Combination Pain Therapy in HIV Neuropathy
- Conditions
- HIV InfectionsPeripheral Neuropathy
- Interventions
- Registration Number
- NCT00863057
- Brief Summary
Neuropathy results from damage to the nerves in the feet and legs. It is usually experienced as pain, tingling or numbness. In HIV-infected people, neuropathy can result from the infection itself or be a side effect of antiretroviral treatment. The purpose of this study is to determine whether two different drugs, methadone and duloxetine, reduce neuropathy-associated pain in HIV-infected people. This study will also examine whether utilization of both of these drugs is more effective than treatment with only one.
- Detailed Description
Peripheral neuropathy is now recognized as the most common neurological complication of HIV disease and its treatment. Before highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) was introduced, the prevalence of HIV-associated distal sensory polyneuropathy (DSP) was already estimated to be 35%, mostly contained to populations with moderate to advanced immunosuppression. Now, since the advent of HAART, the prevalence of HIV-associated neuropathy has increased to 52%, possibly due to a combination of antiretroviral toxic neuropathy (ATN), decreased mortality, and accumulated medical comorbidities.
Successful treatment of neuropathic pain is inherently difficult, and treatment of HIV-associated neuropathic pain is particularly complicated. To date, evidence supporting effective therapies for neuropathic HIV-associated pain is lacking, despite several types and classes of drugs having been evaluated in clinical trials. This study will evaluate the safety and efficacy of duloxetine, methadone, and the combination of duloxetine and methadone in painful HIV-associated neuropathy. Both of these drugs are approved by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) but for purposes unrelated to HIV-associated neuropathy, and no previous studies have utilized these two treatments for this purpose.
For this study, 120 participants with painful HIV-associated neuropathy will be recruited. The trial will last for approximately 23 weeks. Each participant will receive a total of 4 study treatments. The following treatment pairings will be given in a sequence determined by randomization:
1. duloxetine and methadone placebo
2. methadone and duloxetine placebo
3. duloxetine and methadone
4. duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo
Each treatment period will last 4 weeks and will be followed by a 1-week combined taper and washout.
People wishing to enroll in this study will have a screening visit that will last about 3 hours. During this visit, participants will have an HIV test, physical exam, neurologic exam, blood drawn, electrocardiogram (EKG), and a pregnancy test, if applicable. Participants will also be asked about their current health and any medications they may be taking. They will also be asked about their mood and be given the results of tests performed at the screening visit.
If screening qualifies participants for the study, they will return for a pre-entry visit lasting 2 hours. During this visit, participants will have a limited physical exam and be asked about changes in their health or medicines since screening. Participants will also be given a pain diary with instructions to record neuropathy pain every day for each of the 7 days before beginning the study and throughout the study.
After beginning the study, participants will return to the clinic for another 8 visits. These visits are at the end of each 4-week treatment period and at the end of each 1-week crossover period. At each visit, there will be a limited physical exam and participants will answer questions about their health and medications. Participants will also be told the results of routine lab tests and pregnancy tests performed during the study.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- TERMINATED
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 15
- HIV infected
- HIV-associated neuropathy
- Able and willing to provide informed consent
- Successful completion of a daily baseline pain diary over 1 week immediately prior to entry with a mean pain intensity of 4 or more on an 11-point Likert scale
- Karnofsky performance score of 60 or more within 45 days prior to entry
- Required laboratory values. More information on this criterion can be found in the study protocol.
- Willing to comply with protocol requirements for the duration of the study, to include daily completion of the pain diary as instructed, attendance at all study visits, and avoidance of prohibited medications
- On stable or no antiretroviral therapy for 30 days prior to entry. Participants on ARV therapy should plan to remain on the same regimen and drug dose for the duration of the study. Participants not on ARV therapy should have no plans to initiate therapy during study enrollment.
- Not pregnant
- Conditions that confound a diagnosis of HIV-associated neuropathy or preclude accurate assessment of neuropathy symptoms, at the discretion of the site investigator. More information on this criterion can be found in the study protocol.
