Behavioral Activation and Voucher-based Contingency Management for Smokers With Depression
Trial Snapshot
- Phase
- Not Applicable
- Status
- Completed
- Sponsor
- University of Oviedo
- Enrollment
- 180
- Locations
- 2
- Primary Endpoint
- smoking abstinence
Study Overview
Brief Summary
The present research project aims to develop an innovative and empirically validated intervention protocol for smoking cessation among patients with depressive symptoms. For this purpose, two smoking cessation treatments tailored for managing depression will be compared with a standard smoking cessation treatment. Participants will be assigned to one of the following three treatment conditions: 1) Cognitive-behavioral treatment for smoking cessation (CBT); 2) CBT plus Behavioral Activation (BA); 3) CBT+BA+ Contingency Management (CM).
The main goals are:
-
To assess abstinence rates in each of the above-mentioned treatment conditions conditions at short and long-term follow-ups: post-treatment, once during the first three months, and at at six after post-treatment.
-
To assess the effectiveness (relapse rate) of each treatment condition at short and long-term follow-ups: post-treatment, once during the first three months,and at six after post-treatment.
-
To analyze efficiency (cost-efficacy) and feasibility of the treatments to a community setting.
-
To analyze the moderating effect of individual variables over treatment outcomes. In particular, moderating variables will be: sociodemographic characteristics, severity of nicotine dependence, severity of depressive symptomatology and impulsivity.
The study hypothesis are:
1-Adding a voucher-based CM component to CBT+BA will enhance abstinence rates and decrease both short and long-term relapse rates.
-
Providing smoking cessation treatments that include a mood management component (BA or BA+CM) will have a positive impact in ameliorating depression.
-
Certain individual variables (e.g., gender, nicotine dependence and depression severity and impulsivity) will have a moderating effect on treatment outcomes.
-
Both CBT+BA and CBT+BA+CM will prove cost-effectiveness and thus may be generalized to a clinical and community context.
Detailed Description
Cigarette smoking continues to have a startling adverse impact on public health, leading to more than 5 million premature deaths annually worldwide. Smoking rates are disproportionately high among the population suffering from depression. In this regard, smokers with comorbid depression are more likely to smoke heavily and meet criteria for high nicotine dependence. It is also more probable that they experience negative mood changes after withdrawal and show shorter time to relapse and lower rates of abstinence when attempting to quit compared to non-depressed smokers. In recent years there has been a great interest in developing effective strategies to promote abstinence in smokers with depression. In particular, a proliferation on Behavioral Activation (BA) treatments for smokers with depression has been recently produced. There is promising evidence for the positive effect of BA treatments upon both quitting smoking and depression. On the other hand, Contingency Management (CM) has shown promising results in promoting both retention and nicotine abstinence among comorbid and non-comorbid smokers. Nevertheless, there is a lack of research exploring the effectiveness of CM on smokers with depression.
The primary aim of this clinical trial is to yield data on the effectiveness of BA and CM for smoking cessation in smokers with depression. To address this issue, both BA and CM interventions will be compared with a standard smoking cessation treatment, namely Cognitive-behavioral treatment (CBT) for smoking cessation. Participants will be assigned to one of the following three treatment conditions: 1) Cognitive-behavioral treatment for smoking cessation (CBT); 2) CBT plus Behavioral Activation (BA); 3) CBT+BA+Contingency Management (CM).
Regarding the factors contributing to improve the quality of the present clinical trial, sample size was estimated using the software G*Power 3.1. An estimated sample size of 150 participants would detect a medium effect size (Cohen's d = 0.3, with power (1-β) set at 0.97 and α = 05).
Given that data will be collected up to six months after post-treatment, moderate rates of lost to follow-up can be expected. However, the sample size estimate in this study will be sufficient to ensure a representative distribution of the population to whom results will be generalized.
The primary analyses derived from this clinical trial will be conducted using Statistical Package for the Social Science (SPSS) version 22 for Windows. A set of descriptive and frequency analyses will be carried out with regard to the participants' characteristics. Comparisons between the treatment groups for baseline characteristics will be conducted using t-tests for independent groups. A set of chi-square tests for categorical variables, and independent samples t-tests (two-tailed) for continuous variables (after Levene's correction for inequality of variance) will be performed to examine the main effect of each treatment condition on abstinence and relapse rates.
Study Design
- Study Type
- Interventional
- Allocation
- Randomized
- Intervention Model
- Parallel
- Primary Purpose
- Treatment
- Masking
- None
Eligibility Criteria
- Ages
- 18 Years to — (Adult, Older Adult)
- Sex
- All
- Accepts Healthy Volunteers
- No
Inclusion Criteria
- •being age 18 or over
- •having smoked 10 or more cigarettes/day within the last year
- •meeting criteria for current unipolar major depression disorder according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-4th ed., text rev (DSM-IV-TR) (American Psychiatric Association 2000).
