Can BCG Vaccination at First Health-facility Contact Reduce Early Infant Mortality?
- Conditions
- Infant MortalityBCG
- Interventions
- Registration Number
- NCT04658680
- Lead Sponsor
- Bandim Health Project
- Brief Summary
Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccination is recommended at birth to protect against tuberculosis (TB) in countries with high TB burden. BCG is supplied in multidose vials with limited durability after reconstitution. In Guinea-Bissau, this has led to a practice of only opening a BCG vial at specific days, and only if sufficient children are present. Therefore, BCG vaccination is frequently delayed. Accumulating evidence indicates that BCG has beneficial effects on survival beyond the specific protection against tuberculosis, so called non-specific effects (NSEs).
The hypothesis of this study is that increasing the availability of BCG and vaccinating children at the first health-facility contact can reduce early infant non-accidental mortality by 25%.
In a cluster-randomised crossover trial, 23 health facilities (HFs) in three rural regions in Guinea-Bissau will be randomised to either continue with current practice (typically BCG vaccination once a week if a sufficient number of children are present for vaccination); or to offer additional BCG vaccines to make BCG available every day and open a vial of BCG if there is just one eligible child present. All children born in the three regions and registered during the study period, will be eligible for inclusion into the trial 1 day after birth. If consent is given by the mother, the child will be followed until day 42 after birth, when other vaccines are scheduled to be given. The primary outcome will be non-accidental mortality, secondary outcomes are non-accidental hospital admissions, non-accidental neonatal mortality and cost-effectiveness of making BCG available at the first health-facility contact.
- Detailed Description
Background:
The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends Bacillus Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccination at birth to protect against TB in countries with high TB burden. Though the BCG vaccine is scheduled at birth, the vaccine is often given with delay, also among children born in Health Facilities (HFs), where it should be possible to obtain the vaccine. In 2010 in rural Guinea-Bissau, only 38% of children received BCG within the first month of life. BCG is supplied in 20-dose vials and unused doses must be discarded 6 hours after reconstitution. This has led to a local practice of not opening a BCG vial unless sufficient eligible children are present for vaccination. Moreover, the HFs seek to assemble larger groups of children eligible for BCG at specific days. Our observations from the field indicate that even on these days, vials may not be opened if the number of children is too low. Similar practises have been demonstrated in other low-income countries, but this practice is not in line with WHO recommendations, which emphasise that multi-dose vials should be opened and used to vaccinate one child despite any wastage.
In 2012, an estimated 73% of all neonatal deaths occurred within the first week of life. Several studies have suggested that BCG vaccination is associated with survival benefits early in life: In three randomised trials from Guinea-Bissau, BCG-at-birth was associated with a 38% lower neonatal mortality and marked reductions already 3 days after vaccination. A WHO-commissioned review and meta-analysis conducted in 2014 including five clinical trials indicated that BCG-vaccinated children had a relative risk of mortality at 0.70 (95% confidence interval 0.49-1.01) compared with BCG-unvaccinated children. Two randomised trials from India, both published after the review was conducted, found no effect of BCG at birth on neonatal mortality. In both India and Guinea-Bissau, all trials were conducted among low birth weight (LBW) children and primary outcome was neonatal mortality. In Guinea-Bissau, BCG-Denmark was used in all trials, whereas BCG-Russia was used in the trials from India. Strain of BCG has been suggested as a possible reason for the discrepancy between the trials in India, and the trials in Guinea-Bissau.
Therefore, early BCG vaccination may be important, not only for protection against tuberculosis, but also for the impact on survival.
Hypothesis:
Increasing the availability of BCG and vaccinating children at the first health-facility contact can reduce early infant mortality due to other causes than accidents by 25%.
Methods:
This study will be a cluster randomized trial of increased BCG availability at the 23 HFs in three rural regions (Oio, Biombo and Farim) in Guinea-Bissau. In half of the HFs, BCG will be provided as per current practice (typically once a week if a sufficient number of children are present for vaccination); in the remaining HFs, additional BCG vaccines will be supplied to make BCG available every day and opening a vial of BCG if there is just one eligible child present. In collaboration with the national vaccination programme, the investigators will ensure that the same strain of WHO-prequalified BCG vaccines will be used at the same time in both the control and intervention arm of the study. The allocation of centres will be crossed over after 12 months and inclusion of participants will carry on for another 12 months. Pregnancies, births and deaths will be monitored through two different levels of surveillance:
Level 1 - Bandim Health Project's (BHPs) rural Health and Demographic Surveillance System (HDSS). The BHP teams survey women of fertile age and children below the age of 5 years in randomly selected village clusters in all health regions across the country, which involves 40 village clusters distributed across the three regions included in this study. Through this system, it is possible to monitor pregnancies, births, vaccinations and child health.
