Intranasal Cooling for Symptomatic Relief of Migraine
- Conditions
- Migraine Headache
- Interventions
- Device: Active RhinoChillDevice: Placebo RhinoChill
- Registration Number
- NCT02375789
- Lead Sponsor
- Cumbria Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
- Brief Summary
This study will be a randomised placebo controlled trial examining the effectiveness of using an intranasal cooling device (the RhinoChill) in providing relief of pain and symptoms of acute migraine. It will involve using two nasal catheters to cool the nasal cavity which provides localised cooling of the local nasal tissue and the blood vessels which supply blood to the brain. This cooling effect will cause the blood vessels to constrict as well as stimulating special cold receptors that are thought to be involved in the relief of migraine, thereby providing both pain and associated symptomatic relief. Ninety patients will be randomised in a 1:1 fashion, clustered to three different recruitment sites. The patients will have a 30 day period of data collection for their current migraine frequency, treatment and response to medication (with a minimum of 2 migraine attacks recorded) before starting the treatment phase with the RhinoChill Device. Treatment will be for 2 migraine attacks. Only a single treatment is allowed for the first attack, but on the second attack the patient may deliver 2 treatments with a gap of at least 2 hours between treatments.
- Detailed Description
This study is a multi centre, double blinded, randomized, prospective, parallel placebo controlled trial for demonstrating the effectiveness of the RhinoChill System for the symptomatic relief of migraine headache.
The specific study design consists of:
* Participant identification from neurology clinic records and gaining initial consent to transfer contact details to the trial team.
* Telephone contact or direct clinic contact with potential participants to describe the COOLHEAD 2 trial and to seek expressions of interest.
* Initial meetings with potential participants and discussion of trial, provision of patient information leaflets. Informed Consent taking.
* Initial 30 day prospective data collection period (minimum of 2 migraine attacks, longer period if needed)
* Randomisation to either placebo or active RhinoChill
* Device Delivery and training session for the use of the RhinoChill device, self administration, and record keeping.
* Treatment period for the treatment of 2 separate migraines with the RhinoChill.
During an initial screening visit or phonecall, the trial will be discussed with the potential participant and the inclusion/exclusion checklist will be completed.
If the patient meets all inclusion criteria and none of the exclusion criteria, they will be asked for permission to pass on contact details to a member of the trial team for further contact.
Arrangements will then be made for a meeting with the patient either at the clinic or in their own home to further discuss the trial and to consider enrolling into the study. At this time, they will be provided with a patient information sheet and will be shown the RhinoChill device. The patient will be given the opportunity to fully consider all aspects of participation in this trial and to discuss it with family members if they so wish before being being consented into the trial by a member of the study team.
At the time of consent, the researcher will also collect data for the baseline CRF and provide initial instruction on completion of the first stage data collection forms (further described below)
At the baseline visit, the patient will first be given the opportunity to ask any questions they may have about the research. A member of the research team will take informed consent and gain signatures on the consent form. Baseline data will then be collected, including history of migraine headache, frequency, severity of symptoms, medication and therapies currently ongoing or taken in the past. Base line vital signs will also be recorded at this time. Once completed, a short training session on completion of the prospective data collection forms for phase 1 of the trial will given and use of the supplied blood pressure machine and pulse oxymeter machine. Once the baseline visit has been completed the patient will begin a 30 day period of self data collection based on their migraine experience during that time frame and using data capture forms provided by the research nurse (a minimum of 2 migraine attacks are required, therefore if 2 have not occurred during the 30 days, further time will be given to allow the second migraine to occur).
If a patient has not had a single migraine in the first 30 days, then they will not be able to continue to the treatment phase as they have not met the inclusion criteria of at least 1 migraine per month. Following the conclusion to this initial period, the treatment phase will then begin.
After the end of the prospective data collection period, the patient will be randomised to either active treatment or placebo treatment. Randomisation will be provided by sealed envelopes held by E\&E CRO services (Vienna) who are also acting as independent monitors of the trial. Randomisation was performed via the online system www.sealedenvelope.com.