- Potential for unstable neuropathy symptoms during study participation due tthe following: (1) discontinuation of dideoxynucleoside nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NRTI) within 16 weeks prior to entry, (2)treatment within 120 days prior to entry with any drug that the site investigator considers may contribute to sensory neuropathy
- Current history of significant depression on antidepressant therapy precluding withdrawal from antidepressants, upon impression of site investigator with input from the participant's mental health provider where available
- History of active substance abuse or dependence identified through medical chart review or self-report such that, in the opinion of the site investigator, participation poses undue risk for the participant
- History of alcohol-related complications within 6 months prior to entry that include but are not restricted to alcohol withdrawal seizures, alcoholic hallucinosis, delirium tremens, or being in an alcohol detoxification program - Treatment with tricyclic antidepressants, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs), bupropion, or tramadol that, upon judgment of the site investigator, cannot be tapered and discontinued prior to the pre-entry visit
- Treatment with an analgesic opioid regimen of more than 60 mg oral morphine equivalent per day within 45 days prior to entry
- Cognitive impairment that, in the opinion of the site investigator and based on clinical impression, might impact the ability to comply with the study protocol
- Use of an investigational agent within 45 days prior to entry except for expanded-access drugs or drugs used in an ACTG protocol for HIV treatment or for HIV-associated complications, if the drug is not prohibited by this protocol
- Acute active AIDS-defining opportunistic infection (OI) within 30 days prior to entry. Participants with no evidence of active disease and receiving maintenance therapy of AIDS-related OIs will be eligible
- Serious illness requiring systemic treatment and/or hospitalization within 45 days prior to entry
- End-stage renal dialysis requiring hemodialysis
- History of known or suspected hepatic cirrhosis diagnosed by signs and symptoms, radiography, or prior liver biopsy with Metavir score of more than 2
- Prolonged QTc interval (more than 0.45 seconds) within 90 days prior to entry
- Felt to be at high risk of opioid-induced respiratory compromise. More information on this criterion can be found in the study protocol.
- Diagnosis of a new seizure disorder or seizure within 90 days prior to entry
- History of acute angle-closure glaucoma, at the discretion of the site investigator
- Known allergy/sensitivity or any hypersensitivity to duloxetine, methadone, acetaminophen, or their ingredients
- Breastfeeding
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- CROSSOVER
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description 3 Methadone placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone 4 Methadone placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone placebo 3 Methadone Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone 3 Duloxetine placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone 3 Duloxetine Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone 1 Duloxetine placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo 1 Methadone placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo 2 Duloxetine placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone 2 Methadone placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone 4 Duloxetine placebo Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone placebo 1 Duloxetine Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo 1 Methadone Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo 2 Duloxetine Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone 2 Methadone Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine and methadone placebo, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone 4 Duloxetine Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone placebo 4 Methadone Participants will receive treatment in the following order: (Period 1, Weeks 1 to 4) duloxetine placebo and methadone placebo, (Period 2, Weeks 6 to 9) duloxetine and methadone, (Period 3, Weeks 11 to 14) duloxetine placebo and methadone, (Period 4, Weeks 16 to 19) duloxetine and methadone placebo
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Weekly Mean Pain Score Derived From Self-reported Average Daily Pain Intensity on an 11-point Likert Scale During the fourth treatment week of each treatment period Pain was measured on an 11-point Likert numerical rating scale, ranging from 0=''No pain" to 10=''Pain as bad as you can imagine".
Participants were given pain diaries at weeks 0, 5, 10, and 15. They started the diary 7 days prior to their clinic visits at weeks 0, 4, 9, 14, and 19. During the 7 days, each morning, they recorded their pain level due to neuropathy by circling the number that best described their neuropathy pain on average over the past 24 hours.
