Maternal Hyperoxygenation for Intrapartum Fetal Heart Rate Tracing Abnormalities: a Randomized Clinical Trial

Continuous fetal heart rate tracing is part of the standard practice during intrapartum obstetric management. The goal of fetal heart rate monitoring is to identify early signs of fetal distress during labor, initiate effective interventions to improve fetal outcomes and reduce the risk of cesarean and operative vaginal delivery, and when interventions fail to improve the fetal status, to help guide the decision to proceed with operative delivery in order to minimize fetal/neonatal morbidity as a result of fetal intolerance to labor.

There are four major components to fetal heart tracing that guide obstetric management: baseline, variability, acceleration, and deceleration (uterine contraction pattern is also assessed to guide management). When one or more of these components are outside of normal values, it may be associated with fetal hypoxemia/acidemia. The typical management of these abnormal findings include maternal reposition, IV fluid bolus, increase maternal blood pressure, stopping uterine contractions, amnioinfusion, and maternal oxygen. The goal of therapy is to increase maternal blood flow to the uterus and therefore improve maternal-placental perfusion, increase oxygen delivery to and carbon dioxide removal from the fetus.

Maternal oxygenation is part of the standard management of fetal tracing abnormalities nationwide, and is part of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) guideline for this specific indication. Its use intuitively make sense, as one of the major concerns with fetal tracing abnormalities is the development of fetal hypoxemia leading to anaerobic metabolism and the ensuing development of metabolic acidosis. However, clinical evidence to support its use is lacking. This is partly due to the long-ingrained culture of routine oxygen delivery on Labor and Delivery across the country, therefore no clinical trails were considered until recently. More importantly, from a physiologic standpoint, the fetal hemoglobin has significantly higher oxygen affinity compared to adult hemoglobin. Therefore, increasing maternal oxygen saturation does not lead to significant change in fetal oxygen saturation in general. In addition, some of the reasons for the development of fetal hypoxemia and acidemia are due to placental insufficiency or umbilical cord compression. In these circumstances, there is limited oxygen delivery in the fetal circulation at the maternal-fetal interface and therefore maternal oxygen therapy will have limited effects on fetal oxygenation.

Furthermore, there is growing concern regarding the potential risks associated with supraphysiologic oxygen levels. At a cellular level, hyperoxygenation increased the production of oxygen free radicals, which results in cell damage. This is reflected in the neonatal literature regarding hyperoxygenation during neonatal resuscitation, including higher risk for respiratory and neurologic complications, the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) no longer recommend initial neonatal hyperoxygenation during resuscitation. There are similar concerns in oxygen use during obstetric management in recent literature. A number of studies have demonstrated higher risk of neonatal complications associated with maternal intrapartum hyperoxygenation (3-6). However, the evidences have not been adequate to change the clinical practice because the majority of these studies either focused on biological differences rather than clinical outcomes data or were retrospective rather than randomized trials.

Given the ingrained nature of maternal oxygen therapy, the lack of clinical evidence in favor of its use, and concerns regarding potential harm, large scale clinical trials are needed to assess the risks and benefits of the current standard practice. Therefore, the investigators propose a large single center randomized clinical trial to determine the effects of maternal hyperoxygenation therapy for the treatment of fetal heart rate tracing abnormalities.