Catheter Ablation vs Anti-arrhythmic Drug Therapy for Atrial Fibrillation Trial

Not Applicable

Completed

Conditions: Atrial Fibrillation
Arrhythmia

Interventions: Device: Left atrial ablation
Drug: Rate or Rhythm Control Therapy

Registration Number: NCT00911508

Lead Sponsor: Mayo Clinic

Brief Summary: The (Catheter Ablation Versus Anti-arrhythmic Drug Therapy for Atrial Fibrillation Trial) CABANA Trial has the overall goal of establishing the appropriate roles for medical and ablative intervention for atrial fibrillation (AF). The CABANA Trial is designed to test the hypothesis that the treatment strategy of left atrial catheter ablation for the purpose of eliminating atrial fibrillation (AF) will be superior to current state-of-the-art therapy with either rate control or rhythm control drugs for decreasing the incidence of the composite endpoint of total mortality, disabling stroke, serious bleeding, or cardiac arrest in patients with untreated or incompletely treated AF.

Detailed Description: The need for this trial arises out of 1) the rapidly increasing number of pts \> 60 years of age with AF accompanied by symptoms and morbidity, 2) the failure of anti-arrhythmic drug therapy to maintain sinus rhythm and reduce mortality, 3) the rapidly increasing application of radio-frequency catheter ablation without appropriate evidence-based validation, and 4) the expanding impact of AF on health care costs.

This study will randomize up to 2200 patients to a strategy of catheter ablation versus pharmacologic therapy with rate or rhythm control drugs. Each pt will have 1) characteristics similar to AFFIRM pts (≥65 yo or \<65 with \>1 risk factor for stroke, 2) Documented AF warranting treatment, and 3) Eligibility for both catheter ablation and ≥2 anti-arrhythmic or ≥2 rate control drugs. Pts will be followed every 6 months for an average of approximately 5 years and will undergo repeat trans-telephonic monitor, Holter monitor, and CT/MR studies to assess the impact of treatment.

The CABANA trial will disclose the role of medical and non-pharmacologic therapies for AF, establish the cost and impact of therapy on quality of life and will help determine if AF is a modifiable risk factor for increased mortality.

Recruitment & Eligibility

Status: COMPLETED

Sex: All

Target Recruitment: 2204

Inclusion Criteria

Over the preceding 6 months have:
1. ≥2 paroxysmal (electrocardiographic documentation of at least 1) atrial fibrillation (AF) episodes lasting ≥1 hour in duration: (that terminate spontaneously within 7 days or cardioversion is performed within 48h of AF onset): or
2. electrocardiographic documentation of 1 persistent AF episode: (sustained for ≥7 days or cardioversion is performed more than 48h after AF onset): or
3. electrocardiographic documentation of 1 longstanding persistent AF episode: (continuous AF of duration >1 year).
Warrant active therapy (within the past 3 months) beyond simple ongoing observation
Be eligible for catheter ablation and ≥2 sequential rhythm control and/or ≥2 rate control drugs.
Be ≥65 yrs of age, or <65 yrs with one or more of the following risk factors for stroke: Hypertension (treated and/or defined as a blood pressure >140/90 mmHg) [90], Diabetes (treated and/or defined as a fasting glucose ≥126 mg/dl) [91], Congestive heart failure (including systolic or diastolic heart failure), Prior stroke, transient ischemic attack or systemic emboli, Atherosclerotic vascular disease (previous myocardial infarction (MI), peripheral arterial disease or aortic plaque), left atrial (LA) size >5.0 cm (or volume index ≥40 cc/m2), or ejection fraction (EF) ≤35.
Have the capacity to understand and sign an informed consent form.
Be ≥18 years of age.
- NOTE- Subjects <65 yrs of age whose only risk factor is hypertension must have a second risk factor or left ventricular (LV) hypertrophy to qualify.Patients receiving new drug therapy initiated within the previous 3 months may continue that therapy if randomized to the drug therapy arm. Patients may have documented atrial flutter in addition to atrial fibrillation and remain eligible for enrollment.

