Cuff Leak Test and Airway Obstruction in Mechanically Ventilated ICU
- Conditions
- Laryngeal Edema
- Interventions
- Diagnostic Test: Cuff Leak Test
- Registration Number
- NCT03372707
- Lead Sponsor
- McMaster University
- Brief Summary
Introduction: Endotracheal intubation and mechanical ventilation are lifesaving interventions that are commonly done in the intensive care unit (ICU). The act of intubating someone can cause laryngeal edema (LE) that, if extensive enough, can cause airway obstruction after a patient is extubated. To date, the only test that is available to predict this complication is the cuff leak test (CLT). However, its diagnostic accuracy is uncertain as there have been no randomized controlled trials (RCT) examining this. The Cuff leak and airway Obstruction in Mechanically ventilated ICU patients (COMIC) Randomized Control Trial will be done to examine the impact of CLT on postextubation stridor and reintubation. Subsequently, describing the diagnostic accuracy of this test.
Methods: This will be a multi-center centered, pragmatic, double blinded RCT. Mechanically ventilated patients in the ICU, who are deemed ready to be extubated will be included. All patients will have a CLT done prior to extubation. The results of the CLT in the intervention arm will be communicated to the treating physician, and decision to extubate will be left to the treating team, while the results of the CLT for patients in the control arm will not be communicated to the treating physician, and the patient will be extubated, regardless of the result of the CLT.
Objective: This is a pilot trial to assess feasibility of conducting a powered RCT. Feasibility outcomes include: consent rate, recruitment rate, and protocol adherence. Clinical outcomes will include postextubation stridor, reintubation, emergency surgical airway, ICU mortality, in hospital mortality, duration of mechanical ventilation, and ICU length of stay in days.
- Detailed Description
INTRODUCTION Endotracheal intubation and mechanical ventilation are lifesaving interventions. However, as with acute interventions, can be associated with serious complications. One such complication is laryngeal edema (LE) that occurs in 4-55% of patients. LE is thought to be caused by marked polymorphonuclear infiltration to the traumatized upper airway postintubation. The incidence of LE increases as the duration of intubation accrues, but it can occur as early as the first 24 hours of intubation. LE can result in airway narrowing and increased airflow velocity. It is postulated that narrowing of the lumen by 50% or more may result in postextubation stridor and respiratory distress. As a result, 3.5% (range 0-10.5%) of patients with LE will fail an extubation attempt and require reintubation. For various reasons, reintubation has a significant morbidity and mortality.
Identifying patients with LE can be challenging, the presence of the endotracheal tube (ETT) precludes direct visualization of the upper airway prior to extubation, therefore, clinicians cannot accurately predict airway obstruction before it occurs. A cuff-leak test (CLT) was first described in 1988 as a surrogate for direct visualization and a screening for airway edema prior to extubation. This test involves deflating the balloon cuff on an ETT and observing if the patient is able to breathe around it. If air can pass around the ETT, it suggest that the airway is patent and clinicians may proceed with extubation. A small leak or complete absence of one, would suggest an airway obstruction.
There are conflicting results on the utility and accuracy of a CLT. To date, two meta-analyses of observational studies examined the diagnostic accuracy of a CLT. One meta-analysis reports that a failed CLT is insensitive but a specific predictor of LE (pooled sensitivity and specificity 0.56; 95% CI, 0.48-0.63 and 0.92; 95% CI, 0.90-0.93, respectively) and reintubation (pooled sensitivity and specificity for reintubation 0.63; 95% CI, 0.38-0.84 and 0.86; 95% CI, 0.81-0.90, respectively). While the second meta-analysis also states that the failed CLT was associated with postextubation LE, particularly in patients with \> 5 days duration of intubation (odds ratio \[OR\]=2.09; 95% CI, 1.28-2.89), it was not associated with higher odds of reintubation (OR=0.94; 95% CI, 0.32-1.57).
Despite the lack of high quality studies, an absent cuff leak usually results in delayed extubation and exposure to corticosteroids to empirically treat airway edema. A recent meta-analysis of 11 parallel randomized controlled trails (RCTs) with a total of 2472 patients examined the effect of prophylactic corticosteroids prior to extubation on postextubation stridor and reintubation. Prophylactic corticosteroids use reduced the risk of postextubation airway events when compared to placebo or no treatment (RR 0.43; 95% CI 0.29-0.66, P=0.002). A subgroup analysis demonstrates that this benefit is only significant in patients that are deemed "high risk" for LE. Prophylactically treating unspecified patients shows no reduction in postextubation events and exposes patients to high dose steroids (16). Moreover, a false positive CLT can unnecessarily delay extubation, leading to a prolonged length of stay in the intensive care unit (ICU), barotraumas, and increased risk of ventilator associated pneumonias, therefore, exposing patients unnecessarily to these undesirable outcomes. On the other hand, if a CLT is not performed, or if in case of a false negative test, some patients may fail the extubation attempt and require reintubation.
