Urodynamics for Prostate Surgery Trial; Randomised Evaluation of Assessment Methods
- Conditions
- Voiding DysfunctionLower Urinary Tract SymptomsBenign Prostate ObstructionDetrusor Underactivity
- Interventions
- Procedure: Usual careProcedure: Urodynamics
- Registration Number
- NCT02193451
- Lead Sponsor
- North Bristol NHS Trust
- Brief Summary
Background and study aims: The prostate gland sits around the exit of the bladder in men. As men get older, the prostate grows, and this can narrow the exit from the bladder, so that there is restriction of flow. As a result, some men develop difficulty passing urine (voiding) as they age. For these men, prostate surgery can be helpful by removing the part of the prostate causing the narrowing, so that flow improves. However, for some men, almost identical symptoms of difficulty passing urine are due to underactive bladder. In other words, the bladder contraction is too weak, and is not effective at expelling the urine. This is a smaller group, but important, as these men may have no improvement after prostate surgery, while being exposed to risk of complications of surgery. Medical assessment of men with voiding problems typically involves discussing the symptoms, doing a physical examination of the prostate and measuring the urine flow rate. In many NHS hospitals, these are the only tests done before deciding whether to proceed to prostate surgery. In effect, voiding symptoms are presumed to be a result of prostate enlargement for these men, since it is the more common problem compared with bladder underactivity. However, this approach cannot identify which men actually have bladder underactivity as the cause of their voiding symptoms. So, in some hospitals an extra test is used, called urodynamics. Urodynamics is done to measure how much pressure the bladder generates when passing urine, because a high pressure shows the problem is obstruction, and a low pressure shows it is bladder weakness. Urodynamics involves gently putting a small tube into the bladder via the penis to measure the bladder pressure, and to fill the bladder with a sterile fluid (saline). Another small tube is gently placed into the rectum, via the anus, to measure abdominal pressures. Measuring abdominal pressure is necessary because any change in abdominal pressure can affect bladder pressure, and if the test did not allow for this it could give a misleading result. Urodynamics is safe, but some men find it uncomfortable or undignified, and a few develop urine infection afterwards. No studies have been conducted so far to tell us which of these two approaches to assessing men with voiding urinary problems is better overall.
UPSTREAM consists of two phases: "UPSTREAM - Phase I" was a pragmatic, two-arm, multicentre, randomised controlled trial (RCT) to determine the clinical and cost-effectiveness of invasive urodynamics (UDS) for the diagnosis and management of bladder outlet obstruction in men. Men from 26 urology departments of NHS Hospitals in England who had bothersome lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) and were seeking further treatment, which may have included surgery, were randomised to one of two study arms; 'Routine Care' (as per the NICE diagnostic pathway), or routine care plus UDS ('Urodynamics'), which is currently optional. The design was utilised to establish noninferiority in symptom severity (International Prostate Symptom Score \[IPSS\]) 18-months post-randomisation. The primary outcome was IPSS at 18-months post-randomisation, and a key secondary outcome was the influence of UDS on rates of bladder outlet surgery. The RCT started 01 April 2014 and ended 30 September 2018.
In 2018, we were awarded an extension to conduct a further (long term) follow up of UPSTREAM participants, five years post-randomisation; "UPSTREAM - Phase II". We aim to identify: the symptom outcomes of treatment; definitive surgery rates in the two study arms; and the long-term impact of LUTS and its therapy. The focus will continue to be on effectiveness and patient outcomes as per the original commissioning brief. "UPSTREAM - Phase II" started 01 July 2019 and has a planned end date of 30 June 2022.
- Detailed Description
The aim of the UPSTREAM trial ("UPSTREAM - Phase I") was to determine whether a care pathway including invasive urodynamics is no worse for men in terms of symptom outcome than one in which it is not included, at 18 months after randomisation. We also aimed to establish whether inclusion of invasive urodynamics reduces rates of bladder outlet surgery as a main secondary outcome.
The following men were invited to participate (inclusion criterion); • Men seeking further treatment for their bothersome lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) which may include surgery
Men were not invited to participate (exclusion criteria) if they:
* were unable to pass urine without a catheter (urinary retention)
* had a relevant neurological disease, such as a stroke
* were undergoing treatment for prostate or bladder cancer
* had previously had prostate surgery
* were not medically fit for surgery, or were unable to complete outcome assessments
* did not consent to be assigned at random to one of the pathways
We compared the two methods of investigation by finding out whether the men had similar relief of their symptoms, by measuring the change in the prostate symptom score (IPSS) in the two groups at 18 months after randomisation (primary outcome).
