Can Vitamin D Supplementation Improve Hepatitis C Cure Rates : A Pilot Multicentre Randomised Controlled Clinical Trial

Hepatitis C is a major health problem for Scotland with greater than 1% of the population infected; the Scottish Government has recognised this and mounted the Hepatitis C action plan, recognised as the world leading public health response to the epidemic. The key aim of this is to expand treatment access and numbers of patients cured of HCV infection to prevent patients developing the complications of cirrhosis and hepatocellular carcinoma.

The success of treatment for HCV depends on genotype and is measured by the Sustained Viral Response (SVR). The SVR is the absence of virus 24 weeks after end of treatment and has been shown to be a cure of infection. The FDA has recently suggested SVR can be assessed at 12 weeks, in clinical trials. Scotland has an equal mix of genotype 1 & 3 HCV infection accounting for greater than 95% of those infected. Treatment involves Pegylated Interferon injections weekly and Ribavirin twice daily for 6 months for HCV genotype 3 infection, with an SVR of 70%. For genotype 1 infection treatment is with the above dual therapy with the addition of a protease inhibitor, for treatment duration of 6-12 months leading to SVR rates of 65-70%. There are an increasing number of new pharmacological products in advanced development that will be available for clinicians to use but these, as well as increasing efficacy, will increase cost. So it requires clinicians to make treatment as effective as possible.

Vitamin D has traditionally been associated with bone health, with definite deficiency causing osteomalacia and making a contribution to osteoporosis. The traditional, currently used normal ranges for Vitamin D are based on prevention of bone diseases. Recently and controversially it has been suggested that low normal levels of vitamin D are associated with multiple other disease states, including cancer, infection and cardiovascular disease Additionally it has been suggested that many of the normal population in Scotland are vitamin D deficient. Other studies have shown that drug users, a high risk group for HCV infection have similarly deficient levels of vitamin D. Studies have suggested that up to 92% of those with chronic liver disease have vitamin D levels below that deemed acceptable physiologically to maintain health.

Some data is now available to support the role of vitamin D supplementation in the treatment of hepatitis C and improving SVR rates. Several observational studies have found an association between low vitamin D levels and reduced SVR rates, and additionally one study has shown an association between a single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) in vitamin D binding protein and treatment response. A small Israeli trial of vitamin D supplementation in HCV treatment has shown increased SVRs in those supplemented, but the study had a number of flaws including a failure of randomisation(13). Additionally there have been an abstract and a letter report of improved outcome with a vitamin D intervention . Biological mechanisms of interaction between vitamin D and the immune system have been explored. It has been shown that Vitamin D plays a role in the regulation of innate immunity, macrophage function, and cell mediated immunity Vitamin D receptors (VDR) are also expressed on many effector cells of the immune system; activated T and B cells, macrophages and monocytes which act to increase to enhance phagocytic action and interferon activity , it has also been suggested vitamin D has a direct effect on HCV. These give a biological basis for the effect of vitamin D on the success of antiviral therapy.

A randomised controlled trial, to be successful, requires recruitment and retention of subjects in the trial. HCV infection is associated with chaotic lifestyles which might impair the rate of recruitment and retention, although the Scottish HCV clinical database audit clearly shows that, with all comers, routine HCV care in Scotland matches the results from the randomised clinical trials. This pilot study will also help determine the recruitment and retention rates for a larger trial in this population.