Recent clinical practice guidelines for using CLT reflect this uncertainty. The American Thoracic Society guidelines on liberation of mechanical ventilation issued a weak recommendation for performing CLT in mechanically ventilated adults who are at high risk for postextubation stridor (conditional recommendation, very low certainty). There is also significant clinical equipoise. A recent unpublished survey found that 42% (12/26) of Canadian intensive care unit (ICU) physicians either never or rarely request to know the results of a cuff leak test prior to extubating a patient that is at moderate risk of laryngeal edema while 23% will always or usually order the test. Therefore, a large RCT is necessary to investigate the diagnostic accuracy of the CLT and its impact on patients' outcomes.
Herein, the investigators are reporting the protocol for the COMIC Pilot Trial. The COMIC (Cuff leak and airway Obstruction in Mechanically ventilated ICU patients) pilot trial will be a multicenter, randomized, concealed, blinded, parallel-group, pragmatic pilot trial. The purpose is to determine the feasibility of undertaking a powered RCT to examine the impact of CLT on postextubation stridor and reintubation. Subsequently, describing the diagnostic accuracy of this test.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- COMPLETED
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 100
- Eligible patients will be mechanically ventilated adults (>18 years) who are admitted to the ICU and an order to extubate has been provided by the treating physician.
- A palliative care, a one-way extubation, or a decision to withdraw advances life support order has been written.
- Pregnancy.
- Patients at high risk for LE: burn patients, smoke inhalation injuries (as defined as singed facial hair or nasal hair, carbonaceous secretions/sputum, and known to be in an enclosed fire), blunt or penetrating trauma involving the neck and airway, postoperative head and neck surgeries, and patients admitted with airway edema to the ICU (e.g; anaphylaxis).
- Patients with either a difficult or traumatic endotracheal intubation.
- Patients receiving mechanical ventilation via tracheostomy.
- Known preexisting tracheolaryngeal abnormalities such as: vocal cord paralysis, tracheolaryngeal neoplasm, tracheomalacia, tracheolaryngeal stenosis, or previous head and neck surgeries.
- Patients receiving systemic corticosteroids of greater than 30 mg of PO prednisone or equivalent, within 4 days prior to the decision to extubate.
- Patients who failed extubation attempt within the current ICU admission.
- History of postextubation airway obstruction.
- The ICU physician declined enrolling the patient.
- Patient had a failed CLT in the previous 24 hours.
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Intervention Arm Cuff Leak Test Patients randomized to the intervention arm will have the results of the Cuff Leak Test (CLT) (whether failed or passed) communicated to the treating physician; the treating physician will decide whether to proceed with extubation or not based on the CLT results. It is at the discretion of the treating physician to provide corticosteroids (4-5 mg of intravenous dexamethasone every six hours for up to 24 hours, with the last dose given one hour preceding extubation) and/or delay extubation by 24 hours should the patient fail the CLT.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Recruitment Rate 1 year A successful recruitment rate will be defined as achieving enrollment of 40 patients, conventionally expressed as four patients per month over the duration of the trial. While the pilot trial is ongoing, recruitment will be reviewed weekly and the screening records will be reviewed monthly with the cases of missed eligible patients reviewed. If applicable, barriers to enrollment will be addressed to maximize recruitment. The recruitment metric will be measured and interpreted at the end of the pilot trial by calculating the mean number of recruited patients per active screening month.
Consent Rate 1 year A successful consent rate will be defined as 70% of substitute decision makers (SDMs) or patients approached to consent, choosing to participate in the trial. This will be calculated as the overall proportion of SDMs or patients consenting out of those approached (with 95% CI). Note that a mixed consent model will be obtained. In Canada and Saudi Arabia, a priori or deferred consent model will be used. In Poland, a waved consent model will be used.
Protocol Adherence 1 year Successful adherence will be defined as ≥80%. The adherence will be calculated as the proportion of patients that were assigned to the control arm being extubated after CLT being performed and the portion of people that assigned to the intervention arm who are given the prescribed steroids for a failed CLT. As this pilot trial is ongoing, investigators will review adherence monthly and investigate the reasons for compliance failure. All reasons for either failure to extubate after a failed CLT in the control arm will be investigated. The RC will review the Respiratory Therapists' notes, and the medication profile to determine actual compliance. All reasons for non-compliance will be recorded for both groups using distinguishing clinical reasons (eg. Palliation, death, consent withdrawal, errors).
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Emergency surgical airway 30 days Defined as performing urgent tracheotomy or cricothyroidotomy for a life-threatening airway obstruction
In ICU mortality 1 year Duration of mechanical ventilation 1 year Defined as time on the ventilator after randomization in days.
Reintubation 72 hours after original extubation Defined as reintubation within 72 hours of original extubation while in the ICU.
Clinically significant postextubation stridor 48 hours after original extubation Defined as stridor (see definition above) that requires medical intervention such as the administration of systemic steroids, racemic epinephrine, or Heli-ox.
Postextubation stridor 48 hours after original extubation Defined as an audible high pitched inspiratory noise caused by turbulent airflow through the narrowed airway that is detectable with or without a stethoscope within 48 hours of extubation.
In hospital mortality truncated at 30 days 30 days ICU length of stay in days 1 year
Trial Locations
- Locations (3)
Jagiellonian University Medical College
🇵🇱Kraków, Lesser Poland, Poland
St Joseph's Hospital
🇨🇦Hamilton, Ontartio, Canada
Imam Adbulrahman Bin Faisal University
🇸🇦Dammam, Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia