The Use of a Mock MRI Scanner for Reducing the Use of Anesthesia in Children Undergoing Clinical MRI Scans

Not Applicable

• Conditions: Magnetic Resonance Imaging
• Interventions: Behavioral: Preparation materials; Behavioral: Mock MRI scanner; Behavioral: Review Preparation Materials; Behavioral: Child Life Specialist preparation

• Registration Number: NCT02630342
• Lead Sponsor: University of Calgary

Brief Summary

Diagnostic Magnetic Resonance (MR) imaging procedures can be stressful for children and parents. Patients must lie still during the procedure to provide diagnostic quality images. Children \<7 years are often sedated or given general anesthesia (GA) for imaging procedures. The high cost of GA and its associated risks motivate the search for alternatives. The overall goal of this study is to systematically investigate whether training on the mock MR scanner reduces the need for GA during Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) scans in children.

160 participants scheduled for diagnostic MRI scans at Alberta Children's Hospital (ACH) will be recruited to undergo different training methods for MRI scanning. Group 1 will be sent links to online videos about MRI, audio files with scanner noises, and a children's book about MR scans, to prepare at home. Group 2 will receive training materials and visit the ACH to review them with the research team, but will not use the mock scanner. Group 3 will receive training materials and visit the ACH for training on the mock MR scanner. Visits to the mock scanner for Group 3 will include practice lying down, staying still, wearing headphones, and watching a movie on the mirror system. During and after training sessions, the investigators will collect data on total time spent preparing (mock scanner or other), the child's feelings of stress/worry before and after visit, and head motion during mock MRI session (if applicable).

Subjects will be scheduled for a clinical scan without GA and a follow-up clinical scan with GA (to be cancelled if the first scan is successful). Scan success will be determined by a radiologist. Measures of scan success, quality ratings for each scan, children's feelings of stress/worry related to the MRI, and saliva samples to measure cortisol and salivary alpha amylase, will be gathered at the clinical scan. An ANOVA will be used to compare different training groups.

A clinical group of 35 neuro-oncology patients aged 3-7 years of age that undergo frequent MRI scans will also undergo staged preparation by child life specialists using the mock scanner. The age at which they are able to complete MRI without general anesthesia will be compared with a retrospective control group in the 3 years prior. Measures to be used for this group are the same (with the exception of saliva samples). T test and Kaplan- Meier analysis will be used to compare age at which MRI can be performed awake.

Detailed Description

Diagnostic MR procedures can be scary and stressful for children and parents. Because patients must lie still during the procedure to provide diagnostic quality images, young children (typically \<7 years) and others not expected to comply are often sedated or given general anesthesia (GA) for imaging procedures. However, the high cost of GA and its associated risks motivate the search for alternatives. Previous reports demonstrate that preparation (including using a mock MR scanner) reduces anxiety and increases compliance for clinical and research MRI procedures without GA. However, systematic studies of the advantages of a mock MR scanner versus other training methods are lacking. Furthermore, while reducing the use of GA is desirable, repeated unsuccessful scanning procedures are also costly, so identifying factors that predict success for diagnostic MR procedures is important to effectively allocate resources.

Aims

The overall goal of this study is to systematically investigate whether training on the mock MR scanner reduces the need for GA during MRI scans in children. There are three specific aims:

1. Determine whether pre-scan training allows children to have successful diagnostic MRI scans without general anesthesia.

2. Examine the effects of different types of pre-scan training on reducing anxiety and stress in children and their parents related to diagnostic MRI.

3. Determine whether mock scanner training can lower the age at which neuro-oncology patients are able to complete a full diagnostic MRI without anesthesia compared with historic controls.

Patient name, date of birth, and hospital identification number are necessary to perform chart review and access diagnostic images. All identifying information will be removed prior to data analysis.

