Decisional Capacity and Informed Consent in Fragile X Syndrome

FXS is the most common inherited form of intellectual disability (ID). The typical male has an IQ (intelligence quotient) of 50 to 55, but involvement ranges from mild to severe. Females are generally less affected and have a broader range in function. Some have severe ID and adaptive impairments, but most have a normal or borderline intellectual ability. This wide range in cognitive skills leads to variable ability to make choices and live independently. Most research on individuals with FXS has been noninvasive, limited to parent surveys and psychological assessments. Studies such as these evoke few if any major ethical concerns, so the consent process typically involves a straightforward parental consent. Some studies have drawn blood, collected saliva, measured heart rate, or used neuroimaging, but until recently there has been a paucity of treatment research. This scenario has changed dramatically in the past several years. Advances in understanding the molecular basis of FXS have led to a new generation of treatments, and clinical trials are under way using a variety of compounds. The possibility of side effects and the potential for significant changes in behavior and ability elevate to a new level the importance of obtaining meaningful consent, not only from parents, but also from individuals with FXS. Researchers and Institutional Review Board (IRB) members need data to guide decisions about involving individuals with FXS in the consent process. Unfortunately, little is known about the extent to which individuals with FXS can be or are involved in decisions about research participation. This project will assess the range of decisional capacity in FXS, identify factors associated with individual differences in decisional capacity, validate a rating scale for categorizing decisional capacity, and develop a novel tablet-based decision aid technology to assist researchers and clinicians in maximizing decisional capacity and consent. This study will work toward achieving two overarching aims: 1) Characterize and explain individual differences in decisional capacity in FXS, 2) Design and evaluate the effect of a tablet-based decision aid on participation in the consent process for a hypothetical clinical trial. Ultimately, this study will provide important information about the nature of decisional capacity in FXS and validate a novel intervention to maximize successful participation in the consent process.