Trehalose-Loaded Lipid Nanoparticles Enhance mRNA Vaccine Stability and Bridge In Vitro-In Vivo Efficacy Gap
核心洞察
Researchers developed a dual-function trehalose loading strategy that incorporates trehalose both externally and internally within lipid nanoparticles (搜索) to enhance mRNA vaccine stability during freeze-drying and storage.
The trehalose-loaded LNPs (TL-LNPs) demonstrated superior mRNA chemical stability, retaining over 90% mRNA integrity after 4 weeks of storage at 4°C compared to 74% for conventional formulations.
TL-LNPs showed significantly enhanced transfection efficiency both in vitro and in vivo by reducing oxidative stress (搜索) in target cells and improving cellular protection against cationic lipid-induced cytotoxicity (搜索).
A breakthrough in mRNA vaccine stability has emerged from researchers who developed an innovative dual-function trehalose loading strategy that addresses critical challenges in vaccine storage and efficacy. The approach incorporates trehalose both externally as a lyoprotectant and internally within lipid nanoparticles (搜索) (LNPs), significantly enhancing mRNA vaccine performance during freeze-drying and long-term storage.
The research team prepared trehalose-loaded LNPs (TL-LNPs) using a nanoprecipitation and solvent evaporation method, achieving a trehalose encapsulation efficiency of 17.7 ± 0.9%. The freshly prepared formulations showed similar physicochemical properties, with TL-LNPs exhibiting a size distribution of approximately 154.3 ± 1.3 nm and a zeta potential of around 28 mV, comparable to conventional LNPs.
Enhanced Transfection Efficiency Through Cellular Protection
The TL-LNPs demonstrated remarkable improvements in transfection efficiency compared to conventional formulations. In vitro studies using HEK293T cells revealed that TL-LNPs significantly outperformed both trehalose-mixed LNPs (TM-LNPs) and standard LNPs without trehalose, with statistical significance of p < 0.001 and p < 0.0001, respectively.
The enhanced performance stems from trehalose's ability to protect cells from oxidative stress (搜索) induced by cationic LNPs. TL-LNPs transported significantly more trehalose into cells during transfection compared to TM-LNPs (p < 0.01), providing superior cellular protection. The research demonstrated that TL-LNPs significantly reduced cell apoptosis and markedly improved cell viability by decreasing intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS (搜索)) levels.
Mechanistic studies revealed that TL-LNPs reduced the percentage of ROS (搜索)-positive cells and significantly decreased intracellular malondialdehyde (MDA) levels compared to TM-LNPs (p < 0.01). Additionally, TL-LNPs increased intracellular superoxide dismutase (SOD) and glutathione (GSH) levels, indicating enhanced antioxidative defense within cells.
Superior Storage Stability and mRNA Preservation
The freeze-drying optimization process identified -80°C as the optimal pre-freeze temperature, with 20% (w/v) trehalose concentration providing the best results. After freeze-drying, both FDTM-LNPs and FDTL-LNPs maintained excellent colloidal stability and mRNA encapsulation efficiency, with mRNA integrity remaining largely intact.
During storage at 4°C, FDTL-LNPs demonstrated superior stability compared to conventional formulations. After 4 weeks of storage, FDTL-LNPs retained over 90% of mRNA integrity, while FDTM-LNPs maintained only about 74% integrity. This enhanced chemical stability was attributed to the "hydrogen bond replacement" mechanism, where internal trehalose forms hydrogen bonds with mRNA, replacing water-mRNA interactions during lyophilization.
Bridging the In Vitro-In Vivo Performance Gap
A critical finding was the ability of TL-LNPs to maintain consistent performance between in vitro and in vivo evaluations. After 4 weeks of storage, FDTL-LNPs showed negligible decrease in in vivo bioluminescence, while FDTM-LNPs exhibited obviously decreased protein expression compared to 2-week storage samples (p < 0.01), retaining only about 76% of fresh LNP luminescent intensity.
The researchers attributed this discrepancy to the biological effects of trehalose on transfected cells and the differences between in vivo and in vitro environments. The diminished in vivo performance of FDTM-LNPs likely resulted from rapid diffusion of external trehalose, interfering with co-delivery into targeted antigen-presenting cells.
Molecular Mechanisms of Cellular Protection
The study revealed that TL-LNPs significantly reduced cytotoxicity (搜索) by decreasing intracellular oxidative stress (搜索). Nuclear factor erythroid 2-related factor 2 (Nrf2 (搜索)) expression analysis showed that cationic LNPs induced significant oxidative stress, with Nrf2 predominantly localized in the nucleus. However, treatment with TM-LNPs or TL-LNPs markedly reduced Nrf2 expression in both nucleus and cytoplasm, indicating reduced oxidative stress and decreased cellular need for Nrf2's protective function.
Comparative studies using vitamin C as a positive control confirmed that antioxidant loading within LNPs effectively enhanced transfection efficiency. Vitamin C-loaded LNPs (VCL-LNPs) significantly outperformed vitamin C-mixed LNPs (VCM-LNPs), supporting the hypothesis that co-delivery of protective agents with mRNA enhances overall performance.
Implications for Vaccine Development
The dual-function trehalose loading strategy addresses multiple challenges in mRNA vaccine development simultaneously. By preserving both colloidal stability of LNPs and chemical stability of mRNA while providing cellular protection, this approach offers significant advantages over current lyophilization methods that focus primarily on maintaining structural integrity.
The research demonstrates that this strategy could reduce risks and costs associated with inaccurate efficacy evaluations during storage, particularly important for vaccine distribution in resource-poor countries where maintaining ultracold storage conditions is challenging and expensive.
The findings suggest that the internal trehalose co-delivery mechanism provides a more reliable approach to maintaining vaccine efficacy during long-term storage compared to conventional external lyoprotectant methods, potentially revolutionizing mRNA vaccine stability and global accessibility.
