Music Intervention for Preoperative Anxiety and Acute Pain Among Mastectomy Patients

Not Applicable

Completed

• Conditions: Mastectomy; Pain, Postoperative; Breast Cancer
• Interventions: Other: Music intervention

• Registration Number: NCT04824183
• Lead Sponsor: Chinese University of Hong Kong

Brief Summary

Anxiety is a common thing that patients experience when they are preparing to have a surgery. When this anxiety is not properly treated, the patients tend to consume more drugs in the operating room and it also cause their pain to increase after surgery. Pain after surgery is common among patients who have just had surgery. The pain that women who have had mastectomy feels after surgery is usually treated using pain killers. Yet, the pain killers are not enough to reduce the pain or cause some unwanted outcomes for the patients. Therefore, supplementing pain killers with music therapy appears to be a good way to reduce the pain and the unwanted outcomes that may arise from taking too much pain killers.

This research is aimed to test how effective music that is selected by patients, considers their culture and psychological needs can be helpful in reducing anxiety before surgery and pain after surgery. Also its effect on blood pressure, breathing rate and pulse will be tested. The researcher also hope to know how satisfied patients who consent to participate in the study are with their pain management.

The study will be done in two Nigerian hospitals and will mainly include women who have cancer, are above the age of 18, scheduled to have mastectomy, can read or write English or Pidgin, without any mental health challenge and agrees to participate in the study.

This study hope to enrol up to 112 women and put them into two groups randomly, one group will receive the music intervention and the other group will receive the normal care provided by the hospital.

Participants in the music intervention group will be added to a WhatsApp group on the week of their surgery. The WhatsApp session will be three times within the week of the surgery and each session will be about 30 minutes long. This study will use a combination of very short videos and voice notes (3 minutes) as well as real time chats and pictures to enhance communication on the group chat. The researcher will initiate discussions about participant's experience with breast cancer diagnosis, teach them about anxiety before surgery and pain after surgery. Then, they will ask questions that will be answered and also choose their type of music and send it to the group. The songs will be downloaded into a device and given to them on the day of surgery. They will continue to listen to the music after their surgery for the next two days.

Before participants receive the music on the day of surgery, anxiety level and vital signs will be assessed. After the surgery, participant's pain level, vital signs and satisfaction with pain management before and after the intervention will be assessed. Those in the second group will receive a one-on-one chat with the researcher about pain after surgery.

For all the participants, the study will be completed two days after the surgery.

Detailed Description

Music intervention (MI) is considered useful for anxiety and pain management in various surgical populations. It is a mind-body therapy that is expressive and requires interpersonal processes which could be active or passive. In MI, a combination of the emotional, physical, social, mental, spiritual, and aesthetic aspects of music are used to maintain and improve the client's health condition. MI achieves its analgesic effects by acting on mu-opiate receptors, morphine-6-glucuronide and the level of interleukin-6. It could also compete with other peripheral nerve stimuli such as pain transmission to the brain via the spinal cord. MI also enacts a powerful and subtle psychological effect on people because it is rooted in their emotional lives. The psychological effect is rooted in the entrainment to the rhythm of the music which causes alteration of the neuron activities in the lateral temporal lobe.

A systematic review of literature conducted revealed that MI has been employed both in the preoperative phase for the management of anxiety and in the postoperative phase for the management of postoperative pain in breast cancer patients undergoing surgery. All the studies included in the systematic review used music that is culture-specific and face-to-face mode of delivery. None of the studies used theory-driven approach in their intervention development nor considered both preoperative and postoperative patient outcomes together.

Sequel to the recent global pandemic, many healthcare facilities are restricting access to patients in clinical settings creating limitations for music therapy interventions that rely on only face-to-face mode of delivery. Therefore, the delivery of music therapy via hybrid mode becomes an area worthy of research. As with the traditional delivery mode, the cultural context and the use of theory-driven intervention are considerations to be made when developing the intervention. In order to develop a theory-driven and culture-specific intervention, the Symptom Management Model (SMM) will be adopted in this study. SMM was selected based on the review of other literature on MI and considering the relatedness of components of MT and the components of the SMM.

Theoretical framework underpinning MI As stated previously, the SMM could underpin the MI in this study. The model was firstly developed by the School of Nursing symptom management faculty group of the University of California, San Francisco, and further revised. It has three domains which are symptom experience, symptom management strategy and symptom outcomes. The domains are dependent on the nursing concepts of person, environment, and health and illness. The symptom is described as a subjective experience that evinces a patient's biopsychosocial functioning, cognition, and sensation.

Symptom perception, evaluation and response to symptoms are the concepts indicated in the symptom experience domain. The symptom experience domain is directly influenced by risk factors or disease or injury and health status. For mastectomy patients, pain is usually influenced by the type of mastectomy and its extensiveness. However, the type of mastectomy to be done is dependent on the stage of cancer, the possibility of the patient undergoing radiotherapy, and the intended aesthetic result. The symptom management strategy domain is considered as a dynamic domain that aims at slowing down or averting negative outcomes using either professional, self-care, or biomedical strategies. MI is a type of intervention that can be used by both healthcare professionals and patients as an adjunct to pharmacological therapy for pain management. The components of the symptom management strategy include who delivers the intervention, what, how, when, why, where, and how much of the intervention is to be delivered. These are similar to the standards for reporting music intervention which includes consideration for the expertise, duration, frequency, dosage, mode of delivery and environment for the intervention to be delivered.

