Accelerated TMS to a Novel Brain Target in MDD and PTSD

Not Applicable

Completed

• Conditions: Major Depressive Disorder; Post Traumatic Stress Disorder
• Interventions: Device: Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS); Behavioral: Task; Procedure: fMRI-guided TMS target

• Registration Number: NCT03114891
• Lead Sponsor: University of Pennsylvania

Brief Summary

This is a Clinical Trial designed to evaluate novel transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) methods for treating depression/PTSD. TMS is an FDA-approved procedure for treatment-resistant depression. The use of the stimulation in this current study is considered experimental. The purpose of this research study is to compare the effects of TMS at two different brain regions. This information will help the investigators to determine which treatment strategies provide the greatest clinical benefit to patients. Results of the study will provide brain and behavior measures for future work, which may be critical to developing effective disease markers and novel treatments for psychiatric conditions.

Detailed Description

Non-invasive transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) is now FDA-approved for the treatment of major depressive disorder (MDD). However, there is growing evidence that the targeting strategy for delivering TMS treatment would yield superior clinical outcomes if it were more tailored to individual neuroanatomy. The current study take this idea one step further and suggest that functional MRI guided TMS might yield an even greater leap forward in promoting optimal clinical outcomes.

The sgACC has been well established as a brain area sensitive to negative mood inductions and implicated in neural abnormalities associated with affective and stress disorders. It is therefore one of the primary targets for deep brain stimulation (DBS) treatment of MDD using surgically implanted DBS devices. Recent posthoc imaging studies of patients who have undergone TMS treatment for depression suggest that treatment outcomes tended to be better when patients were by chance stimulated in an area of lateral prefrontal cortex that had high levels of functional connectivity with sgACC. Based on this finding and on interleaved TMS/fMRI probe data, the investigators contend that targeting delivery of TMS to the brain surface non-invasively as indicated by sgACC resting functional connectivity may be especially effective in downregulating sgACC and thereby producing superior clinical outcomes.

Researchers have used TMS/fMRI to better understand causal communication among circuits typically examined with resting fMRI alone. Recent work suggests that there are specific sites that, when stimulated, influence subcortical brain areas implicated in affective disorders such as the sgACC. Previously, TMS targets were based on brain atlases mapped onto individual brain surfaces. This proposal will utilize more individualized targeting from participants' own resting connectivity data to guide stimulation that we show is especially effective in influencing downstream brain areas of interest. The investigators will focus on a target region of the lateral prefrontal cortex (LPFC) that data suggest is particularly effective at influencing the sgACC. As an alternative brain target, we will also test the efficacy of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex as a target given its precedence in the literature as an effective stimulation site for remediating depressive symptoms. The target will be chosen based on an atlas and will adjust the target coordinates based on the inverse of a nonlinear normalization of each participant's brain to standard brain space. Thus, individual anatomical differences will be taken account with this target though without guidance from individual functional imaging data.

To increase generalizability to other disorders and to patients with comorbid anxiety and depression (the typical clinical profile), the investigators will recruit patients who are diagnosed PTSD and have symptoms of depression or those who experience trauma-induced MDD. Participants will be scanned in an MRI to get anatomical and resting fMRI data to guide TMS, then participants will be invited to participate in two rounds of two week TMS treatment to each site (order counterbalanced) with one month between treatments. Participants will be monitored to assess PTSD symptoms, depressive symptoms,and quality of life before, acutely after, and one month following TMS treatments to evaluate the effectiveness of each site in mitigating symptoms or improving functioning.

Study Timeline

• Study First Submitted: 2017-04-04
• Study First Submitted QC: 2017-04-10
• Study First Posted: 2017-04-14
• Study Start: 2017-04-20
• Primary Completion: 2021-12-01
• Study Completion: 2021-12-01
• Results First Submitted: 2022-04-04
• Status Verified: 2023-04
• Results First Submitted QC: 2023-04-13
• Last Update Submitted: 2023-04-13
• Results First Posted: 2023-05-06
• Last Update Posted: 2023-05-06

Recruitment & Eligibility

• Status: COMPLETED
• Sex: All
• Target Recruitment: 50

Inclusion Criteria

1. 18-60 years old, male or female, any race
2. Patients must currently meet sufficient DSM criteria for PTSD and have symptoms of depression; or meet criteria for trauma-induced MDD
3. Capacity to give informed consent and follow study procedures
4. English speaking

Read More

Exclusion Criteria

1. Outside age range
2. Patient does not meet sufficient DSM criteria for PTSD or MDD
3. Psychiatric medication use
4. Significant handicaps (e.g. mental handicap) that would interfere with testing procedures
5. MRI contraindications
6. Additional TMS contraindications
7. Medication use that substantially reduces seizure threshold to TMS (olanzapine, chlorpromazine, lithium)
8. Opiate medication
9. Known neurological disorders including multiple sclerosis, encephalopathy, seizure disorder, brain tumors
10. Current alcohol or substance abuse disorder (moderate or severe)
11. Current schizophrenia or other psychotic disorder, or current bipolar disorder
12. Refusal to abstain from illicit drug use for the duration of the study
13. Refusal to abstain from alcohol within 24 hours of the MRI scan
14. Pregnancy
15. Newly initiated psychotherapy (less than 6 weeks)