We also looked at the following secondary outcomes:
* Whether the invasive tests changed the decision for surgery in some of the men (how many men had surgery in each of the two groups?)
* The cost-effectiveness of the two management pathways
* Adverse effects of (a) the tests and (b) the treatments (e.g. urinary infection, urinary retention)
* Urinary symptoms at 6, 12 \& 18 months, using the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaires (ICIQ) and the Male Lower Urinary Tract Symptoms questionnaire (ICIQ-MLUTS)
* Quality of life, using the IPSS-QoL question
* Sexual function, using the ICIQ-MLUTS sex questionnaire
* Satisfaction with urodynamic testing, using the ICIQ-UDS-S questionnaire
* The maximum urinary flow rate (Qmax) at 18 months
* Health outcomes, using the EQ-5D-5L questionnaire
For "UPSTREAM - Phase II". In this further follow up study ("UPSTREAM - Phase II"), we want to find out the longer term (5-year) results of treatment for the men's LUTS, and see how many men went on to receive surgery after the initial 18-months (i.e. after the original study, "UPSTREAM - Phase I").
We will approach existing participants of the UPSTREAM trial ("UPSTREAM - Phase I"). In taking part in "UPSTREAM - Phase II", men do not need to return to hospital for any clinical assessments. Instead we will ask them to complete one questionnaire booklet about their urinary symptoms, the effect on their everyday life, and their general state of health. We will also securely collect information relevant to this study from central NHS records (such as information about relevant inpatient stays and outpatient attendances).
Outcome measures will include:
LUTS will be measured with the widely-used patient reported outcome, the International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS), at five years post-randomisation.
• Measures from the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaires (ICIQ) will also be used, giving sensitive and comprehensive assessment of LUTS severity/ bother, sexual function and quality of life (QoL), i.e.: O IPSS QoL O ICIQ Male LUTS (ICIQ-MLUTS) O ICIQ sexual function in Male LUTS (ICIQ-MLUTS-sex)
* The EQ-5D-5L will be used to provide the QoL weights used to calculate Quality Adjusted Life Years (QALYs).
* Data for: Surgery rates (the relative proportion of men in each group having surgery up to five years post-randomisation); diagnostic testing after the main trial (where possible); and resource use will be obtained via a one-off bespoke data extraction of Health Episode Statistics (HES) and HES-Office of National Statistics (ONS) linked data, via NHS Digital. This will include individual level data about participants' relevant: inpatient stays; outpatient attendances: including procedures; radiology and accident and emergency (A\&E) episodes; and cause of death (where applicable).
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- UNKNOWN
- Sex
- Male
- Target Recruitment
- 820
- Men seeking further treatment for their bothersome lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) which may include surgery
- unable to pass urine without a catheter (urinary retention)
- relevant neurological disease, such as a stroke
- undergoing treatment for prostate or bladder cancer
- previously had prostate surgery
- not medically fit for surgery, or are unable to complete outcome assessments
- do not consent to be assigned at random to one of the pathways
"UPSTREAM - Phase II":
Inclusion criteria:
PROMS (questionnaire) study component:
Men randomised (enrolled) to the UPSTREAM trial (Phase I) who were willing to be contacted for long term follow up, as indicated on their original (Phase I) consent form.
NHS Digital data extraction study component:
Men randomised (enrolled) to the UPSTREAM trial (Phase I).