Finally, the symptom outcomes domain according to the SMM includes the effects of the intervention on the symptom status (pain intensity and analgesic consumption), functional status (vital signs), mood/emotional status (anxiety), and satisfaction with care. The SMM stresses that symptom experience assessment and adherence to the symptom management strategy will influence the outcomes achieved. Since pain is multidimensional, the amenability of each dimension to change by MI varies.

In relation to the findings that the cultural context in which MI will be implemented is crucial to the acceptance and effectiveness of the intervention and that symptom outcome in the SMM model in relation to MI for pain management can include symptom status (pain intensity and analgesic consumption), functional status (vital signs), mood/emotional states (anxiety), and satisfaction with care. To the best of our knowledge, an hybrid mode of delivering music intervention to women undergoing mastectomy has never been used to address postoperative pain. Given the strong relationship between music and pain, we hypothesize that the hybrid-mode delivered music therapy will reduce the preoperative anxiety, postoperative pain intensity, vital signs as well as improve satisfaction with pain management of women undergoing mastectomy. Therefore, this study aims to test the feasibility and evaluate the effectiveness of hybrid-mode delivered MI on preoperative anxiety, and acute postoperative pain, vital signs, analgesic consumption, and satisfaction with pain management among African women undergoing mastectomy.

Objectives of the study

The objectives of the study are to:

i) test the feasibility of implementing the MI intervention in clinical settings in Africa ii) Estimate the effects of MI on preoperative anxiety, acute postoperative pain, vital signs, analgesic consumption, and satisfaction with pain management among African women with breast cancer undergoing mastectomy

Study Timeline

• Study First Submitted: 2021-03-25
• Study First Submitted QC: 2021-03-30
• Study First Posted: 2021-04-01
• Study Start: 2021-06-05
• Primary Completion: 2022-03-22
• Study Completion: 2022-03-27
• Status Verified: 2022-08
• Last Update Submitted: 2022-08-18
• Last Update Posted: 2022-08-19

Recruitment & Eligibility

• Status: COMPLETED
• Sex: Female
• Target Recruitment: 36

Inclusion Criteria

Women who are:

1. Aged 18 years and above
2. Diagnosed with breast cancer
3. Attending the surgical out-patient clinic for booking visit
4. Being scheduled for mastectomy
5. Can communicate verbally or in writing in English, Yoruba or Pidgin;
6. Without existing chronic pain diagnosis
7. Consent to join the study. -

Exclusion Criteria

1. Pre-existing mental health disorders and cognitive impairment if they are 2. Transferred to the intensive care unit due to complications within the first two days after surgery.

Study & Design

• Study Type: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Design: PARALLEL

Arm && Interventions

Group	Intervention	Description
Music intervention	Music intervention	Music intervention that begins with patient education on WhatsApp will be delivered to participants 3 times within 48 hours before surgery followed by face-to-face monitoring of intervention usage.

Primary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Change in acute postoperative pain intensity	Pre-intervention and immediately after the intervention through study completion at 48 hours after surgery	The Visual Analogue Scale will be used to assess the pain intensity level. The score on this scale ranged from 0 to 10, higher score represents high pain intensity

Secondary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Change in blood pressure	Pre-intervention and immediately after the intervention through study completion at 48 hours after surgery	The systolic and diastolyic blood pressure will be assessed using an automated blood pressure monitor.
Analgesia consumption	Post-intervention at 48 hours after surgery	The type, dosage, frequency and mode administration of analgesia will be assessed and documented in the pharmacological pain prescription and management technique chart.
Satisfaction with pain management	Immediately after intervention at 48 hours after surgery	Patient satisfaction with pain management will be assessed using the numerical rating scale. The score on this scale ranged from 0 to 10, higher score represents high level of satisfaction
Change in heart rate	Pre-intervention and immediately after the intervention through study completion at 48 hours after surgery	Heart rate will be assessed through an automated machine and documented in beats per minutes
Change in respiratory rate	Pre-intervention and immediately after the intervention through study completion at 48 hours after surgery	Respiratory rate will be counted manually for one full minutes and documented as cycles per minute
Change in preoperative anxiety	Pre-intervention and immediately after the intervention on the day of surgery	Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Inventory will be used to assess anxiety level. This is a four point likert scale with score ranging from 0 to 80. Higher score represents high anxiety level.

Trial Locations

Locations (3)

Lagos University Teaching Hospital; 🇳🇬 Lagos, Nigeria

Kamuzu Central Hospital; 🇲🇼 Lilongwe, Malawi

Lagos State University Teaching Hospital; 🇳🇬 Ikeja, Lagos, Nigeria