Exclusion Criteria

Lone AF in the absence of risk factors for stroke in patients <65 years of age
Patients who in the opinion of the managing clinician should not yet receive any therapy for AF
Patients who have failed >2 membrane active anti-arrhythmic drugs at a therapeutic dose due to inefficacy or side effects (Table 5.2.2)
An efficacy failure of full dose amiodarone treatment >8 weeks duration at any time
Reversible causes of AF including thyroid disorders, acute alcohol intoxication, recent major surgical procedures, or trauma
Recent cardiac events including MI, percutaneous intervention (PCI), or valve or bypass surgery in the preceding 3 months
Hypertrophic obstructive cardiomyopathy (outflow track)
Class IV angina or Class IV congestive heart failure (CHF) (including past or planned heart transplantation)
Other arrhythmias mandating anti-arrhythmic drug therapy (i.e. ventricular tachycardia (VT), ventricular fibrillation (VF))
Heritable arrhythmias or increased risk for torsade de pointes with class I or III drugs
Prior LA catheter ablation with the intention of treating AF
Prior surgical interventions for AF such as the MAZE procedure
Prior AV nodal ablation
Patients with other arrhythmias requiring ablative therapy
Contraindication to appropriate anti-coagulation therapy
Renal failure requiring dialysis
Medical conditions limiting expected survival to <1 year
Women of childbearing potential (unless post-menopausal or surgically sterile)
Participation in any other clinical mortality trial (Participation in other non-mortality trials should be reviewed with the clinical trial management center)
Unable to give informed consent
- NOTE- Prior ablation of the cavo-tricuspid isthmus alone is not an exclusion if the patient develops subsequent recurrent AF. Planned atrial flutter ablation in combination with the left atrial ablation is not an exclusion.

Study & Design

Study Type: INTERVENTIONAL

Study Design: PARALLEL

Arm && Interventions

Group	Intervention	Description
Left Atrial Ablation	Left atrial ablation	Pulmonary vein isolation using a circumferential ablative approach in the left atrium. Ablation may be performed using circular mapping catheter-guided ablation, antral isolation using a circular guided approach, or wide area circumferential ablation.
Rate or Rhythm Control Therapy	Rate or Rhythm Control Therapy	Current state-of-the-art drug therapy for atrial fibrillation (rate control or rhythm control). Treating physicians will be encouraged to follow the American College of Cardiology / American Heart Association / European Society of Cardiology Atrial Fibrillation Guidelines with regard to drug therapy for atrial fibrillation. The specific choice of rate control versus rhythm control drug therapy and the specific drugs to be used will ultimately be left to the discretion of the treating physician.

Primary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Number of Participants With Composite of Total Mortality, Disabling Stroke, Serious Bleeding, or Cardiac Arrest in Patients Warranting Therapy for AF.	From date of enrollment until time-to-first event over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	All events for each component of the primary endpoint were reviewed and adjudicated in a blinded fashion by an independent clinical events committee using prospectively determined event definitions. Death was defined as all-cause mortality, disabling stroke (including intracranial bleeding) as an irreversible physical limitation defined by a Rankin Stroke Scale ≥2, and serious bleeding as bleeding accompanied by hemodynamic compromise that required surgical intervention or a transfusion of ≥3 units of blood.