Training will be undertaken to ensure that the patient is fully competent and safe in the use of the RhinoChill intranasal cooling device.
The patient will be instructed on:
* Preparation of the device
* Insertion of the nasal catheter
* Selecting correct flow rate
* Positioning during treatment
* Cleaning and storage of the nasal catheters
* Trial documentation
* 24 hour contact numbers for additional supplies, troubleshooting and practical support.
The patient will also be left with a reference booklet for issues around the trial and the practical use of the RhinoChill device.
At the onset of migraine headache (or as soon as possible thereafter), the patient will start to complete the 'Treatment' CRF.
Each step of the treatment procedure is to be completed in order and as described to the patient. Patients are instructed that there is no scope for any alteration in the treatment order or requirements of the trial unless a safety issue becomes evident. If a patient does deviate from the standard procedures as outlined below, they are required to contact the 24 hour COOLHEAD 2 mobile phone to report the incident so that it can be reviewed and logged as a protocol deviation and reviewed by the site/principal investigator at the earliest opportunity. The RhinoChill device is then prepared for use and treatment can be administered.
The RhinoChill Migraine Intranasal catheters are then inserted and the 10 minute treatment is commenced on Low Flow. following these steps for each individual treatment:
It is recognised that participants in this study will already be taking medication for their migraine headache. Normal prophylaxis will be allowed as part of the trial and will be recorded in the initial screening interview. No change in prophylaxis is allowed within three months of the start of the trial or while the patient is participating in the trial.
However, acute treatments such as triptans are allowed to be taken but must be withheld until at least two hours following completion of treatment with the RhinoChill to allow assessment of the intervention. Any rescue medication taken after this point will be recorded in the associated trial documentation. A full medication history along with other therapies (including alternative therapies) will also be recorded.
No new treatment or therapy will start while the participant is enrolled in this trial.
Recruitment & Eligibility
- Status
- TERMINATED
- Sex
- All
- Target Recruitment
- 27
- 18 Years or over and ≤70 years of age.
- Migraine diagnosis of at least 1 year.
- Migraine attacks between 1 and 15 per month.
- Onset of first migraine < 50 years of age.
- Migraine prophylaxis medication unchanged for 3 months prior to enrollment
- Meets International Classification for Headache Disorders (2nd Edition) criteria for diagnosis of Episodic Migraine with or without aura
- Able to attend and understand a short training session on the practical use of the RhinoChill device and agrees to only use the device as instructed and as laid out in the official instructions for use.
- < 18 and >70 years of age
- Known oxygen dependency to maintain SaO2 >95%
- Diagnosed Hypertensive and currently uncontrolled with Systolic BP > 140mmHg and Diastolic BP > 90mmHg on baseline assessment.
- Marked nasal septal deviation, recurrent epistaxis or chronic Rhino-Sinusitis
- Intranasal obstruction preventing full insertion of nasal catheter
- Known acute base of skull fracture or facial trauma
- Concurrent sinus/intranasal surgery
- Diagnosed with thromobocytopenia.
- Previous Stroke or Myocardial Infarction
- Unable to fully understand the consent process and provide informed consent due to either language barriers or mental capacity
- Previously enrolled into the COOLHEAD 1 trial
- No recorded migraine following initial 30 day data collection period
Study & Design
- Study Type
- INTERVENTIONAL
- Study Design
- PARALLEL
- Arm && Interventions
Group Intervention Description Active RhinoChill Active RhinoChill Following the initial 30 days (and minimum of 2 separate migraine attacks) of data collection the patient will be trained in the use and self administration of the RhinoChill device. At the onset of an acute migraine, the patient will insert the RhinoChill Migraine Intranasal catheters and commence a 10 minute treatment on the Low Flow setting of the device. During this time the patient will complete the basic data record sheets to document current symptoms and changes in severity throughout the period of treatment and then at specific time points thereafter. The patient remains in the trial until two separate migraines have been treated. Placebo RhinoChill Placebo RhinoChill The same procedure will be followed for the placebo comparator as in the active comparator. The RhinoChill device looks identical and functions in a very similar way to the active device however through some minor design changes the device has been altered to provide a sufficient placebo treatment. At the onset of an acute migraine headache the patient will insert the RhinoChill Migraine Intranasal catheters and the 10 minute treatment is commenced on Low Flow. During this time the patient will complete the basic data record sheets to document current symptoms and changes in severity throughout the period of treatment and then at specific time points thereafter. The patient remains in the trial until two separate migraines have been treated.
