Spinal Segment MRI Perfusion and Diffusion Response to Spinal Manipulation in Low Back Pain Patients
- Conditions
- Pain, Back
- Interventions
- Other: Spinal Manipulative Therapy
- Registration Number
- NCT03880500
- Lead Sponsor
- Balgrist University Hospital
- Brief Summary
The main objective is to quantify changes in diffusion and perfusion in the intervertebral disc and adjacent spinal muscle tissue of a spinal segment receiving a spinal manipulative or control intervention using diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance Imaging (MRI) (DWI, used for quantifying diffusion) and intravoxel incoherent motion MRI (IVIM, used for quantifying perfusion).
Additional objectives are to test if clinical parameters such as pain and disability, radiological parameters, or pain-related inflammatory parameters in venous blood have predictive value in relation to these perfusion and diffusion effects, and if these effects correlate to clinical outcome.
An additional objective is to test the repeatability of IVIM-MRI in assessing perfusion changes in musculoskeletal tissue, and, as a positive control, assessing diurnal changes in perfusion and diffusion parameters in spinal tissue of healthy controls.
- Detailed Description
Non-specific low back pain (LBP) is a very common condition in developed countries, with a point prevalence between 15% and 30% and a lifetime prevalence of about 70%. As a non-invasive treatment method, high-velocity, low-amplitude spinal manipulative therapy (SMT) is used in the conservative treatment of non-specific low back pain (LBP). Several studies suggest an association with favourable outcome. However, the overall effect size of clinical improvement following SMT remains modest. Most research on the effectiveness of SMT on back pain is conducted on patients suffering from "non-specific" LBP, the diagnosis of which is usually based upon the criterium that pain is not attributed to a recognizable pathology (e.g., infection, tumor, inflammatory diseases, fractures, disc herniations with nerve compression)8. In most of these studies, it is unclear whether patients' diagnoses were based upon more than history and clinical examination. The investigators argue that in the majority of cases, back pain labelled as non-specific might be more accurately labelled as non-specified and does have an attributable source and cause, whether one is able to recognize it or not. Therefore, if the diagnosis of non-specific LBP comprises heterogenic conditions, it is unlikely that patients will respond to one therapeutic modality equally.
Diffusion-weighted MR-imaging (DWI) is an application of magnetic resonance imaging that allows the measurement of water movement within and between tissues and is increasingly being used to study musculoskeletal physiology. Because DWI is sensitive even to small changes in fluid flow, it is potentially valuable in the study of the influence of therapeutic interventions such as manual therapy, exercise, and physical agents on musculoskeletal tissues. Studies using DWI have suggested that changes in diffusion within lumbar intervertebral discs occur in response to joint mobilization, prone press-ups, spinal traction and spinal manipulative therapy.
Intravoxel incoherent motion (IVIM) is a method proposed in 1988 by Le Bihan et al. which extracts microvascular blood flow information from diffusion-weighted imaging acquired at different b-values. It is used to generate separate images of diffusion and perfusion without requiring the injection of exogenous contrast agents. Originally developed in brain studies, it has been used in recent years to study perfusion in musculoskeletal tissue. There is a paucity of research addressing physiological events following a SMT intervention for patients with low back pain. A deeper understanding of local biomechanical and neurophysiological effects of SMT interventions might help refine its utilization and improve its effectiveness.
The purpose of this study is to quantify changes in diffusion and perfusion parameters within the intervertebral disc and paraspinal muscle tissue of a spinal segment receiving a spinal manipulative or sham intervention and to evaluate whether those changes differ in spinal segments with or without degenerative changes in 50 low-back-pain patients.
Additionally, it is of interest to determine the relationships between baseline parameters and changes in diffusion and perfusion as well as the degree of degenerative changes. Post-intervention changes in segmental spinal muscle perfusion will also be investigated. There will be a clinical follow-up immediately after the second MRI and at 1 week,4 and 12 weeks.
The repeatability and diurnal variation of IVIM imaging in quantifying perfusion in musculoskeletal tissues will be assessed by comparing perfusion parameters of 20 controls who will not receive any intervention. The investigators will perform a diffusion- and perfusion-weighted MRI at the beginning of the visit in the morning, which is repeated after approximately 20 minutes of rest (lying supine). Controls will present for an additional MRI approximately 10 hours later in the evening of the same day.
In participants consenting to venipuncture, approximately 8 ml of venous blood will be withdrawn using serum collection tubes, allowed to clot, and then centrifuged. The resulting serum supernatant is stored in aliquots at Balgrist Campus at -80°C. It will be analysed at the end of data collection for pro- and anti-inflammatory markers (e.g. C-reactive Protein, Interleukin 1-beta, Interleukin 6 and Tumor Necrosis Factor) in order to determine the relationship between inflammatory markers and degenerative changes, pain duration, and pain and disability outcomes.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- RECRUITING
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 70
Not provided
Not provided
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Patient Spinal Manipulative Therapy 25 Patients will receive a spinal manipulative therapy Intervention, the other 25 Patients receive a sham Intervention.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Diffusion Change Measured on day 1 during the study Measured on diffusion-weighted MRI in square millimeters per second. Diffusion (D) in intra- and extracellular compartments in the intervertebral disc and adjacent spinal muscle tissue is measured in patients before and after an SMT- or control intervention and in controls before and after 20 minutes of lying supine. The computed difference is the Diffusion Change.
Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Change Measured on day 1 during the study Computed on diffusion-weighted MRI, refers to the mean diffusion in a voxel (on MRI). Apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) is measured in the intervertebral disc and adjacent spinal muscle tissue in patients before and after an SMT- or control intervention and in controls before and after 20 minutes of lying supine. The computed difference is the Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Change.
Capillary Perfusion Change Measured on day 1 during the study Also called pseudodiffusion or D\*. Measured on IVIM-MRI in square millimeters per second. Perfusion in capillaries in spinal muscle tissue is measured in patients before and after an SMT- or control intervention and in controls before and after 20 minutes of lying supine. The computed difference equals the Capillary Perfusion Change.
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Change in Capillary Perfusion (Control) Measured approximately 9 hours after the first MRI, during the study Secondary outcomes are the diurnal changes of capillary perfusion in musculoskeletal tissue in controls approximately 9 hours after the first MRI.
Diffusion change Measured approximately 9 hours after the first MRI, during the study Secondary outcomes are the diurnal changes of diffusion in the intervertebral disc and adjacent spinal muscle tissue in controls approximately 9 hours after the first MRI.
Change in Apparent Diffusion Coefficient (Control) Measured approximately 9 hours after the first MRI, during the study Measured on MRI. Secondary outcomes are the diurnal changes of the apparent diffusion coefficient in musculoskeletal tissue in controls approximately 9 hours after the first MRI.
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
University Hospital Balgrist
🇨🇭Zürich, Zurich, Switzerland