Read More

Study & Design

• Study Type: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Design: CROSSOVER

Arm && Interventions

Group	Intervention	Description
First Round: 6cm Target/Video, Second Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task	Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)	First round: This 'standard' target will be identified by measuring 6cm anterior of the hand knob. Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this to this target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their fMRI-guided target (cortical target influencing sgACC). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task.
First Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task, Second Round: 6cm Target/Video	Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)	First round: This site of stimulation will be created from participants' individualized resting connectivity data. We will identify a cortical target in the left prefrontal cortex (LPFC) that influences the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC). Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this fMRI-guided target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their 'standard' target (6cm anterior of their hand knob). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video.
First Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task, Second Round: 6cm Target/Video	fMRI-guided TMS target	First round: This site of stimulation will be created from participants' individualized resting connectivity data. We will identify a cortical target in the left prefrontal cortex (LPFC) that influences the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC). Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this fMRI-guided target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their 'standard' target (6cm anterior of their hand knob). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video.
First Round: fMRI-guided Target/Video, Second Round: 6cm Target/Task	Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)	First round: This site of stimulation will be created from participants' individualized resting connectivity data. We will identify a cortical target in the left prefrontal cortex (LPFC) that influences the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC). Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this fMRI-guided target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their 'standard' target (6cm anterior of their hand knob). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task.
First Round: fMRI-guided Target/Video, Second Round: 6cm Target/Task	fMRI-guided TMS target	First round: This site of stimulation will be created from participants' individualized resting connectivity data. We will identify a cortical target in the left prefrontal cortex (LPFC) that influences the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC). Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this fMRI-guided target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their 'standard' target (6cm anterior of their hand knob). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task.
First Round: 6cm Target/Task, Second Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task	Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS)	First round: This 'standard' target will be identified by measuring 6cm anterior of the hand knob. Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this to this target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their fMRI-guided target (cortical target influencing sgACC). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video.
First Round: 6cm Target/Video, Second Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task	fMRI-guided TMS target	First round: This 'standard' target will be identified by measuring 6cm anterior of the hand knob. Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this to this target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their fMRI-guided target (cortical target influencing sgACC). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task.
First Round: fMRI-guided Target/Video, Second Round: 6cm Target/Task	Task	First round: This site of stimulation will be created from participants' individualized resting connectivity data. We will identify a cortical target in the left prefrontal cortex (LPFC) that influences the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC). Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this fMRI-guided target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their 'standard' target (6cm anterior of their hand knob). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task.
First Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task, Second Round: 6cm Target/Video	Task	First round: This site of stimulation will be created from participants' individualized resting connectivity data. We will identify a cortical target in the left prefrontal cortex (LPFC) that influences the subgenual anterior cingulate cortex (sgACC). Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this fMRI-guided target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their 'standard' target (6cm anterior of their hand knob). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video.
First Round: 6cm Target/Video, Second Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task	Task	First round: This 'standard' target will be identified by measuring 6cm anterior of the hand knob. Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this to this target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their fMRI-guided target (cortical target influencing sgACC). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task.
First Round: 6cm Target/Task, Second Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task	Task	First round: This 'standard' target will be identified by measuring 6cm anterior of the hand knob. Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this to this target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their fMRI-guided target (cortical target influencing sgACC). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video.
First Round: 6cm Target/Task, Second Round: fMRI-guided Target/Task	fMRI-guided TMS target	First round: This 'standard' target will be identified by measuring 6cm anterior of the hand knob. Two daily sessions (\~10min apart) of intermittent theta-burst stimulation will be administered to this to this target for 10 consecutive weekdays. Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will complete a working memory task. Second round: After 3 weeks, participants will undergo another set of two daily iTBS sessions for 10 consecutive weekdays to their fMRI-guided target (cortical target influencing sgACC). Between the two iTBS sessions, participants will watch a relaxing nature video.

Primary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Percent Change in Depression Severity of TMS at fMRI-guided Brain Target vs Standard Brain Target	Before and after the first round of two weeks of TMS treatment (two daily iTBS sessions over 10 consecutive weekdays)	We used the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS) to measure depression severity after TMS at fMRI-guided brain target vs standard brain target. The MADRS is clinician-rated and consists of 10 items; each item is rated on a 0-6 scale, resulting in a maximum total score of 60 points. Higher MADRS score indicates more severe depression.; For this outcome, we calculated the change (percent decrease) from the participant's baseline MADRS score to their MADRS score after the first round of TMS (to either fMRI-guided brain target or standard brain target). If the outcome is positive, there was a reduction in the MADRS total score, or a reduction in the presence of depressive symptoms after TMS. If the change is negative, there was an increase in the MADRS total score, or an increase in the presence of depressive symptoms after TMS.; Higher positive values means better outcome (or more symptom reduction).

Trial Locations

Locations (1)

University of Pennsylvania; 🇺🇸 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States