The following data will be collected/recorded for each participant at enrollment:

1. Study number

2. Sex

3. Age at time of scan(s)

4. Type of diagnostic scans requested

5. Parent report on overall stress

6. Parent proxy measures of child stress/worry (PedsQL)

7. Parent predictions of child success on MRI

8. (Aim 3 only) Primary Oncology Diagnosis: i) Site ii) Histology

9. (Aim 3 only) Treatment mode i) Surgery ii) Chemotherapy iii) Radiotherapy

Training Sessions

For Aims 1 and 2, participants will be randomly assigned to one of three training groups. Group 1 will be sent links to online videos about MRI, audio files with scanner noises, and a children's book about MR scans, to prepare at home. Group 2 will receive training materials and visit the ACH to review them with the research team, but will not use the mock scanner. Group 3 will receive training materials and visit the ACH for training on the mock MR scanner. Visits to the mock scanner for Group 3 will include practice lying down, staying still, wearing headphones, and watching a movie on the mirror system. The Child Life Specialist will talk with the child and his/her family about the experience, and allow them up to 1 hour of practice time on the mock scanner.

For Aim 3, all participants will receive training on the mock scanner similar to group 3 with the difference being Child Life Specialists will utilize a goal based preparation of 3 X 20 minute sessions to coincide with other visits to the hospital.

All participants will be booked for one MR scan without GA and one with GA a week later in case the first scan fails.

The following data will be collected during/after training sessions:

1. Total time spent preparing (mock scanner or other)

2. Child's feelings of stress/worry before and after visit (PedsQL)

3. Head motion during mock MRI session (if applicable)

Diagnostic MRI Sessions

The following information will be recorded for each child's MRI scan:

1. Date of MRI.

2. Child's age at time of scanning.

3. Scan success without anesthesia (pass/fail)

4. Number of sequences requiring repeating

5. Total scan length (mins)

6. Sum of individual scan sequence times (mins)

7. Quality of images, as determined by a pediatric neuro-radiologist and graded as Excellent (no motion artifact ), Good (minimal motion artifact ); Acceptable (motion artifact; but satisfactory to answer the clinical question); Unacceptable (significant motion artifact ; unable to answer the clinical question)

8. Parent proxy measures of child stress ( PedsQL )

9. Child's stress/worry (PedsQL)

10. (Aims 1 and 2) Saliva sample to measure cortical and salivary alpha amylase before and after diagnostic MR scan

If images are deemed suitable for clinical diagnosis, the subsequent GA booking will be cancelled.

No raw images will be retained for any patients outside of their hospital record.

For Aim 3 prospective data, the above information will be recorded at each scanning session until the patient is able to complete the entire scan without anesthesia.

For Aim 3 retrospective data: The patient's hospital identification number will be used to identify MRI scans performed on that patient in the 3 years prior to the study. The MRI report will be cross referenced with the department of anesthesia electronic database to determine the date and thereby the age at which MRI without GA was able to be performed. In the case where the MRI report states that scan was performed under GA but no electronic record of GA is present the paper chart will be reviewed to determine if GA was performed. If The MRI scan report does not specify that GA was performed and an anesthesia record for the MRI exists then scan will be considered to have been performed under GA.

Statistical Plan

An ANOVA will be used to evaluate group differences on scanning success measures. Additional analyses will focus on correlations between scan successes and age, sex, measures of child/parent stress, cortisone, salivary alpha amylase, and training session compliance.

Aim 3 will also explicitly test differences in the mean age in months at which neuro-oncology patients were able to successfully complete the diagnostic MRI without anesthesia in the groups with and without mock scanner training. These will be compared utilizing T-test and Kaplan-Meier Analysis.