- •, and/or scoring ≥ 14 on the Beck Depression Inventory (Beck, Steer, & Brown, 1996)
- •meeting the diagnostic criteria for nicotine dependence according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-4th ed., text rev (DSM-IV-TR) (American Psychiatric Association 2000).
Exclusion Criteria
- •not being able to attend the entire treatment,
- •suffering from severe mental disorders others than depression such as cognitive impairment, a psychotic disorder or bipolar disorder.
- •being currently receiving other psychological treatment for smoking cessation or depression.
- •meeting criteria for abuse and/or dependence on a substance other than nicotine.
Arms & Interventions
Cognitive-behavioral treatment (CBT)
The CBT treatment condition is implemented in group-based sessions carried out during 8 weeks. Components included: information about tobacco, behavioral contract whereby patients committed to attend sessions, self-monitoring and graphical representation of cigarette smoking, nicotine fading (a weekly reduction of 30% of nicotine intake from the first to the four week, and abstinence from the fifth week onwards), physiological feedback (CO in expired air and cotinine analyses) on cigarette intake, stimulus control, strategies for managing nicotine withdrawal symptoms, training in alternative behaviors, and relapse prevention strategies (e.g., problem solving techniques).
Intervention: Cognitive-behavioral treatment (CBT) (Behavioral)
CBT+Behavioral Activation (BA)
This intervention includes both CBT and BA strategies for smoking cessation and depression management. Participants allocated to this condition received 8 therapy sessions. The BA module included: treatment rationale, information on the relationship between smoking and depression, identification of life areas, values and activities, generation of meaningful and reinforcing activities, social support (i.e., behavioral contracts).
Intervention: Cognitive-behavioral treatment (CBT) (Behavioral)
CBT+Behavioral Activation (BA)
This intervention includes both CBT and BA strategies for smoking cessation and depression management. Participants allocated to this condition received 8 therapy sessions. The BA module included: treatment rationale, information on the relationship between smoking and depression, identification of life areas, values and activities, generation of meaningful and reinforcing activities, social support (i.e., behavioral contracts).
Intervention: CBT+Behavioral Activation (BA) (Behavioral)
CBT+BA+ Contingency Management (CM)
This intervention is provided in the same manner as the above treatment protocols but with the addition of a CM procedure reinforcing abstinence since fifth session and onwards. The number of sessions was the same as in the aforementioned treatment conditions and CO and cotinine samples were also collected. Participants providing negative specimens of both CO (≤4 ppm) and cotinine (≤80 ng/ml) earned points exchangeable for rewards (e.g., cinema tickets) on a schedule of escalating magnitude of reinforcement (from 10€ voucher value with maximum possible earnings of 175€ in vouchers).
Intervention: Cognitive-behavioral treatment (CBT) (Behavioral)
CBT+BA+ Contingency Management (CM)
This intervention is provided in the same manner as the above treatment protocols but with the addition of a CM procedure reinforcing abstinence since fifth session and onwards. The number of sessions was the same as in the aforementioned treatment conditions and CO and cotinine samples were also collected. Participants providing negative specimens of both CO (≤4 ppm) and cotinine (≤80 ng/ml) earned points exchangeable for rewards (e.g., cinema tickets) on a schedule of escalating magnitude of reinforcement (from 10€ voucher value with maximum possible earnings of 175€ in vouchers).
Intervention: CBT+Behavioral Activation (BA) (Behavioral)
CBT+BA+ Contingency Management (CM)
This intervention is provided in the same manner as the above treatment protocols but with the addition of a CM procedure reinforcing abstinence since fifth session and onwards. The number of sessions was the same as in the aforementioned treatment conditions and CO and cotinine samples were also collected. Participants providing negative specimens of both CO (≤4 ppm) and cotinine (≤80 ng/ml) earned points exchangeable for rewards (e.g., cinema tickets) on a schedule of escalating magnitude of reinforcement (from 10€ voucher value with maximum possible earnings of 175€ in vouchers).
Intervention: CBT+BA+ Contingency Management (CM) (Behavioral)
Outcomes
Primary Outcomes
smoking abstinence
Time Frame: 6 months follow-up
Abstinence is considered when participants met the following criterion: 7-day point prevalence abstinence. Abstinence is confirmed by asking participants to provide a sample of carbon monoxide (CO) and cotinine urine.
Secondary Outcomes
- anxiety(intake (baseline), end of treatment (8-week),1,2,3 and 6 months follow-up)
- impulsivity(intake (baseline), end of treatment (8-week),1,2,3 and 6 months follow-up)
- depression(intake (baseline), end of treatment (8-week),1,2,3 and 6 months follow-up)
- behavioral activation(intake (baseline), end of treatment (8-week),1,2,3 and 6 months follow-up)
- environmental reward(intake (baseline), end of treatment (8-week),1,2,3 and 6 months follow-up)
- cigarette craving(intake (baseline), end of treatment (8-week),1,2,3 and 6 months follow-up)
Investigators
Roberto Secades
Professor/PhD
University of Oviedo