Surgical Planning and Informed Consent

Informed consent is the authorisation of an activity based on the understanding of what that activity entails in the absence of control by others. In surgery this process needs the comprehension of the benefits and the risks of the operation. Despite this, it has been argued that most surgeons do not devote adequate importance and time to this step in their daily practice; sometimes they are just afraid of scaring the patients with too many unnecessary details. Surgeons then might hide themselves behind legal booklets that should provide all information; too often though, patients do not fully realise their diseases and the possible outcomes.

New devices for anatomical studies and 3D visualization have proven to be useful for preoperative surgical planning and intra-operative procedures; the hypothesis of our study is that Surgical Theater and Vesalius (two new-generation, immersive, 3D imaging visualizers) can improve doctor-patient communication during the process of obtaining informed consent: through the tridimensional representation of anatomic structures of the brain, these devices are able to help patients better understand their anatomy, the surgical approach for their disease and possible complications.

In a prospective, randomized controlled pilot study, 40 patients undergoing neurosurgery for intracranial tumours were enrolled. Patients' cognitive function, verbal comprehension and memory were assessed before being enrolled. All groups initially underwent the standard informed consent process. Then the experimental groups received a second informed consent process with the aid of surgical planners, while the control group went through to a second round of standard informed consent. Questionnaires about appreciation, anxiety, and perceived and objective comprehension (on pathology, surgery, complications) were given.

Tridimensional surgical planners may be of great help in improving how technical information is conveyed to patients when consented for surgery. Considering that every individual has unique features, a standardised method cannot be taken into account, therefore, thanks to the case-specific 3D reconstruction of the patient's anatomy, the explanation of the surgical procedure can be customized for every patient. Using new 3D technologies is expected to reduce patients' anxiety and to improve the understanding of their conditions and the possible consequences related to any treatment options.