Electroconvulsive Therapy for Traumatic Memories: A Randomized Controlled Clinical Trial

Traumatic events contribute to the genesis of disorders such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and depression, and memories of the event can cause ongoing distress. Short-term episodic memories are encoded by the hippocampus and gradually become consolidated through reciprocal connections with the cortex, resulting in long-term memories being stored in a distributed network throughout the cerebral cortex. There are no effective treatments currently for specifically targeting traumatic memories and reducing the distress they cause.

ECT is the most effective treatment for improving mood in patients with depression and there is new evidence emerging that suggests ECT can also improve PTSD symptoms independently of co-morbid depression. In addition, the main side-effect of ECT is memory loss, specifically for autobiographical details surrounding the course of ECT, but not typically affecting long-term episodic memory, nor procedural memories. Memories stored in the hippocampus are vulnerable to disruption by ECT because they rely on synaptic changes that are mediated by relatively unstable modifications in AMPA receptor and metabotropic glutamate receptor density. The investigators propose to exploit this feature of ECT, which normally is considered an undesirable side-effect of treatment, in an attempt to selectively reduce traumatic memories and the distress associated with them.

The investigators propose to recruit patients referred for ECT for treatment-resistant depression, who also have traumatic memories that are causing distress. These patients will be asked to write two narratives, one of the traumatic memory, and the other of a trivial, non-traumatic remote event. Patients will then be asked to listen to an audio recording of either the traumatic memory or the neutral memory (control group) immediately before their ECT sessions. The severity of the traumatic memory related symptoms will be assessed before and after the course of ECT using the Modified PTSD Symptom Scale (MPSS-SR) and the Clinician Administered PTSD Scale for DSM-5 (CAPS-5). Data will be analyzed by comparing the change in overall MPSS-SR scores and CAPS-5 scores pre- and post-ECT between the experimental and control groups. Physiological data will also be collected at each ECT session during the time the participant is listening to the audio recordings. Heart rate and skin conductance will be measured prior to and during listening of the traumatic or non-traumatic memory, in order to determine if there is a change associated with a stress response, and whether this response normalizes in association with reduction of PTSD symptoms with treatment.