Diagnostic Test Accuracy of Histological Muscle and Skin Biopsies of Rheumatoid Arthritis Patients Revealing Objective Chronic Widespread Pain Phenomena Related to Fibromyalgia
试验速览
- 阶段
- 不适用
- 状态
- 已完成
- 发起方
- 入组人数
- 48
- 试验地点
- 1
- 主要终点
- Muscle pathology
研究概览
简要总结
Background: Chronic widespread pain is challenging in the management of the patient with rheumatoid arthritis (RA), affecting approximately one third of this patient population. However, pain is not always caused by disease activity (inflammation) but can be associated to central pain mechanisms as seen in fibromyalgia (FM). FM is characterized by widespread pain and tenderness; often accompanied by disturbed sleep, fatigue, cognitive impairment, emotional distress and multiple symptoms from various organ systems. Among patients with RA the prevalence of concomitant FM is reported to be 12-17% compared to 1-3% in the general population. In general the pain, felt by the fibromyalgia patients is considered to be due to lower pain thresholds because of abnormal central pain processing. Pain reported by RA patients with concomitant FM could potentially be explained by this phenomenon. Little is known about RA patients fulfilling criteria for FM. Muscles-studies of FM patients have not found any histopathological explanation of the pain felt, however an old study of muscle changes in RA patients found changes that could explain muscle pain. Small fiber neuropathy (SFN) is a condition associated with autoimmune diseases, and evidence suggests that SFN is likely to contribute to the pain observed in FM.
Objectives: To determine the diagnostic test accuracy (sensitivity and specificity) of both muscle- and skin-biopsies for fibromyalgia phenotyping and detection by clinical referral (RA with concomitant FM) as the reference standard (i.e. fulfilment of 2016 FM criteria).
Data collection: Will be done as study subjects are included and stored in REDCAP.
Eligibility criteria for participants and settings where the data will be collected: RA patients will be assessed in the daily clinic in Esbjerg and Odense and examined for concomitant FM (I.e. satisfying the 2016 criteria for FM). Patients will afterwards be invited to participate in the study. Inclusion will continue until 25 RA patients fulfilling FM criteria and thus based on the expected prevalence at least 25 (- and maximum 50) RA patients not fulfilling FM critieria has undergone the index tests.
Whether participants form a consecutive, random, or convenience series: Participants form a consecutive series.
Description of the index test and reference standard: Twenty-five RA patients with concomitant FM and more than 25 (- maximum 50 patients) RA patients not fulfilling FM criteria will undergo the index tests. Muscle and skin biopsies will be performed in each group using standardized techniques. The reference standard will be fulfillment of the 2016 criteria for fibromyalgia.
Estimates of diagnostic accuracy and their precision: Regarding muscle- and skin biopsies sensitivity, specificity and positive predictive value will be calculated using two times two table. Regarding skin biopsies, median values in the two groups (RA +/- FM) will be compared using a two-sample t-test.
详细描述
To determine the diagnostic test accuracy (the sensitivity and specificity) of both muscle- and skin-biopsies for fibromyalgia phenotyping and detection by clinical referral (RA with concomitant CWP) as the reference standard (i.e. fulfilment of 2016 FM criteria).
Background Pain poses a huge challenge in the management of Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients, affecting approximately half of this patient population, even in patients with low disease activity. 1/3 report significant pain. As the composite DAS-28 score has become the standard tool for monitoring RA patients in daily routine, the patient's history of joint pain is of great importance as it influences the VAS applied for patient global assessment and the tender joint count (TJC), which is the single factor with the highest impact on the final DAS-28 score. However, the TJC score is not always associated with clinically quantified inflammation but can be associated with central pain mechanisms, as seen in Fibromyalgia (FM). FM is characterized by widespread pain and tenderness, often accompanied by disturbed sleep, fatigue, cognitive impairment, emotional distress, and multiple symptoms from various organ systems. The prevalence of FM varies between 1-3 percent in the general population. However, among patients with RA, the prevalence is reported to be 12-17%.
