A Clinical Comparison of Three Contact Lens Care Systems and Their Effect on Contact Lenses

Not Applicable

Completed

• Conditions: Contact Lenses
• Interventions: Device: Opti-Free RepleniSH multi-purpose disinfecting solution; Device: ReNu MultiPlus multi-purpose solution; Device: Clear Care cleaning and disinfecting system; Device: Lotrafilcon B contact lens (AIR OPTIX AQUA); Device: Senofilcon A contact lens (ACUVUE OASYS); Device: Comfilcon A contact lens (Biofinity)

• Registration Number: NCT00982046
• Lead Sponsor: Alcon Research

Brief Summary

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical performance of three differing contact lens care solutions when used in conjunction with three contact lenses.

Detailed Description

This study was conducted as three separate studies based on the contact lens brand dispensed. In each study, the contact lens was evaluated in conjunction with three solutions: Opti-Free Replenish, ReNu MultiPlus, and Clear Care. The total enrollment number of 75 represents a combined enrollment of the three studies, with some subjects participating in more than one study.

Basic Information
|
Recruitment & Eligibility
|
Study & Design
|
Trial Locations

Study Timeline

• Study Start: 2009-04
• Study First Submitted: 2009-09-18
• Study First Submitted QC: 2009-09-21
• Study First Posted: 2009-09-22
• Primary Completion: 2010-05
• Study Completion: 2010-05
• Status Verified: 2012-07
• Last Update Submitted: 2016-11-15
• Last Update Posted: 2016-11-16

Recruitment & Eligibility

• Status: COMPLETED
• Sex: All
• Target Recruitment: 75

Inclusion Criteria

• Signed informed consent.
• Adapted contact lens wearer for at least one month.
• Spherical prescription range between +6.00 to -8.00 diopters.
• Astigmatism of less than or equal to 1.00 diopter in at least one eye.
• Normal eyes with no evidence of abnormality or disease.
• Other protocol-defined inclusion criteria may apply.

Read More

Exclusion Criteria

• Rigid Gas Permeable (RGP) contact lens wear in last 30 days.
• Concurrent ocular medication, systemic illness, or medical treatment that will affect ocular physiology, lens performance, or vision.
• Corneal infiltrates, scarring, or neovascularization within central 4 millimeters of cornea.
• Eye injury or surgery within 8 weeks prior to study.
• Aphakia, amblyopia, abnormal lacrimal secretions, ocular irritation, keratoconus, corneal irregularity, pregnancy, lactating, planning to become pregnant during the study, and participation in a concurrent clinical trial.
• Other protocol-defined exclusion criteria may apply.

Read More

Study & Design

• Study Type: INTERVENTIONAL
• Study Design: CROSSOVER

Arm && Interventions

Group	Intervention	Description
ACUVUE OASYS	Opti-Free RepleniSH multi-purpose disinfecting solution	Acuvue Oasys contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
ACUVUE OASYS	Clear Care cleaning and disinfecting system	Acuvue Oasys contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
AIR OPTIX AQUA	ReNu MultiPlus multi-purpose solution	Air Optix Aqua contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
AIR OPTIX AQUA	Opti-Free RepleniSH multi-purpose disinfecting solution	Air Optix Aqua contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
AIR OPTIX AQUA	Clear Care cleaning and disinfecting system	Air Optix Aqua contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
AIR OPTIX AQUA	Lotrafilcon B contact lens (AIR OPTIX AQUA)	Air Optix Aqua contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
Biofinity	ReNu MultiPlus multi-purpose solution	Biofinity contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
Biofinity	Clear Care cleaning and disinfecting system	Biofinity contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
ACUVUE OASYS	ReNu MultiPlus multi-purpose solution	Acuvue Oasys contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
ACUVUE OASYS	Senofilcon A contact lens (ACUVUE OASYS)	Acuvue Oasys contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
Biofinity	Opti-Free RepleniSH multi-purpose disinfecting solution	Biofinity contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.
Biofinity	Comfilcon A contact lens (Biofinity)	Biofinity contact lenses worn on a daily wear basis and cleaned nightly with one of three contact lens care solutions. Each solution was used for 2 weeks, and the order in which the solutions were used was randomized. A fresh pair of lenses was dispensed with each solution. Total duration of contact lens wear was six weeks.

Primary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
End of day comfort	2 weeks	As assessed by the subject as a measure of the comfort of the contact lenses at the end of an average day. End of day comfort is recorded on an 11-point scale where 0=poor and 10=excellent.
Bulbar hyperemia	2 weeks	Bulbar hyperemia is the injection (or redness) of the blood vessels in the tissues overlaying the white of the eye. Bulbar hyperemia is measured on a 0-4 scale, with 0=none, 1=trace, 2=mild, 3=moderate, and 4=severe. Half-grades are allowed.
Corneal staining type	2 weeks	An ophthalmic dye is used to highlight dead or degenerated corneal epithelial cells. The type of staining is measured over the five sectors of the cornea on a 0-4 scale, where 0=none, 1=micropunctate, 2=macropunctate, 3=coalesced macropunctate, and 4=patch (1mm). The five sectors are averaged to give a single score.
Upper palpebral roughness	2 weeks	The roughness of the inner lining of the upper eyelid is measured on a 0-4 scale, where 0=uniform appearance, 1=trace, 2=mild, 3=moderate, and 4=severe. Half grades are allowed.
High contrast visual acuity	2 weeks	High contrast visual acuity is a measure of the clearness of vision with full room illumination. Visual acuity is measured with a computer-generated, high contrast logMAR (logarithm minimum angle of resolution) chart.
Modulus	2 weeks	Modulus is a measure of the stiffness of a contact lens material. Modulus is determined from the slope of the stress-strain curve created during tensile tests conducted on a sample of the material. Modulus is measured in mega Pascals (MPa). A higher modulus indicates a stiffer contact lens.

Trial Locations

Locations (1)

Visioncare Research Ltd.; 🇬🇧 Farnham, Surrey, United Kingdom