Basic Information
|
Recruitment & Eligibility
|
Study & Design
|
Trial Locations

Study Timeline

• Study First Submitted: 2015-12-09
• Study First Submitted QC: 2015-12-14
• Study First Posted: 2015-12-15
• Study Start: 2016-01
• Status Verified: 2019-05
• Last Update Submitted: 2019-05-28
• Last Update Posted: 2019-05-30
• Primary Completion: 2019-09
• Study Completion: 2019-09

Recruitment & Eligibility

• Status: UNKNOWN
• Sex: All
• Target Recruitment: 160

Inclusion Criteria

• Elective MRI scans
• No previous Diagnostic MRI without GA
• Would normally receive GA for diagnostic MRI
• No significant developmental delay
• Ability to understand English for groups 1,2 and 3.
• For neuro-oncology group: Ability of accompanying parent and/or child to communicate in English with regular exposure of the child to the English language
• For Neuro-oncology subgroup:a diagnosis of primary brain tumor under the care of neuro-oncology at Alberta Children's Hospital

Read More

Exclusion Criteria

• Inability to understand consent form
• Urgent Scans (insufficient time to prepare)
• Previous diagnostic MRI without the need for general anesthesia
• Fast brain MRI (single sequence for sole purpose of determining size of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) spaces)

Read More

Study & Design

• Study Type: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Design: PARALLEL

Arm && Interventions

Group	Intervention	Description
Group 2: Materials with review	Preparation materials	This group will receive in preparation for a clinical MRI scan links to online videos about MRI, audio files with scanner noises, and a childrens book about MRI scan. Preparation for this group will occur at home and include a visit with research team to review preparation materials with the research team
Group 2: Materials with review	Review Preparation Materials	This group will receive in preparation for a clinical MRI scan links to online videos about MRI, audio files with scanner noises, and a childrens book about MRI scan. Preparation for this group will occur at home and include a visit with research team to review preparation materials with the research team
Group 1: preparation materials only	Preparation materials	This group will receive preparation materials for a clinical MRI scan. These include links to online videos about MRI, audio files with scanner noises, and a childrens book about MRI scan. Preparation for this group will occur only at home.
Group 3: Mock MRI scanner	Mock MRI scanner	This group will receive the same materials as training group 1. In addition they will attend the mock scanner where the research team will utilise a mock MRI scanner to practice lying down in a scanner, staying still , wearing headphones and watching a movie/video on the mirror system.
Neuro-oncology prospective	Mock MRI scanner	Child life specialist preparation will be provided to these patients. This preparation for Diagnostic MRI scanning in which utilise the Mock MRI scanner as preparation for the scan.
Neuro-oncology prospective	Child Life Specialist preparation	Child life specialist preparation will be provided to these patients. This preparation for Diagnostic MRI scanning in which utilise the Mock MRI scanner as preparation for the scan.
Group 3: Mock MRI scanner	Preparation materials	This group will receive the same materials as training group 1. In addition they will attend the mock scanner where the research team will utilise a mock MRI scanner to practice lying down in a scanner, staying still , wearing headphones and watching a movie/video on the mirror system.

Primary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Success of Diagnostic Scan	Immediate: on the date of scheduled MRI	Whether child is able to complete a diagnostic MRI scan without general anesthesia
Neuro-oncology Age of completion of MRI without GA	3 years	Determine the age at which neuro-oncology patients can complete a full diagnostic MRI without requiring general anesthesia

Secondary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Time taken to complete diagnostic MRI	Immediate: on the date of scheduled MRI	Time in minutes
Salivary stress hormone levels (cortisol & alpha amylase)	Immediate: on the date of scheduled MRI	Salivary stress hormones will be measured for training groups 1,2 and 3
Quality of scan Quality of MRI for diagnostic purposes	Immediate: on the date of scheduled MRI	Ability to use scan for diagnostic purpose
Childs feelings of stress	Immediate: on the date of scheduled MRI	Using Peds QL child version and parent proxy version to quantify stress
Compliance with training	2 weeks	recording the amount of time preparation took
Number of scan sequences that require repeating	Immediate: on the date of scheduled MRI	Number of scans sequences that need repeating

Trial Locations

Locations (1)

Alberta Children's Hospital; 🇨🇦 Calgary, Alberta, Canada