Comparative Study Between Swenson and Soave Techniques for Cases With Hirschsprung Disease

Hirschsprung's disease is characterized by a lack of enteric nervous system ganglion cells (aganglionosis) in a variable extent of distal bowel. It is the commonest congenital bowel motility disorder and affected neonates usually present with distal intestinal obstruction in the first few days of life. Despite the common underlying pathology of Hirschsprung disease, it has varying presentations. Infants classically present with delayed passage of meconium, feeding intolerance, and bilious emesis. In fact, 90% of children with Hirschsprung will not have passage of stool within the first 24 h of life. Neonates and infants can also present with abdominal distension, failure to thrive, enterocolitis, or bowel perforation.

Hirschsprung's disease is characterized by a variable length of distal colonic aganglionosis. In approximately 80% of cases, it is short-segment, and only involves the rectosigmoid colon. Less commonly, it can extend proximal to the sigmoid colon (15%), include the entire colon (total colonic aganglionosis, 5%), or rarely, the entire intestine (total intestinal aganglionosis). The principles of the operation are to remove the aganglionic colon and connect the normally innervated bowel just above the anus, at a level which prevents further functional obstruction, but at the same time preserves fecal continence.

The surgical treatment of Hirschsprung's disease has evolved from the historical three-stage procedure to a single-stage technique. Since then, multiple series reported its safety, efficacy, and feasibility in the management of HSCR in the neonatal period. Swenson and Bill, Soave, and Duhamel are the most common procedures for Hirschsprung's disease. However, there is a heated debate about which technique gives the best short- and long-term outcomes. There are many surgical approaches to Hirschsprung's disease, including the transabdominal approach (TAB) and transanal endorectal pull-through (TERPT). The TAB includes 4 types: the Swenson, Duhamel, Rehbein, and Soave procedures. Both the Swenson and the Soave procedures have been adapted as transanal approaches.

Transanal access is based on the traditional surgical techniques performed previously in abdominal approach. This type of surgery is used for the treatment of small children. Transanal endorectal pull-through method performed with transanal access is characterized by low invasiveness of surgery and good results of treatment.

The Swenson procedure involves the removal of the entire affected site and end-to-end anastomosis of the normal colonic anal canal. In the Soave procedure, physiological saline is injected into the rectum after cutting through the rectal muscle layer in a circular manner, while keeping the mucosa intact to the dentate line level.