Exploring How Exercise Frequency Impacts Muscle Resistance and Balance in Institutionalized Seniors: Protocol for a Randomized Controlled Trial

Ageing is a universal experience. However, the physical ageing process occurs differently across individuals. When individuals remain physically active throughout life, their levels of physical fitness tend to be higher compared to those with low or no engagement in physical activity. Nevertheless, the literature shows that the general population does not meet the international recommendation of 150 minutes of moderate-intensity physical activity per week, and that the proportion of physically inactive individuals is higher among the older population compared to adults or children.

Given this scenario, marked by a lack of physical activity and the gradual loss of muscle mass inherent to ageing, which is exacerbated by the absence of muscular and cardiovascular stimulation, there is an increased risk of adverse outcomes, such as falls. It is well documented in the literature that physically inactive ageing is more pronounced in older adults living in institutions compared to those who remain in the community. This may be because community-dwelling older adults typically engage in behaviors considered physically active, such as household chores, social and recreational activities outside the home, gardening, or do-it-yourself tasks that promote movement. Conversely, older adults in institutional care, who are typically institutionalized due to a lack of autonomy and independence, tend to experience an accelerated physical ageing process, given the general lack of opportunities for physical activity. In such settings, household chores are not typically performed, opportunities to leave the premises for social or recreational activities are limited, and access to gardening spaces is often unavailable. Thus, institutionalized older adults are more vulnerable to the effects of physical inactivity, which further increases dependency on others.

The literature consistently highlights the beneficial effects of physical activity on the quality of life of older adults, including those living in institutions. Reducing the risk of falling is essential, as such events may result in total dependence, such as becoming bedridden or reliant on a wheelchair, and often involve a longer and more demanding recovery, both physically and psychologically. Falls also incur various costs: individual (e.g., medication), public (e.g., medical treatments), and institutional (e.g., hiring additional staff). Furthermore, fear of engaging in physically active behaviors, such as walking, due to the potential risk of falling again, can further discourage movement. Understanding that physical activity can play a protective role, by reducing fall risk, increasing confidence in physical activity, and gradually promoting independence and autonomy, may yield benefits both for the individual and for all parties involved in the care of institutionalized older adults.

In terms of international recommendations, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) advise that individuals perform at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity physical activity per week, preferably 30 minutes per day. Additionally, strength training is recommended at least twice per week, at moderate intensity, involving 8-10 exercises and 10-15 repetitions per set. Flexibility and balance training are also advised twice per week, with each stretch lasting 15-30 seconds and repeated 2-4 times per muscle group, using static, dynamic, passive, or active exercises. However, despite being labelled as "recommendations," these guidelines present several practical limitations for the institutionalized older population. First, they imply approximately 60-90 minutes of regular physical activity per day, a significantly high volume for a population that is, by nature, physically inactive. Second, transitioning from inactivity to 60-90 minutes of daily exercise may be too abrupt, especially in the absence of appropriate adaptation and progression, and may increase the risk of adverse events associated with existing metabolic or cardiovascular conditions. Third, according to the ACSM, institutionalized older adults already present with at least one (or more) cardiovascular risk factor, requiring more cautious approaches than those applied to community-dwelling older adults or younger individuals. Lastly, not all institutions have access to resistance or cardio machines, free weights, transport to fitness facilities, or supervised professional guidance, which may limit the implementation of the strength training recommended by the WHO and ACSM.

Given this context, physical activity prescription for this population requires a tailored methodology suited to the institutional setting, namely, through multicomponent exercise programs. These programs integrate various components of physical fitness, including cardiovascular endurance, muscular strength, balance, agility, and flexibility. Sessions typically last 45-60 minutes and are conducted at light to moderate intensity, individualized based on each participant's subjective perception of effort, thereby allowing for self-regulation of intensity according to individual capabilities. According to the FITT framework, three of the four principles (Intensity, Type, and Time) are thereby addressed, with Frequency remaining as the variable to be further explored.