跳至主要内容
临床试验/NCT06579456
NCT06579456已完成不适用

FormaldEhyde-free embalmeD Cadavers as a Training Tool in a mUltimodal Structured Curriculum in Laparoscopic SURGERY: a Randomized Clinical Trial

University of Los Andes, Columbia2 个研究点 分布在 1 个国家目标入组 37 人开始时间: 2022年1月28日最近更新:
适应症

试验速览

阶段
不适用
状态
已完成
发起方
入组人数
37
试验地点
2
主要终点
Improvement in Skills in Laparoscopic Surgery using global operative assessment of laparoscopic skills (GOALS) scale

研究概览

简要总结

Development of Laparoscopic surgery skills for general surgery residents are considered competencies of major importance. Different tools are used for this purpose, including synthetic models, virtual reality, animal models and human cadaveric specimens preserved by freezing.Cadaveric models share the anatomical similarity, however have some clear disadvantages including the biological risk and the alteration of the mechanical properties of the bodies preserved by this technique, such as tissue rigidness, lack of elasticity and consistency, and the impossibility of achieving adequate pneumoperitoneum. However, we previosly devoleped a formaldehyde free solution for anatomical preservation. Hence. we propose a a single-center, single-blind, randomized educational intervention clinical trial. Research participants who meet the inclusion criteria have a theoretical and practical module on the acquisition of skills in laparoscopy and take a pre-test focused on intracorporeal enterorrhaphy. Subsequently, they are randomized by blocks into three groups: Negative Control, Positive Control, and Intervention, continuing their training in skill acquisition models, silicone models, or Formaldehyde-free solution preserved corpses, respectively. Finally they are evaluated with a post-test. Two blind experts will evaluate participants using the GOALS and OSATS scales for laparoscopic surgery.

详细描述

General surgery residents (GSR) face several challenges throughout their training, including learning and developing laparoscopic surgery skills (LSS). For GSR, who are constantly subjected to training in minimally invasive interventions, which require training in different skills than traditional surgery - such as minimal invasive manual dexterity, two-dimensional spatial perception and positioning different operating tools amongst others - simulation training (ST) plays an important role in the transition of knowledge acquisition and development of technical expertise during surgical training; The main challenge of ST in minimally invasive surgery is to recreate an environment that achieves both the basic physical parameters and provides decision-making experience during surgery, being its final objective mastering the use and location of the instruments to minimize possible errors during real life surgery. Since the inception of the concept of ST several simulation tools have been created to answer the challenges of training, however evidence suggest that frozen human or animal cadaveric models are the most preferred option by GSR.

Cadaveric models, frozen or fresh, share an anatomical similarity with real practice scenario and accurately reflect the characteristics of human tissues and thus are currently ideal for ST and development of (LSS), however, they present clear disadvantages and limitations that make their use difficult, specially the biological risk and the alteration of the mechanical properties of the bodies preserved by this technique, such as tissue rigidness, lack of elasticity and consistency, and the impossibility of achieving adequate pneumoperitoneum. In response to this issue, there are a variety of preservation techniques that do not use formaldehyde or use minimal amounts of this reagent, however these techniques present their own problems, such as elevated costs, complexity, and poor quality of preservation.

In previous work in our lab, a formaldehyde-free solution was developed and presented as a new preservation solution that claims to maintain -to a certain extent- the color, texture, rigidity, and elasticity of the tissues, allowing the clear identification of anatomical structures, and the creation of adequate pneumoperitoneum at representative low pressures for laparoscopic ST (+/- 5mmHg) after multiple tests. The corpses preserved with this solution can be used for surgical simulation, as they preserved the pose no biosafety risks comparable to those of fresh human tissues, can be reused, and pulse arterial flow can be generated by using an external peristaltic pump articulated with the system.

To our knowledge there is no evidence of the use of human cadaveric specimens preserved with formaldehyde free solutions in LSS development, whereby the aim of this manuscript is to evaluate the use of cadaveric specimens preserved with a formaldehyde free preservation solution as an alternative training tool to develop basic LSS and determine the existence of equivalence between this model and two widely used dry training models.

MATERIALS AND METHODS Design A single-center, single-blind, randomized educational intervention clinical trial was carried out to compare the use of formaldehyde free solution cadaver training in laparoscopic surgery with other traditional simulation surgery options. The trial was approved by our Institutional Research Board, prior to the beginning of the study (Act. No.201910224). Written informed consent was obtained from each participant and the CONSORT statement was followed.

研究设计

研究类型
Interventional
分配方式
Randomized
干预模型
Parallel
主要目的
Other
盲法
Single (Investigator)

入排标准

性别
All
接受健康志愿者

入选标准

  • Fourth, fifth or sixth year medical students over 18 years old who completed their general surgery rotations
  • General Surgery residents over 18 years old at any level of training Over 18 years old.

排除标准

  • Serious illnesses that affect the hability of the participant to safety and ability to complete the study.
  • Participants who have known allergies to components of the interventions or have experienced severe adverse reactions in the past will be excluded from the study.
  • Participants who cannot provide valid informed consent due to cognitive issues, mental impairment, or legal incapacity will be excluded from the study.

结局指标

主要结局

Improvement in Skills in Laparoscopic Surgery using global operative assessment of laparoscopic skills (GOALS) scale

时间窗: 48 hours

Pre- and post-intervention individual measures will be taken using the operative assessment of laparoscopic skills (GOALS) to compare the efficacy of the simulated program. The unit of measure are the points of GOALS Scale with a minum score of 5 and a maximum of 25 points. A higher score means a better outcome.

Improvement in the Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS) global rating scale

时间窗: 48

Pre- and post-intervention individual measures will be taken using the Objective Structured Assessment of Technical Skills (OSATS) Scale to compare the efficacy of the simulated program. The unit of measure are the points of OSATS Scale with a minum score of 4 points and a maximum of 20 points. A higher score means a better outcome.

次要结局

  • The efficacy given by the progression through the different multimodal methods at OSATS Scale(48 hours)
  • The efficacy given by the progression through the different multimodal methods at GOALS Scale(48 hours)

研究者

发起方
University of Los Andes, Columbia
申办方类型
Other
责任方
Principal Investigator
主要研究者

Roberto Rueda

Associate Professor

University of Los Andes, Columbia

研究点 (2)

Loading locations...

相似试验

Evaluation in a Multimodal Structured Curriculum of... | 临床试验