Secondary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Number of Participants With All-cause Mortality	From date of enrollment until date of death over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	All deaths were reviewed and adjudicated by the Clinical Events Committee
Number of Participants With Mortality or Cardiovascular (CV) Hospitalization	From date of enrollment until time-to-first event of death or CV hospitalization over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	Hospitalization was characterized by the site principal investigator (PI) and reported as part of the hospitalization case report form.
Number of Participants With Mortality, Disabling Stroke, or CV Hospitalization (for Heart Failure or Acute Ischemic Events)	From date of enrollment until time-to-first event of death, stroke, or CV hospitalization (for heart failure or acute ischemic event) over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	Disabling stroke (including intracranial bleeding) was defined as an irreversible physical limitation defined by a Rankin Stroke Scale ≥2 and the reason for hospitalization was characterized by the site PI and reported as part of the hospitalization case report form.
Number of Participants With Cardiovascular Death	From date of enrollment until date of a cardiovascular death over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	Cardiovascular death as determined by the Clinical Events Committee based on the available data provided by the Principal Investigator
Number of Participants With Cardiovascular Death or Disabling Stroke	From date of enrollment until time-to-first event of a cardiovascular death or disabling stroke over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	Disabling stroke (including intracranial bleeding) was defined as an irreversible physical limitation defined by a Rankin Stroke Scale ≥2.
Number of Participants With an Arrhythmic Death or Cardiac Arrest	From date of enrollment until time-to-first event for an arrhythmic death or cardiac arrest over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	All deaths and cardiac arrest events were adjudicated by the Clinical Events Committee
Number of Participants With Heart Failure Death	From date of enrollment until date of heart failure death over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	All deaths were categorized and adjudicated by the Clinical Events Committee
Number of Participants Free From Recurrent Atrial Fibrillation (AF) Following the 90 Day Blanking Period	From date of therapy initiation until date of first AF recurrence following a 90 day wait (blanking) period over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	Data from patients using the study provided ECG event recording system were analyzed. A 30-second episode of AF in either group, confirmed through blinded review by an ECG Core Lab Committee was used for defining the endpoint of recurrent AF.
Number of Participants With Cardiovascular Hospitalization	From date of enrollment until date of cardiovascular hospitalization over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	The reason for hospitalization was characterized by the site PI and reported as part of the hospitalization case report form.
Changes in Quality of Life Measures - AFEQT	Baseline ,12 month, 5 years	Atrial Fibrillation Effect on Quality of Life (AFEQT) Overall Score (Scale: 0 = complete disability, 100 = no disability). The AFEQT is a 21-item AF-specific, health-related QOL questionnaire designed to assess the effect of atrial fibrillation on patient quality of life. The AFEQT has an Overall Score (calculated from 18 of the questions) and subscale scores in three domains: symptoms, daily activities, and treatment concern. Overall and subscale scores range from 0 (corresponds to complete disability) to 100 (no AF-related disability).
Changes in Quality of Life Measures - MAFSI Frequency Score	Baseline, 12 Month, 5 Year	The Mayo AF-Specific Symptom Inventory (MAFSI) is a questionnaire comprised of a 10-item AF symptom checklist that asked about both the frequency and severity of each symptom. MAFSI frequency of symptoms over the past month was recorded as 0 (never), 1 (rarely), 2 (sometimes), 3 (often), and 4 (always) for each of the 10 items listed in the questionnaire. The 10 item responses were summed for a total Frequency Score that ranged from 0 (no AF symptoms) to 40 (worst score).
Changes in Quality of Life Measures - MAFSI Severity Score	Baseline, 12 Month, 5 Year	The Mayo AF-Specific Symptom Inventory (MAFSI) is a questionnaire comprised of a 10-item AF symptom checklist that asked about both the frequency and severity of each symptom. MAFSI severity scores over the past month were recorded as 1 (mild), 2 (moderate), and 3 (extreme) for each of the 10 items listed in the questionnaire. The 10 items items were then summed for the total Severity Score that ranged from 0 (no AF symptoms) to 30 (most severe AF symptoms).
Number of Participants With Adverse Events/Complications	From treatment start date to date of event over a median follow-up of 48.5 months.	Comparing individual non-endpoint adverse events between ablative and drug therapy is difficult due to the substantial difference in the types of adverse events expected. Ablation-related events were counted among all patients that were randomized to and received an ablation. Drug-related events were counted among all patients that were randomized to and received drug therapy.