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Use of Rescue Medication (Acetaminophen) During each treatment period and the subsequent cross-over (or final study week) period Number of Participants With Treatment-emergent Grade 2 to 4 Adverse Events From study entry to end of study at week 20 or premature study discontinuation The DAIDS Table for Grading the Severity of Adult and Pediatric Adverse Events (DAIDS AE Grading Table), Version 1.0, December 2004 was used (see the link to the grading table in Protocol Section)
Maximum Tolerated Dose of Duloxetine and Methadone During each treatment period Number of Participants With 30% or More Improvement in Mean Pain Score on an 11-point Likert Scale At Baseline and over the fourth treatment week of each treatment period Pain was measured on an 11-point Likert numerical rating scale, ranging from 0=''No pain" to 10=''Pain as bad as you can imagine" at baseline and over the fourth treatment week of each treatment period.
The % of improvement was calculated as (x-y)/x,where x was the MPI score at baseline, and y was the MPI score at the end of each treatment stage.Number of Participants With 50% or More Improvement in Mean Pain Score on an 11-point Likert Scale At Baseline and over the fourth treatment week of each treatment period Pain was measured on an 11-point Likert numerical rating scale, ranging from 0=''No pain" to 10=''Pain as bad as you can imagine" at baseline and over the fourth treatment week of each treatment period.
The % of improvement was calculated as (x-y)/x,where x was the MPI score at baseline, and y was the MPI score at the end of each treatment stage.Mean Nighttime Pain Measure on an 11-point Likert Scale Over the fourth treatment week of each treatment period Pain was measured on an 11-point Likert numerical rating scale, ranging from 0=''No pain" to 10=''Pain as bad as you can imagine".
Participants were given pain diaries at weeks 0, 5, 10, and 15. They started the diary 7 days prior to their clinic visits at weeks 0, 4, 9, 14, and 19. During the 7 days, each morning, they recorded their pain level due to neuropathy by circling the number that best described their neuropathy pain on average during the night time.Pain-related Interference Measured by the Brief Pain Inventory (BPI) Interference Items At the fourth week of each treatment period The BPI interference scale measured level of interference with the following seven items:
1. General activity
2. Mood
3. Walking ability
4. Normal work
5. Relations with other people
6. Sleep
7. Enjoyment of life
Interference scales range from 0='Does not interfere' to 10='Completely interferes'. The overall BPI score is the mean of seven item with the minimum and maximal scores of 0 and 70, respectively.Quality of Life Measured by SF-36 Healthy Survey (SF-36) At the fourth treatment week of each treatment period The data for this outcome are not available for the analysis due to an issue with a company which provides software to calculate SF-36.
Patient and Clinician Global Impression of Change (PGIC and CGIC) on a 7-point Likert Scale At the fourth treatment week of each treatment period The GIC scale is a validated instrument that consists of seven verbal descriptors on a 7-point scale:
1. Very much improved
2. Much improved
3. Minimally improved
4. No change
5. Minimally worse
6. Much worse
7. Very much worse
Participants were carefully instructed to consider the impact of study treatments on their level of neuropathic pain intensity during the baseline phase of the study.Emotional Functioning as Measured by the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) At the fourth treatment week of each treatment period The CES-D is a 20-item self-report rating inventory measuring characteristic attitudes and symptoms of depression. Participants were asked to score each item: (0) Rarely, (1) Occasionally, (2) Sometimes, and (3) Most of time. Some items are multiplied by -1 to change direction. The overall CES-D score is simply the sum of 20 items. The highest possible total CES-D score is 48, and the lowest possible score is -12. The total CES-D score is considered missing if more than 4 items are not answered.
Trial Locations
- Locations (8)
Houston AIDS Research Team CRS
🇺🇸Houston, Texas, United States
Ucsd, Avrc Crs
🇺🇸San Diego, California, United States
Harbor-UCLA Med. Ctr. CRS
🇺🇸Torrance, California, United States
Massachusetts General Hospital ACTG CRS
🇺🇸Boston, Massachusetts, United States
MetroHealth CRS
🇺🇸Cleveland, Ohio, United States
Northwestern University CRS
🇺🇸Chicago, Illinois, United States
University of Colorado Hospital CRS
🇺🇸Aurora, Colorado, United States
Washington U CRS
🇺🇸Saint Louis, Missouri, United States