Real-Time fMRI Feedback Effects on Pain Perception

Not Applicable

Completed

Conditions: Cognitive Pain Control

Interventions: Behavioral: Attention/Distraction Strategy
Behavioral: Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy
Behavioral: Control Strategy

Registration Number: NCT01588197

Lead Sponsor: Medical University of South Carolina

Brief Summary: The purpose of this study is to determine whether real-time functional magnetic resonance imaging may be a viable treatment for chronic pain in the future.

Detailed Description: Twenty-four healthy volunteers will undergo a series of four fMRI scanning sessions wherein thermal pain stimuli will be used to elicit activation of the pain neuro-matrix. All participants will undergo thermal pain threshold testing before and after fMRI scan. Participants will also rate the painfulness and unpleasantness of the thermal stimuli applied before fMRI and after fMRI. All participants will be given prompts to apply a set of cognitive pain-control strategies. Half of the participants will receive real-time fMRI feedback of activity in the Right Anterior Cingulate Cortex (rACC) and the other half will receive real-time fMRI feedback of activity in the Prefrontal Cortex (PFC). It is hypothesized that those receiving real-time feedback of brain activity thought to be involved with analgesic effects will demonstrate greater analgesia associated with the application of the cognitive control techniques after fMRI paradigm (decreased pain intensity and unpleasantness ratings and increased thermal pain thresholds) than those who are not given feedback before fMRI paradigm.

Recruitment & Eligibility

Status: COMPLETED

Sex: All

Target Recruitment: 20

Inclusion Criteria

Healthy adults ages 18-65

Exclusion Criteria

Clinical depression
Anxiety
Substance dependence or chronic pain
Ferrous metal implants
Cardiac pacemakers or other implanted medical devices that might be adversely impacted by the MRI scanner magnetic field

Study & Design

Study Type: INTERVENTIONAL

Study Design: PARALLEL

Arm && Interventions

Group	Intervention	Description
PFC Real Time fMRI Feedback	Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy	Each participant will undergo thermal pain threshold assessments ten times using the Medoc Pathway System with MRI-compatible ATS Thermode (30mmX30mm; Medoc Inc, Israel). Participants will be instructed to "focus on the thermal stimuli" for the first 5 trials, and to engage in three cognitive pain inhibition strategies (Attention/Distraction Strategy, Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy, and the Control Strategy. The participants will be randomly assigned to receive Real Time fMRI Feedback of inverse activation in the PFC after each pain/rest block during the last 3 fMRI scans in the form of two simple thermometer images on the in-scanner computer display.
ACC Real Time fMRI Feedback	Attention/Distraction Strategy	Each participant will undergo thermal pain threshold assessments ten times using the Medoc Pathway System with MRI-compatible ATS Thermode (30mmX30mm; Medoc Inc, Israel). Participants will be instructed to "focus on the thermal stimuli" for the first 5 trials, and to engage in three cognitive pain inhibition strategies (Attention/Distraction Strategy, Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy, and the Control Strategy. The participants will be randomly assigned to receive Real Time fMRI Feedback of inverse activation in the rACC after each pain/rest block during the last 3 fMRI scans in the form of two simple thermometer images on the in-scanner computer display.
ACC Real Time fMRI Feedback	Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy	Each participant will undergo thermal pain threshold assessments ten times using the Medoc Pathway System with MRI-compatible ATS Thermode (30mmX30mm; Medoc Inc, Israel). Participants will be instructed to "focus on the thermal stimuli" for the first 5 trials, and to engage in three cognitive pain inhibition strategies (Attention/Distraction Strategy, Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy, and the Control Strategy. The participants will be randomly assigned to receive Real Time fMRI Feedback of inverse activation in the rACC after each pain/rest block during the last 3 fMRI scans in the form of two simple thermometer images on the in-scanner computer display.
PFC Real Time fMRI Feedback	Attention/Distraction Strategy	Each participant will undergo thermal pain threshold assessments ten times using the Medoc Pathway System with MRI-compatible ATS Thermode (30mmX30mm; Medoc Inc, Israel). Participants will be instructed to "focus on the thermal stimuli" for the first 5 trials, and to engage in three cognitive pain inhibition strategies (Attention/Distraction Strategy, Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy, and the Control Strategy. The participants will be randomly assigned to receive Real Time fMRI Feedback of inverse activation in the PFC after each pain/rest block during the last 3 fMRI scans in the form of two simple thermometer images on the in-scanner computer display.
PFC Real Time fMRI Feedback	Control Strategy	Each participant will undergo thermal pain threshold assessments ten times using the Medoc Pathway System with MRI-compatible ATS Thermode (30mmX30mm; Medoc Inc, Israel). Participants will be instructed to "focus on the thermal stimuli" for the first 5 trials, and to engage in three cognitive pain inhibition strategies (Attention/Distraction Strategy, Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy, and the Control Strategy. The participants will be randomly assigned to receive Real Time fMRI Feedback of inverse activation in the PFC after each pain/rest block during the last 3 fMRI scans in the form of two simple thermometer images on the in-scanner computer display.
ACC Real Time fMRI Feedback	Control Strategy	Each participant will undergo thermal pain threshold assessments ten times using the Medoc Pathway System with MRI-compatible ATS Thermode (30mmX30mm; Medoc Inc, Israel). Participants will be instructed to "focus on the thermal stimuli" for the first 5 trials, and to engage in three cognitive pain inhibition strategies (Attention/Distraction Strategy, Stimulus Quality/Severity Strategy, and the Control Strategy. The participants will be randomly assigned to receive Real Time fMRI Feedback of inverse activation in the rACC after each pain/rest block during the last 3 fMRI scans in the form of two simple thermometer images on the in-scanner computer display.

Primary Outcome Measures

Name	Time	Method
Average Pain Rating	Before and After fMRI Paradigm, an average of 2 hours	All participants will undergo thermal pain threshold testing directly before (Baseline) and after MRI scan.Participants will be asked to rate painfulness of the thermal stimuli applied, on a scale of 0-10, before the fMRI Paradigm (Baseline) and directly after the fMRI paradigm (after MRI). 0="no pain" and 10="worst pain imaginable"
Average Unpleasantness	Before and After fMRI Paradigm, an average of 2 hours	All participants will undergo thermal pain threshold testing directly before (Baseline) and after MRI. Participants will be asked to rate pain unpleasantness, on a scale of 0-10, before the fMRI Paradigm (Baseline) and directly after the fMRI paradigm (after MRI). 0="no unpleasantness" and 10="worst unpleasantness imaginable"
Ability to Distract	Before and After fMRI Paradigm, an average of 2 hours	All participants will undergo thermal pain threshold testing before and after fMRI paradigm. Participants will rate the ability to distract themselves from the thermal stimuli, on a scale of 0-10, before fMRI paradigm (Baseline) and after fMRI paradigm, 0="not able to distract at all" and 10="completely able to distract". A Higher rating represents greater ability to distract from thermal pain stimuli.