Exclusion criteria:
PROMS (questionnaire) study component:
- Patients who are not already randomised (enrolled) to the UPSTREAM trial (Phase I)
- UPSTREAM (Phase I) participants who:
2.1. are not willing to be contacted about long term follow up 2.2. have withdrawn trial participation, or at least withdrawn permission to be contacted in the future for long term follow up, at the time of their 18-month timepoint 2.3. do not consent and/or are not willing or able to comply with essential study procedures of this further follow up (UPSTREAM - Phase II)
NHS Digital data extraction study component:
- Patients who are not already randomised (enrolled) to the UPSTREAM trial (Phase I)
- UPSTREAM (Phase I) participants who have withdrawn permission for the study to continue to access sections of their medical notes and NHS records, ONS and NHS Central registers information, at the time of their 18-month timepoint
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Usual care Usual care Usual diagnostics in male LUTS; flow rate test, symptom score and bladder diary Urodynamics Urodynamics Invasive urodynamic cystometry including pressure flow studies, along with usual diagnostics in male LUTS Urodynamics Usual care Invasive urodynamic cystometry including pressure flow studies, along with usual diagnostics in male LUTS
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method International Prostate Symptom Score 18 months Primary clinical outcome: difference in lower urinary tract symptom (LUTS) between the two arms at 18 months, measured with the International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS)
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Surgery rate 5 years post randomisation ("UPSTREAM - Phase II") "UPSTREAM - Phase II": The relative proportion of men in each group having surgery up to 5 years after randomisation
International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaires 18 months Measures from the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaires (ICIQ) regarding LUTS severity/ bother, sexual function, quality of life and satisfaction with urodynamic testing. The following will be measured at 6, 12 and 18 months; IPSS (including quality of life) ICIQ Male LUTS (ICIQ-MLUTS) ICIQ sexual function in Male LUTS (ICIQ-MLUTS-sex)
Cost-effectiveness analyses 18 months Cost effectiveness from the perspectives of the Health Service, Personal Social Services and patients
Adverse events 18 months Adverse events of testing and treatment (e.g. infection, urinary retention).
Maximum urinary flow rate 18 months Maximum urinary flow rate (Qmax) at 18 months. In men undergoing surgery in both arms, an additional Qmax measure at 4 months after operation will be used as a quality measure for surgery.
EQ-5D-5L 5 years post randomisation ("UPSTREAM - Phase II") "UPSTREAM - Phase II": EQ-5D-5L consists of the EQ-5D descriptive system and the EQ visual analogue scale (EQ VAS). In the descriptive system, respondents rate their health 'TODAY' according to 5 dimensions (Mobility; Self-Care; Usual Activities; Pain/Discomfort; and Anxiety/Depression), with 5 levels of severity (No Problems; Slight; Moderate; Severe; and Extreme Problems). This results in a 1-digit number that expresses the level selected for that dimension. The digits for the five dimensions are combined into a 5-digit number that describes the patient's health state. The EQ VAS records the patient's self-rated health on a vertical visual analogue scale, where the endpoints are labelled 'The best health you can imagine' (100) and 'The worst health you can imagine' (0). The VAS can be used as a quantitative measure of health outcome reflecting the patient's own judgement. Full details of the scoring system can be found via the EQ-5D website/user guide.
International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) 5 years post randomisation ("UPSTREAM - Phase II") "UPSTREAM - Phase II": difference in lower urinary tract symptom (LUTS)
Measures from the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaires (ICIQ) regarding male lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) severity/ bother 5 years post randomisation ("UPSTREAM - Phase II") "UPSTREAM - Phase II": ICIQ Male LUTS (ICIQ-MLUTS); questionnaire evaluating MLUTS and impact on quality of life. 13 items, Scoring: 0-20 voiding symptoms subscale 0-24 incontinence symptoms subscale. Bother scales are not incorporated in the overall score but indicate impact of individual symptoms for the patient. See https://iciq.net for further information.
Measures from the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaires Measures from the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaires (ICIQ) regarding regarding sexual function 5 years post randomisation ("UPSTREAM - Phase II") "UPSTREAM - Phase II":ICIQ sexual function in Male LUTS (ICIQ-MLUTS-sex). Patient-complete questionnaire for evaluation of male sexual function associated with their MLUTS and impact of quality of life. 4 items, scoring: 0-12 overall score with greater values indicating increasing problems with sexual matters. Bother scales are not incorporated in the overall score but indicate impact of individual symptoms for the patient. See https://iciq.net for further information.
Quality of Life (QoL) 5 years post randomisation ("UPSTREAM - Phase II") "UPSTREAM - Phase II": International Prostate Symptom Score (IPSS) including QoL question. The IPSS is based on the answers to seven questions concerning urinary symptoms and one question concerning quality of life. Each question concerning urinary symptoms allows the patient to choose one out of six answers indicating increasing severity of the particular symptom. The answers are assigned points from 0 to 5. The total score can therefore range from 0 to 35 (asymptomatic to very symptomatic).
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
North Bristol NHS Trust
🇬🇧Bristol, United Kingdom