Increasing Medical and Nursing Students Searching of Current Best Evidence to Answer Clinical Questions

Not Applicable

Completed

• Conditions: Medical and Nursing Students' Evidence Retrieval Skills
• Interventions: Behavioral: Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder; Behavioral: Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach; Behavioral: Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback

• Registration Number: NCT02240095
• Lead Sponsor: McMaster University

Brief Summary

Translation of new knowledge from research into evidence-informed health care is a shared obligation of the clinical and the scientific communities. Unfortunately, studies of quality of care continue to show that this goal is substantially unrealized. One main barrier is lack of quick and easy identification, appraisal and synthesis of current best evidence. This start with medical and nursing students, which have numerous clinical-related questions daily, but face a large volume of 3000 articles published every day, accessible in many scattered resources.

To address theses problems, McMaster's Health Information Research Unit (Hamilton, Ontario, Canada) has developed and implemented "McMaster Premium LiteratUre Service Federated Search" (MPFS), an online search engine that provides a unique 1-stop search and organized access to current best evidence in daily practice. However additional barriers need to be overcome for students to actually search and use this evidence in their learning and practice. Theses include logistical barriers (time constraints, forgotten questions), as well as educational barriers (eg, lack of awareness of the "architecture" of evidence, limited searching skills, and lack of reference standards among peers for finding best evidence).

In a previous trial, the investigators tested 3 innovative online interventions among clinicians registered to MPFS to overcome these barriers and increase the quantity and quality of searching for current best evidence to answer clinical questions (NCT02038439). The investigators seek to conduct a second randomized trial testing the same 3 interventions, this time among medical and nursing students registered in MPFS.

Detailed Description

1. Rationale \& Objectives

One main barrier to achieving evidence-informed care by clinicians is lack of quick and easy identification, appraisal and synthesis of current best evidence. Clinicians and students information needs are considerable - but about 3000 articles are published in Medline every day. Numerous evidence-based resources have been developed to filter and process the evidence, but although increasingly used, each offer a fragmented and scattered view of information, and none provides comprehensive topic coverage or satisfactory updating.

To address theses problems, McMaster's Health Information Research Unit (Hamilton, Ontario, Canada) has developed and implemented "McMaster Premium LiteratUre Service Federated Search (MPFS)", an online search engine that provides a unique 1-stop search and organized access to current best evidence in daily practice. MPFS provides both alerts to users about new research, and a novel federated search function, with the particular feature of organizing information according to the "pyramid of evidence-based resources", with the most clinically applicable evidence at the top. Thus MPFS simultaneously retrieves evidence from Studies ("Medline", both filtered and unfiltered, at the bottom), then Systematic reviews; Synopses of studies and systematic reviews (selected for methodological rigor and clinical relevance), and, at the top level, online widely used Summaries (e.g."Best Practice").

Combining features of the current best evidence-based resources is not enough to increase access and use of current best evidence. Additional well-known barriers that need to be overcome include logistical barriers (time constraints, forgotten questions, and simplicity of using one single albeit limited resource), as well as educational barriers (eg, lack of awareness of the "architecture" of evidence and limits of other single resources, lack of knowledge and experience of what federated searches can offer, limited searching skills, and lack of reference standards among peers for finding best evidence).

2. Hypothesis

This trial seeks to test 3 innovative online interventions among medical and nursing students registered to MPFS to overcome these barriers and increase the quantity and quality of searching for current best evidence to answer the learning needs and clinical questions. These interventions build on effective models for the teaching of clinical skills at the point of care, so that they are facilitated in using the search engine as a clinical tool, and perceive evidence retrieval skills as true clinical skills.

3. Methods

1. Study design: Randomized Factorial Controlled Trial.

2. Setting and Participants: The trial will be conducted among medical and nursing students registered in MPFS and working in the teaching hospitals and clinics of McMaster University (see eligibility criteria below)

3. Participating clinicians will be randomized to 3 online interventions (see description below) in a factorial design (A x B x C), whose permutation results in 8 allocation arms (A+B+C, A+B, A+C, B+C, A, B, C, no intervention, see details below)

4. Randomization: will be computer-generated, and stratified for medical vs. nursing students. Registrants will be randomly allocated to each study arms. Allocation will be concealed from research staff.

5. Blinding and control group: Although participants cannot be blinded to the interventions, they will not be told of the different features offered, and all will receive usual searching features of MPFS.

Study Timeline

• Study Start: 2014-09
• Study First Submitted: 2014-09-11
• Study First Submitted QC: 2014-09-12
• Study First Posted: 2014-09-15
• Status Verified: 2017-10
• Primary Completion: 2017-10-22
• Study Completion: 2017-10-22
• Last Update Submitted: 2017-10-23
• Last Update Posted: 2017-10-25

Recruitment & Eligibility

• Status: COMPLETED
• Sex: All
• Target Recruitment: 960

Inclusion Criteria

• All medical and nursing students currently registered for more than one month in the MPFS search engine,
• And learning in the teaching hospitals and clinics of the Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario.

Read More

Exclusion Criteria

• Registrants that are no longer working or training at McMaster University,
• Registrants that never logged in MPFS during the last 12 months counting back from the beginning of the trial.

Read More

Study & Design

• Study Type: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Design: FACTORIAL

Arm && Interventions

Group	Intervention	Description
Interventions A + B	Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered the 2 following interventions combined: * Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder * Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach
Intervention B alone	Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered only the following intervention: \* Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach
Interventions A + B	Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered the 2 following interventions combined: * Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder * Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach
Interventions A + C	Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback	In this arm, students will be offered the 2 following online interventions combined: * Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder * Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Interventions B + C	Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered the 2 following online interventions combined: * Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach * Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Interventions: A + B + C	Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered all 3 online interventions combined: * Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder * Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach * Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Interventions A + C	Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder	In this arm, students will be offered the 2 following online interventions combined: * Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder * Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Interventions: A + B + C	Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered all 3 online interventions combined: * Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder * Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach * Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Interventions: A + B + C	Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered all 3 online interventions combined: * Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder * Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach * Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Intervention C alone	Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered only the following intervention: \* Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Interventions B + C	Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered the 2 following online interventions combined: * Intervention B - Online Evidence Retrieval Coach * Intervention C - Online Audit and Feedback
Intervention A alone	Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder	See Interventions Description. In this arm, students will be offered only the following intervention: \* Intervention A - Online Clinical Questions Recorder

Primary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Utilization of evidence-based resources on MPFS as measured by rate of searches/month/user	6 months	Each students participating in the trial has a personal online account in MPFS. When they are signed on their account, the system continuously tracks their searches and utilization of individual resources. We will record their utilization over the full duration of the trial (6 months) and analyze it in the end.

Secondary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Use (application of evidence in practice) as assessed by the Impact Assessment Measure questionnaire	6 months	This Impact Assessment Measure questionnaire will be sent to students after a random sample of searches and completed online for a random sample of searches.
Utility (satisfaction in meeting users' information needs) as assessed by the Impact Assessment Measure questionnaire	6 months	This Impact Assessment Measure questionnaire will be sent to students after a random sample of searches and completed online for a random sample of searches.
Perceived Usefulness in patient care and outcomes as assessed by the Impact Assessment Measure questionnaire	6 months	This Impact Assessment Measure questionnaire will be sent to students after a random sample of searches and completed online for a random sample of searches.

Trial Locations

Locations (1)

McMaster University; 🇨🇦 Hamilton, Ontario, Canada