Trial Locations

Locations (118): Ohio State University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Columbus, Ohio, United States
Drexel University College of Medicine
🇺🇸
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
Good Samaritan Hospital
🇺🇸
Los Angeles, California, United States
Cleveland Clinic Foundation
🇺🇸
Cleveland, Ohio, United States
Massachusetts General Hospital
🇺🇸
Boston, Massachusetts, United States
Brigham and Womens Hospital
🇺🇸
Boston, Massachusetts, United States
University of Washington Medical Center
🇺🇸
Seattle, Washington, United States
University of Miami Hospital
🇺🇸
Miami, Florida, United States
Minneapolis V.A. Medical Center
🇺🇸
Minneapolis, Minnesota, United States
Duke University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Durham, North Carolina, United States
University of Cincinnati Medical Center
🇺🇸
Cincinnati, Ohio, United States
Guangdong Provincial People's Hospital
🇨🇳
Guangzhou, Guangdong, China
University of California at San Francisco Medical Center
🇺🇸
San Francisco, California, United States
Henry Ford Hospital
🇺🇸
Detroit, Michigan, United States
Vanderbilt University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Nashville, Tennessee, United States
Intermountain Medical Center-LDS Hospital
🇺🇸
Salt Lake City, Utah, United States
Providence Saint Vincent Medical Center
🇺🇸
Portland, Oregon, United States
Southlake Regional Health Centre
🇨🇦
Newmarket, Ontario, Canada
Bakoulev Scientific Center for Cardiovascular Surgery
🇷🇺
Moscow, Russian Federation
Asklepios Klinik St. Georg
🇩🇪
Hamburg, Germany
Arkansas Cardiology, PA
🇺🇸
Little Rock, Arkansas, United States
Stanford University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Stanford, California, United States
University of California Los Angeles
🇺🇸
Los Angeles, California, United States
Penrose Saint Francis Health Services
🇺🇸
Colorado Springs, Colorado, United States
Hartford Hospital
🇺🇸
Hartford, Connecticut, United States
George Washington University Medical Faculty Associates
🇺🇸
Washington, District of Columbia, United States
Tallahassee Memorial Hospital
🇺🇸
Tallahassee, Florida, United States
Northside Hospital and Heart Institute
🇺🇸
Saint Petersburg, Florida, United States
Alexian Brothers Medical Center
🇺🇸
Barrington, Illinois, United States
Mercy Medical Center-Iowa Heart Center
🇺🇸
West Des Moines, Iowa, United States
Georgia Regents University
🇺🇸
Augusta, Georgia, United States
NorthShore University Health System
🇺🇸
Evanston, Illinois, United States
Johns Hopkins Hospital
🇺🇸
Baltimore, Maryland, United States
Rush University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Chicago, Illinois, United States
Saint Joseph Mercy Hospital
🇺🇸
Ypsilanti, Michigan, United States
Jackson Heart Clinic
🇺🇸
Jackson, Mississippi, United States
Park Nicollet Methodist Hospital
🇺🇸
Saint Louis Park, Minnesota, United States
Cooper University Hospital
🇺🇸
Camden, New Jersey, United States
Saint John's Mercy Heart Health Center
🇺🇸
Saint Louis, Missouri, United States
Saint Louis Heart and Vascular
🇺🇸
Saint Louis, Missouri, United States
Hackensack University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Hackensack, New Jersey, United States
Albany Associates in Cardiology
🇺🇸
Albany, New York, United States
New York University Langone Medical Center
🇺🇸
New York, New York, United States
Robert Wood Johnson University Hospital
🇺🇸
New Brunswick, New Jersey, United States
Columbia University Medical Center
🇺🇸
New York, New York, United States
Stony Brook University Hospital and Medical Center
🇺🇸
Stony Brook, New York, United States
The Sanger Clinic, PA
🇺🇸
Charlotte, North Carolina, United States
Oklahoma Heart Institute
🇺🇸
Tulsa, Oklahoma, United States
Oregon Health and Science University
🇺🇸
Portland, Oregon, United States
Penn State University Cardiovascular Center
🇺🇸
Hershey, Pennsylvania, United States
Geisinger Wyoming Valley Medical Center
🇺🇸
Danville, Pennsylvania, United States
V.A. Pittsburgh Healthcare System
🇺🇸
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, United States
Greenville Hospital System University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Greenville, South Carolina, United States
University of Pennsylvania Health System
🇺🇸
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States
Lankenau Hospital