Level 2 - Reinforced community health worker monitoring. In all villages in Guinea-Bissau, community health workers (CHWs) monitor births and deaths through a national monitoring system. The CHWs report aggregated data on pregnancies, number of births and neonatal deaths (in two categories: 0-7 days, 8-28 days) in their capture area to the local health centre at monthly meetings. This data collection will be reinforced by supervision and further data collection from BHP supervisors covering each health centre area. The CHWs will receive a visit every 1-2 months from a supervisor.
All children registered during pregnancy in Oio, Biombo or Farim enter the trial cohort 1 day after birth. A pregnancy can be registered in more than one village, but the child will only enter the trial if the mother gave birth in the village or the nearby health facility, and then was discharged to the village where the pregnancy was registered.
For all registered deaths, a specially trained field worker will visit the household of the deceased child to conduct a verbal autopsy.
Prior to study start, all 23 HFs in the three regions will be visited by a team from BHP. During these visits, refresher training on vaccination technique and assessment of lymph glands will be conducted. The training will include general information on the BCG vaccine, information on reconstitution and durability of the vaccines, how to check that the vials have not been damaged by heat and information on adverse events. During the trial, the HFs will be visited regularly by a nurse from BHP, who will observe and supervise the vaccination sessions for vaccination technique, attention to registration of adverse event, used strain of vaccinations, registration of cold chain and state of vaccine stock.
Statistical analyses:
The primary outcome will be non-accidental mortality rate between 1 day after birth and 42 days after birth, where other vaccines are scheduled to be given. 22,800 infants are expected to be included in the study during the two-year study period. With a baseline mortality of 2.5% (varying between 1.5 and 3.5% by HF) this sample size should result in 88% power to demonstrate an effect if the true mortality reduction is assumed to be 25% (power simulations based on a logistic regression with Generalised Estimating Equation (GEE)-based correction for village cluster). Secondary outcomes are non-accidental hospital admissions, non-accidental neonatal mortality and cost-effectiveness of making BCG available at the first health-facility contact. The effect of making BCG available at the first HF contact will be analysed in logistic regression models with GEE-based correction for village cluster.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- RECRUITING
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 22800
- All children registered during pregnancy in Oio, Biombo or Farim by CHWs or the BHP HDSS
- Children, who have died within 1 day after birth
- Children born outside Oio, Biombo and Farim health regions
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description BCG available at first health facility contact BCG vaccination at first health facility contact Infants living in catchment areas of HFs randomized to opening of BCG vial if just 1 eligible child is present.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Odds ratio of non-accidental early infant mortality From 1 day after birth to 42 days after birth The primary analysis of early infant non-accidental mortality will be assessed in an intention-to-treat (TT) analysis. Logistic regression models with generalised estimating equation (GEE) correction for village cluster will be used.
Furthermore, an assessment of whether the effect of the intervention on the primary outcome is modified by the following potential effect modifiers, will be carried out: Sex, maternal BCG scar (yes/no), season of birth (dry/rainy), strain of BCG.
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Odds ratio of severe morbidity From 1 day after birth to 42 days after birth Non-accidental hospital admissions (defined as overnight hospitalisations or arrival at the hospital and death within the first day) defined by the following potential effect modifiers: sex, maternal BCG scar (yes/no), season of birth (dry/rainy), strain of BCG.
Odds ratio of non-accidental neonatal mortality From 1 day after birth to 28 days after birth Assessment of the effect of BCG availability on the village cluster level non-accidental neonatal mortality based on CHW registration.
Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio per death averted by making BCG available at the first health facility contact From 1 day after birth to 42 days after birth A cost-effectiveness analysis estimating the incremental costs per death averted by making BCG available at the first health facility contact will be undertaken. Incremental costs will be assessed by contrasting the costs of BCG vaccine provision in the present programme and in a scenario with BCG available at the first health-facility contact as tested in the trial. The costs/savings associated with different rates of consultations and admissions will also be taken into account. This analysis will only be carried out, if the analysis of the primary outcome shows that increasing availability of BCG reduces early infant mortality.
Trial Locations
- Locations (1)
Bandim Health Project
🇬🇼Bissau, Guinea-Bissau