- Primary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Pain free at two hours following treatment Two hours following treatment Percentage of patients who are pain free two hours following treatment
- Secondary Outcome Measures
Name Time Method Headache response 10 mins, 1 hour, 24 hours Headache response - Improvement of pain from Severe/Moderate to mild/none immediately following treatment and at one hour and 24 hours following treatment.
Relapse Incidence Between 2 and 48 hours after the intervention Relapse Incidence - Frequency of headache return between 2 and 48 hours after the intervention
Percentage of patients pain free 10 mins, 1 hour, 2 hours, 24 hours Percentage of patients scoring a pain intensity score of None
Pain response 10 mins, 1 hour, 2 hours, 24 hours Change in pain score (Visual Analogue Score of 0-10) immediately following treatment and at one hour, 2 hours and 24 hours following treatment.
Total Migraine Freedom Between 1 and 24 hours after the intervention Absence of pain, nausea, photophobia and phonophobia at 2 hours
Percentage of patients taking rescue medication at 2 hours after treatment 2 hours after treatment Percentage of patients taking rescue medication at 2 hours after treatment
Global Impression of Change to be completed at the end of trial period, an average of 8-10 weeks Global Impression of Change
Global impact on quality of life to be completed at the end of trial period, an average of 12 weeks Global impact on quality of life Global impact on disability and Quality of life
Sustained Pain Freedom Between 1 and 24 hours after the intervention Pain free at 2 hours with no use of rescue medication or relapse within the subsequent 46 hours
Change in Headache Intensity during treatment. 5 mins and 10 mins Change in Headache Intensity during treatment.
Change in Headache Intensity 2 hours following treatment 2 hours following treatment. Change in Headache Intensity 2 hours following treatment
Time to meaningful relief Between 10 mins and 24 hours after the intervention Time to meaningful relief. Time to meaningful relief Time to freedom from pain
Migraine pain scores, pre intervention data collection period versus treatment with the intervention. to be completed at the end of trial period, an average of 12 weeks Migraine pain score, pre intervention data collection period versus treatment with the intervention.
Time to freedom from pain Between 10 mins and 24 hours after the intervention Time to freedom from pain Time to meaningful relief Time to freedom from pain
Global impact on disability. to be completed at the end of trial period, an average of 12 weeks Global impact on disability. Global impact on disability and Quality of life
Impact on migraine associated symptoms To be measured at 10 mins, 1 hour, 2 hours, 24 hours Impact on migraine associated symptoms:
Nausea Photophobia PhonophobiaComparison of symptoms scores between pre intervention data collection period and treatment with the intervention. to be completed at the end of trial period, an average of 12 weeks Comparison of symptoms scores between pre intervention data collection period and treatment with the intervention.
* Headache severity Severe/moderate - mild/none
* VAS score (0-10 pain scale \& Symptom severity)Adverse events From day one of the intervention period until 48 hours post 2nd trial treatment Adverse events noted throughout the treatment phase and during follow up
Trial Locations
- Locations (3)
The James Cook University Hospital, South Tees Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust
🇬🇧Middlesborough, United Kingdom
CITY HOSPITALS SUNDERLAND NHS FOUNDATION TRUST, 11 Norfolk Street, Sunderland SR1 1EA
🇬🇧Sunderland, Tyne and Wear, United Kingdom
Neurosciences department, Penrith Hospital, Cumbria Partnership NHS Foundation Trust
🇬🇧Penrith, Cumbria, United Kingdom