Detection of Racial Bias in an Artificial Intelligence Based Orthodontic Diagnosis System
试验速览
- 阶段
- 不适用
- 状态
- 已完成
- 入组人数
- 10,000
- 试验地点
- 3
- 主要终点
- Accuracy
研究概览
简要总结
This study explores how artificial intelligence (AI) can be used in orthodontics, which is the area of dentistry that focuses on correcting jaw and bite problems. AI is a computer technology that can learn from large amounts of data and then make predictions or decisions. It is already being tested in medicine and dentistry to help doctors and dentists diagnose conditions.
For this study, the AI system was trained using photographs and X-rays from patients in Turkey. The system learned to recognize specific orthodontic skeletal malocclusions. After the training stage, the AI was tested in two groups: one group included Turkish patients whose records were not used in training, and the other group included patients from different ethnic backgrounds who were treated at a clinic in Belgium. This design allows researchers to see if the AI works equally well for people of different backgrounds.
Only photographs and X-rays taken before orthodontic treatment are used in the study, and all data are anonymized so that no personal information is shared. The images must meet certain quality standards. For example the head must be in natural position, with no beards, scars, or previous orthodontic treatment that might affect the image. Patients who do not meet these criteria are not included.
The AI program analyzes the profile photographs, prepares them for evaluation by adjusting and standardizing the images, and then tries to decide each patient has which malocclusion. The results from Turkish patients and patients from other populations are compared to see if the system makes fair and accurate decisions for everyone.
The purpose of this study is not to test a new treatment, but to understand how well AI can recognize orthodontic problems in different populations. This information is important because AI systems are increasingly being used in healthcare, and they need to be fair and accurate for all patients, not just those from one group.
By participating, patients help researchers learn whether AI in orthodontics is reliable across diverse communities. This knowledge can guide future improvements in AI technology, ensuring that it supports orthodontists in providing safe, equal, and effective care for everyone.
详细描述
This study investigates how artificial intelligence (AI) can be used to diagnose skeletal malocclusions. AI is a computer technology that can learn from data, recognize patterns, and then make predictions. It is already being used in different areas of medicine and dentistry, but its accuracy and fairness may depend on the data it was trained with.
In orthodontics, skeletal problems are usually classified into four main groups: Class I (normal skeletal relationship), Class II Division 1, Class II Division 2 (upper jaw forward or lower jaw retruded or both ), and Class III (lower jaw forward in relation to the upper jaw or upper jaw retruded relation to lower jaw or both).
For this study, an AI system was trained with profile photographs and X-rays of 3,280 Turkish patients. The system learned to recognize all four types of skeletal relationships: Class I, Class II Division 1, Class II Division 2, and Class III. After the training, the AI was tested on new groups of patients whose images were not part of the training set. This included a group of Turkish population and another group of patients from different population treated in Belgium. By comparing the AI's results in these two groups, researchers will be able to see whether the system works equally well for people of different populations.
The patient data used in this study is completely anonymized. Only pre-treatment profile photographs and lateral cephalometric X-rays are included. The images must comply with quality standards such as being taken in natural head position, with a clear background and without beard, scars, or previous orthodontic treatment that might interfere with recognition. Patients whose photographs do not meet these standards are excluded.
This research is conducted as a cross-sectional diagnostic accuracy study (single-gate, multi-center). The diagnostic performance of the AI system is evaluated using accuracy, recall (sensitivity), precision, false positive rate, F1 score, and area under the curve (AUC).
研究设计
- 研究类型
- Observational
- 观察模型
- Other
- 时间视角
- Retrospective
入排标准
- 年龄范围
- 4 Years 至 —（Child, Adult, Older Adult）
- 性别
- All
- 接受健康志愿者
- 是
入选标准
- •Patients with lateral profile photographs taken before starting orthodontic treatment
- •Profile photographs with a plain background
- •Patient in natural head position facing forward
- •No beard or mustache that could camouflage the profile
- •Availability of lateral cephalometric radiographs taken before treatment together with the profile photograph
排除标准
- •Blurry missing or non standard profile photographs
- •Presence of beard mustache scars cleft lip palate or soft tissue deformities that may significantly affect facial appearance
- •Previous orthodontic treatment history
研究组 & 干预措施
Turkish Citizen's Control Group (Hold-out)
The AI system was trained with data from 7,000 people. To test whether the AI has bias, the system should be evaluated both on a group of Turkish population who were not included in the training data and on patients from different populations.
Individuals from different populations
Test set, consisting of individuals from different populations.
结局指标
主要结局
Accuracy
时间窗: At baseline (retrospective single time-point data analysis)
Accuracy (proportion of correctly classified cases) will be compared between Turkish test set, and non-Turkish cohort from different ethnic backgrounds.
次要结局
- Precision (Positive Predictive Value)(At baseline (retrospective single time-point data analysis))
- Recall(At baseline (retrospective single time-point data analysis))
- False Positive Rate(At baseline (retrospective single time-point data analysis))
- F1 score(At baseline (retrospective single time-point data analysis))
研究者
Aslı Eker Davut
Dentist - PhD Student
Bezmialem Vakif University