N.B. Previous:
- •partial cystectomy;
- •endoscopic resection of bladder tumour/s;
- •intravesical chemotherapy; or
- •intravesical BCG
- •does not exclude the patient from being eligible. However, the patient should have an adequate functioning bladder (this should be clarified with the referring Urologist and if need be voiding volumes should be measured).
Exclusion Criteria
- •Pure squamous carcinomas or adenocarcinomas.
- •Extensive or multifocal CIS change in the bladder.
- •T3 or T4a tumours unsuitable for curative treatment (i.e. \> 7cm in any dimension), T4b, node positive and metastatic disease.
- •Presence of ureteric obstruction due to tumour infiltration at the UO not amenable to stenting.
- •Previous radiation treatment to the pelvis.
- •Previous significant pelvic surgery.
- •Significant bowel or gynaecological inflammatory disease.
- •Creatinine clearance \< 50ml/minute by calculation or measurement. A white blood cell count \< 3.5 x 10\^9/L with an absolute neutrophil count \< 1.5 x 10\^9L and/or a platelet count \< 100 x 10\^9/L.
- •Other considerations making patient unfit for Cisplatin therapy.
- •Prior or concurrent malignancy of any other site unless disease-free for greater than 5 years, except for:
Arms & Interventions
A
Synchronous chemo / radiation therapy
Intervention: Cisplatin
A
Synchronous chemo / radiation therapy
Intervention: External beam radiation treatment
B
Radiation Alone
Intervention: External beam radiation treatment
Outcomes
Primary Outcomes
Invasive local failure at 3 years
Time Frame: 3 years
Secondary Outcomes
- Complete response (CR) rate at 3 months from randomisation(3 months)
- Disease-free survival(Final analysis when all patients have been followed for 3 years. (approx. 7 years from start of trial))
- Overall survival(Final analysis when all patients have been followed for 3 years. (approx. 7 years from start of trial))
- Cystectomy-free survival(Final analysis when all patients have been followed for 3 years. (approx. 7 years from start of trial))
- Acute and late toxicity(Interim analyses will be performed on an annual basis.)
- Pattern of failure (local, regional, distant)(Final analysis when all patients have been followed for 3 years. (approx. 7 years from start of trial))
- Quality of life measures(Final analysis when all patients have been followed for 3 years. (approx. 7 years from start of trial))