Overall Survival Following Interval and Delayed Cytoreduction Surgery in Advanced Stage Ovarian Cancer: a Pragmatic Phase III Randomised Controlled Trial

The standard of care for advanced stage epithelial ovarian cancer is primary cytoreduction surgery with the aim of complete cytoreduction, followed by platinum and taxane-based chemotherapy and consideration of maintenance therapy (bevacizumab or Poly ADP-ribose polymerase (PARP)-inhibitor). Neoadjuvant chemotherapy before and after interval cytoreduction surgery has become an alternative approach as randomized controlled trials have demonstrated non-inferiority of this type of management over primary surgery. In these studies, neoadjuvant chemotherapy was restricted to three to four cycles. However, real-world clinical practice varies, with centres giving more than four pre-operative cycles. The decision to delay surgery is complex and influenced by multiple factors. These include poor performance status, radiological evidence of unresectable sites of disease, or insufficient surgical resources (either lack of surgical expertise operating room availability due to waiting lists) particularly when high complexity surgery is required to achieve complete cytoreduction. International disparities in access to surgical resources between high and low-middle income country settings also results in delays to surgery.

Knowledge gap:

There is a paucity of data in the setting of extended use of neoadjuvant chemotherapy (more than four cycles). Data on the role of delayed cytoreduction surgery post four cycles are controversial. While some data have shown survival to be similar to that of patients undergoing interval cytoreductive surgery after three cycles,6-12 others have reported poorer prognosis. Conflicting data are due to selection biases such as heterogeneous inclusion criteria, small sample sizes and retrospective study designs. Delaying surgery to after four cycles has the potential to reduce surgical complexity and post-operative morbidity, and increase rates of complete cytoreduction (an independent marker of survival).

Our multi-centre, international, retrospective cohort study (GO SOAR2) of 2498 women from twenty-two centres across twelve countries with advanced stage ovary cancer, showed that interval cytoreduction surgery was associated with statistically significant greater overall survival in comparison to delayed cytoreduction surgery (HR 0.81, p=0.01) but was associated with a higher GO SOAR surgical complexity score and greater surgical morbidity. Our results indicate that early maximum effort cytoreduction surgery with complete cytoreduction in high volume centres with appropriate surgical skill mix and resources, is what is needed to increase overall survival for women with advanced stage ovarian cancer.

We present the study design for a pragmatic phase III superiority randomised controlled trial comparing overall survival following interval and delayed cytoreductive surgery.

Our hypothesis is that overall survival is greater following interval cytoreduction surgery when compared to delayed cytoreduction in women with stage III-IV epithelial ovarian cancer.