The sensation of pain is a product of the interaction of multiple processes. Nociceptors transduce mechanical, chemical, or thermal stimuli into electric signals, which are transmitted through the dorsal horn of the spinal cord to the brainstem and higher cortical areas. The Periaqueductal grey substance (PAG) and the rostral ventromedial medulla (RVM) modulate the pain signal through descending pathways to the dorsal horn of the medulla. In chronic pain states, changes in nociceptive signaling may involve sensitization of nociceptive neurons and ascending spinal tracts accompanied by dysfunction of descending pain modulatory pathways. Changes in nociceptive signaling with lowering of pain thresholds could be an explanation of a high TJC in RA patients if inflammation is not present. As RA patients with FM have similar complaints to patients with primary FM, including former histopathology studies in FM is relevant. Several muscle biopsy studies have been performed on FM patients with conflicting results. Four studies found no differences, three studies report changes associated with ischemia, and few studies report differences between muscle biopsies obtained from FM and healthy controls; however, no pathognomonic pathology in the FM muscles has been detected. Today, consensus exists regarding pathology in muscle biopsies with inflammatory myopathy, which was not the case when all earlier studies were performed. In our study, we apply this method to muscle biopsies from patients with RA and fibromyalgia.
Polyneuropathy is associated with autoimmune diseases. Evidence suggests that small fiber neuropathy (SFN) is likely to contribute to the pain in FM. In skin biopsies, SFN is associated with intra-epidermal nerve fiber density (IENFD). It can be evaluated histologically and quantified. The technique has recently been validated. No muscle or skin biopsy study has been performed on RA patients with or without concomitant FM.
Research question and aim. To determine the sensitivity and specificity of both muscle- and skin biopsies for fibromyalgia phenotyping and detection by clinical referral (RA with concomitant CWP) as the reference standard (i.e., fulfillment of 2016 FM criteria).
研究设计
- 研究类型
- Observational
- 观察模型
- Case Control
- 时间视角
- Cross Sectional
入排标准
- 年龄范围
- 18 Years 至 100 Years(Adult, Older Adult)
- 性别
- All
- 接受健康志愿者
- 否
入选标准
- •Age equal to or over 18
- •RA patient
排除标准
- •Alcohol abuse
- •Wheelchair users, and patients who require personal assistance with daily activities.
- •Medication with glucocorticoids within the last 6 weeks.
- •A diagnosis of a systemic autoimmune disease other than RA
- •Peripheral vascular disease manifested by claudication or ischemic rest pain
- •Neuropathy
- •Patients with abnormal TSH levels.
结局指标
主要结局
Muscle pathology
时间窗: The biopsies will be performed the day the patients give written consent coresponding to day/time of inclusion. Estimated period of time over which the event is assessed is 40 weeks.
Two muscle biopsies from every patient will be necessary. The proportion of patients in each group (RA with and without FM) will be compared regarding muscle fibers, the vascular domain, connective tissue, and inflammation (non-parametric tests). International consensus exists regarding clear histological signs of disease; therefore, dichotomization is feasible and relevant. Definition of and rationale for test #1 (Muscle biopsy) positivity cut-offs: The muscle pathologists evaluate the muscle biopsies, and the test result will be reported as dichotomous, that is, pathological or non-pathological according to international consensus.
Skin biopsies
时间窗: The biopsies will be performed the day the patients give written consent coresponding to day/time of inclusion. Estimated period of time over which the event is assessed is 40 weeks.
3 mm punch skin biopsies 10 cm proximal from the right ankle will be evaluated regarding IENFD density. The proportion of patients in each group (RA with and without FM) will be compared (non-parametric test). Definition of and rationale for test #2 (Skin biopsy) positivity cut-offs: Skin biopsies regarding intra epidermal nerve fiber density (IENFD) will be evaluated. IENFD will be considered abnormal according to values outside the 95% percentile of the normal range according to age. The proportion of patients with abnormal values will be compared in the two groups.
次要结局
- Computerized Cuff pressure algometry (CPA)(The Test will be performed the day the patients give written consent coresponding to day/time of inclusion. Estimated period of time over which the event is assessed is 40 weeks.)
- Cold pressure test(The Test will be performed the day the patients give written consent coresponding to day/time of inclusion. Estimated period of time over which the event is assessed is 40 weeks.)
- Pain pressure threshold (PPT)(The Test will be performed the day the patients give written consent coresponding to day/time of inclusion. Estimated period of time over which the event is assessed is 40 weeks.)
研究者
Philip Rask Lage-Hansen
MD
Esbjerg Hospital - University Hospital of Southern Denmark