🇺🇸
Wynnewood, Pennsylvania, United States
The Heart Hospital Baylor Plano
🇺🇸
Plano, Texas, United States
University of Texas Health Science Center
🇺🇸
Houston, Texas, United States
South Texas Cardiovascular Consultants
🇺🇸
San Antonio, Texas, United States
Baylor All Saints Medical Center
🇺🇸
Fort Worth, Texas, United States
Scott and White Memorial Hospital
🇺🇸
Temple, Texas, United States
Sentara Norfolk General Hospital
🇺🇸
Norfolk, Virginia, United States
Virginia Hospital Center - Arlington
🇺🇸
Falls Church, Virginia, United States
Cardiac Study Center
🇺🇸
Tacoma, Washington, United States
Swedish Medical Center - Providence Campus
🇺🇸
Seattle, Washington, United States
Royal Melbourne Hospital
🇦🇺
Parkville, Victoria, Australia
University of Western Ontario - London Health Sciences Centre
🇨🇦
London, Ontario, Canada
Royal Adelaide Hospital
🇦🇺
Adelaide, South Australia, Australia
University of Calgary
🇨🇦
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
Waukesha Memorial Hospital
🇺🇸
Waukesha, Wisconsin, United States
Hamilton Health Sciences
🇨🇦
Hamilton, Ontario, Canada
First Affiliated Hospital of Nanjing Medical University
🇨🇳
Nanjing, Jiangsu, China
First Affiliated Hospital of Dalian Medical University
🇨🇳
Dalian, Liaoning, China
Beijing Anzhen Hospital
🇨🇳
Beijing, China
Na Homolce Hospital
🇨🇿
Prague 5, Hlavni Mesto Praha, Czechia
Fuwai Hospital
🇨🇳
Beijing, China
Saint Anne's University Hospital, ICRC
🇨🇿
Brno, Czechia
Charles University
🇨🇿
Prague 2, Czechia
University Hospital of Mannheim
🇩🇪
Mannheim, Baden-Wurttemberg, Germany
Universitares Herrzentrum Hamburg
🇩🇪
Hamburg, Freie-Hansestadt Hamburg, Germany
Clinic of Cardiology IKEM Medical Institute
🇨🇿
Prague 4, Czechia
Klinikum Coburg
🇩🇪
Coburg, Bayern, Germany
Herz-und Diabeteszentrum NRW
🇩🇪
Bad Oeynhausen, Nordrhein-Westfalen, Germany
Herzzentrum Leipzig
🇩🇪
Leipzig, Germany
Technische Universitat Dresden
🇩🇪
Dresden, Saxony, Germany
CCB - Cardioaniologisches Centrum Bethanien
🇩🇪
Frankfurt, Germany
Georg-August-University
🇩🇪
Gottingen, Germany
Kerckhoff Klinik
🇩🇪
Bad Nauheim, Germany
Policlinico San Donato Center of Clinical Arrhythmia and Electrophysiology
🇮🇹
San Donato Milanese, Lombardia, Italy
Universitat Rostock
🇩🇪
Rostock, Germany
Asklepios Klinik Barmbek
🇩🇪
Hamburg, Germany
Saint Vincentius-Kliniken
🇩🇪
Karlsruhe, Germany
Policlinico Multimedical Cardiology and Arrhythmia Centre
🇮🇹
Milan, Italy
Ospedale di Circolo e Fondazione Macchi
🇮🇹
Varese, Italy
Yonsei University Severance Hospital
🇰🇷
Seoul, Korea, Republic of
Korea University Anam Hospital
🇰🇷
Seoul, Korea, Republic of
Research Institute of Circulation of Pathology
🇷🇺
Novosibirsk, Novosibirskaya Oblast, Russian Federation
Clinical Hospital # 83 under the Federal Medical and Biological Agency
🇷🇺
Moscow, Russian Federation
Scientific Research Institute of Cardiology of Ministry of Health of Russian Foundation
🇷🇺
Tomsk, Russian Federation
Golden Jubilee Hospital
🇬🇧
Glasgow, United Kingdom
Saint George's Hospital Medical School
🇬🇧
London, United Kingdom
Saint Bartholomew's Hospital
🇬🇧
London, United Kingdom
Saint Mary's Hospital
🇬🇧
London, United Kingdom
University of California Davis Medical Center
🇺🇸
Sacramento, California, United States
The Medical Center of Aurora
🇺🇸
Aurora, Colorado, United States
Florida Heart Rhythm-University of South Florida College of Medicine
🇺🇸
Tampa, Florida, United States
Mayo Clinic Rochester
🇺🇸
Rochester, Minnesota, United States
Wake Forest University Health Sciences
🇺🇸
Winston-Salem, North Carolina, United States
Georgia Arrhythmia Consultants & Research Institute
🇺🇸
Macon, Georgia, United States
Loyola University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Maywood, Illinois, United States
Memorial Health Care System
🇺🇸
Chattanooga, Tennessee, United States
Baylor Heart and Vascular Hospital
🇺🇸
Dallas, Texas, United States
University of Virginia Health System
🇺🇸
Charlottesville, Virginia, United States
Praxisklinik Herz and GefaBe
🇩🇪
Dresden, Germany
Florida Hospital
🇺🇸
Orlando, Florida, United States
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
🇺🇸
Chapel Hill, North Carolina, United States
Texas Cardiac Arrhythmia
🇺🇸
Austin, Texas, United States
Virginia Commonwealth University Medical Center
🇺🇸
Richmond, Virginia, United States
Montefiore Medical Center
🇺🇸
Bronx, New York, United States