Percutaneous Radiologic Gastrostomy With and Without Gastropexy: A Prospective Comparison
试验速览
- 阶段
- 不适用
- 入组人数
- 60
- 试验地点
- 2
- 主要终点
- Pain level as reported on 10-point Visual Analog Scale
研究概览
简要总结
Percutaneous (through the skin) radiologic (x-ray guided) gastrostomy (to the stomach) (PRG) is a common procedure performed to help provide supplemental nutrition for those for who have difficulty swallowing their food. This population typically includes patients receiving radiation therapy for cancers of the mouth or throat, patients who have had a stroke or other neurologic disorders. It involves making a small incision in the skin on the belly to insert a feeding tube directly into the stomach. PRG has been well established as a safe and effective procedure for many years now. Although known to be safe, there is still debate regarding the best way to perform the procedure. Some doctors believe it is necessary to stitch the stomach wall against the wall of the belly before inserting the tube, this is called gastropexy. They argue that this decreases the risk of the tube being positioned incorrectly and prevents leakage of stomach content in the first few weeks after the procedure. Other doctors feel that these risks are very small and this step is not required as it can cause the patient more pain in the days following the procedure since the stomach is fixed against the body wall and cannot move naturally. To this day, the procedure is performed safely both ways, depending on the hospital.
The purpose of this research study is to compare these two methods and determine if one technique gives better results, meaning less pain and fewer complications for patients.
详细描述
When percutaneous radiological gastrostomy (PRG) first emerged as an alternative method to surgical or endoscopic techniques, gastropexy was considered an essential step. This consists of using sutures and "T-fasteners" to fix the anterior gastric wall to the anterior abdominal wall and many variations are described in the literature. It was postulated that this step is necessary to avoid tube misplacement and peritonitis caused by early leakage of gastric content around the site of tube insertion. It is still considered imperative in some groups of patients at high risk of gastric leakage (i.e. patients with ascites, steroid treatment, and/or severe malnourishment). However, in other patients its use has become subject of debate.
Experiments with animal models have shown no evidence of gastric leakage following insertion of a 14 French tube, even when the tube is subsequently removed and the defect left unrepaired. Furthermore, several groups have had success without the use of gastropexy and some have described complications caused by performing this step such as peristomal infection, increased post-procedural pain, persistent leakage, and gastrocutaneous fistulas. Other large series of patients who underwent gastrostomy with gastropexy did not experience gastropexy-related complications, further complicating the matter. To date, the guidelines for transabdominal gastrostomy published by the Society of Interventional Radiology (SIR) and American Gastroenterological Association (AGA) acknowledge both techniques but have no official recommendation on the use of gastropexy reflecting the lack of clear evidence regarding advantage with or without its use.
The investigators hypothesize that the use of gastropexy for PRG does not significantly decrease complications.
The investigators also hypothesize that the use of gastropexy is associated with increased post procedural pain.
At the investigators' institution (University Health Network) PRG without gastropexy is regularly performed first-line for gastrostomy. There is a high volume of requests for PRG and thus establishing which method is superior will help to reduce the number of complications and revisions. In doing so, the investigators hope to be able to establish an optimal evidence-based protocol for PRG for future patients as well as improving patient safety and satisfaction.
研究设计
- 研究类型
- Interventional
- 分配方式
- Randomized
- 干预模型
- Parallel
- 主要目的
- Other
- 盲法
- Single (Outcomes Assessor)
盲法说明
Patients and interventional radiologists cannot be blinded to the procedure as the follow up and performing the procedure for gastropexy versus non-gastropexy is different.
入排标准
- 年龄范围
- 18 Years 至 —（Adult, Older Adult）
- 性别
- All
- 接受健康志愿者
- 否
入选标准
- •Adults (age 18 years and older) meeting standard eligibility criteria for percutaneous radiologic gastrostomy
- •Dysphagia related to malignancy or surgery/radiation therapy
- •Able to appropriately understand and complete English questionnaires either independently or with the assistance of a translator
排除标准
- •Unable to provide informed consent
- •Unable or unwilling to complete the pre and post-procedure questionnaires
- •Dysphagia related to neurological deficits
- •Large volume of ascites
- •Prior partial gastrectomy
- •Long-term steroid use
研究组 & 干预措施
Gastropexy
Percutaneous radiologic guided insertion of G-tube. The skin over the epigastrium is prepared and draped in sterile fashion. Midazolam and fentanyl are administered for conscious sedation. Lidocaine for local analgesia. The stomach is insufflated with air after insertion of an OG or NG tube. Two T-fasteners are inserted into the stomach approximately 4cm apart. A needle is inserted into the stomach and an Amplatz wire is then inserted into the stomach. The tract is dilated with an 18Fr peel away sheath. A 14 Fr balloon retention gastrostomy tube is inserted. The balloon is inflated and bolster set as appropriate. The gastropexy/T-fastener sutures are cut after one week.
干预措施: Gastropexy. (Device)
Non-Gastropexy
Percutaneous radiologic guided insertion of G-tube. The skin over the epigastrium is prepared and draped in sterile fashion. Midazolam and fentanyl are administered for conscious sedation. Lidocaine for local analgesia. The stomach is insufflated with air after insertion of an OG or NG tube. A needle is inserted into the stomach and an Amplatz wire is then inserted into the stomach. The tract is dilated with an 18Fr peel away sheath. A 14 Fr balloon retention gastrostomy tube is inserted. The balloon is inflated and bolster set as appropriate.
干预措施: Non-Gastropexy (Procedure)
结局指标
主要结局
Pain level as reported on 10-point Visual Analog Scale
时间窗: Pre-procedure baseline measure, post-procedure (day 1) measure, and 30 day post-procedure measure
10-point Visual Analog Scale (VAS) (0 = no pain, 10 = worst pain imaginable) with specific procedure-related questions, as outlined in the pre- and post-procedure questionnaire.
次要结局
- Complications(30 days post-procedure follow-up.)
研究者
Ganesan Annamalai
Principal Investigator
University Health Network, Toronto